Renae and Jeremiah work through the mess of emotions that is the Matt James Bachelor season, episode 5. We discover the superiority of seasonal Reese's candies, while Jeremiah takes a stand against all desserts and Renae finally admits she's wrong for once. All the important details of the Chuck E. Cheese murder maze is uncovered, Thumbgate 2021 is heralded, and the hosts hold back their digested dinners with the thought of the inevitable Senior Bachelor season.