Andrew and Mike have to deal with two incompetent doppelgangers who don’t understand how to properly start the episode and then want to talk about Star Trek!  Once that’s all sorted, Andrew nitpicks endlessly and discusses the use of empty cups in Hollywood while Mike works on his best Joe Bob Briggs impersonation.

Sam and Dean are dealing with their own lookalike nuisance this week – a sewer dwelling shape shifter!  The Winchester brothers have to determine who-is-who while avoiding all the disgusting piles of discarded flesh being casually left lying around.  All this and even an unnecessary S.W.A.T. team on this week’s BAM!

Our friends will say stop whining, they’ve had enough of that...but there’s something about Bloody Mary, that they don’t know!  Mary.  There’s just something about Bloody Mary.  Mike and Andrew purchase a rather old suspicious mirror from the local antique store and then test its evil authenticity by playing all sorts of fun mirror-themed games like: Candyman, Bloody Mary, and Oh F*ck 7 Years Bad luck!

Meanwhile Sam Winchester and Dean Yamashiro are in Toledo, Ohio tracking down the eerie mirror-spirit named Bloody Mary!  Got a secret?  Well, don’t tell this Mary because you can’t count on her to keep a secret.  However, you can count on Bloody Mary interrupting your chemistry class and getting your blood pumping and your eyes bleeding!  Cover all reflective surfaces and check out this week’s episode!  BAM!

A ghost…on a plane?  Surely you can’t be serious?  Mike and Andrew argue about who gets the first-class aisle seat on Spooky Airlines. The loser has to sit at the back of the plane where everybody is wrestling and speaking Latin.  Once the plane lands Andrew is off to design exciting theme music for the podcast and Mike gets browbeat by his wife for his pathetic knowledge of airplanes.

Sam and Dean are also taking to the skies as they deal with an angry spirit who wants to crash airplanes and leave no survivors.  It’s a harrowing flight as the brothers have only 40 minutes to save the plane – and Dean’s afraid to fly!  So come fly with Burgers and Monsters!  Let’s fly, let’s fly away!

Cannonball!  Mike and Andrew plunge into the frigid lake waters of Vancouver for a rousing game of Marco Polo.  Mike tries to name-check the difference between Haley and Andrea while Andrew deep dives into an exhaustive frame-by-frame analysis of this episode’s high water mark – “Haley’s” bathtub attack!

Meanwhile Dean and Sam travel to Wisconsin to investigate a slew of swimmers who have been “drowning” in the local waters.  Turns out the land loving residents of the town now have more to fear as the angry water spirit has decided that pipes, toilets, and sinks are also fair game while it searches for its prey.  Perhaps cancelling the pool party would be a better decision for everyone on this week’s Burgers & Monsters!

What’s that inviting aroma drifting off the BBQ?  Is that Steve I smell?  Somebody pass me a big plate of Steve!  Andrew and Mike discuss fine cannibalistic cuisine, camping, and all the perils of things that can happen to us when we leave the safety of our home.  Of course, if we stay in our homes then there’s always the chance of a random squirrel incursion.

Naturally we’ll also get to Supernatural in our weekly discussion.  This time Sam and Dean head to Colorado the Wendigo Capital of...this episode.  The Winchester brothers battle the carnivorous creature in the deepest woods all while sporting their best blue jeans and biker boots!  Fun and food are being served here at Burgers & Monsters!

Mike & Andrew introduce themselves and then get introduced to Sam and Dean Winchester. That's right the SUPERNATURAL journey begins here as we review PILOT (Season 1, Episode 1).

It's up to Sam and Dean to get reacquainted with each other after several years apart as the monster-hunting brothers battle the absolutely gorgeous THE WOMAN IN WHITE! Trust us, she's got Mike's full attention while Andrew is busy learning the ins-and-outs of being a HUNTER!