By Order of The Faithfuls

Wells and 3x Survivor player, Jonathan Penner are discussing one of the most controversial Survivor episodes to date… Some fans have called it the worst episode EVER. What do we think?

Who isn’t getting a “winner’s edit”, according to Jonathan? What unsuspecting players does he think will make it to the end? Was the advantage this episode simply unfair?

Plus, how long does it actually take for Jeff to go “read the votes” at tribal?! What is the audience not seeing?

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Jonathan Penner, 3x Survivor player and longtime fan favorite, is joining Wells this week to talk Old Era vs. New Era, the secret to success in this game, and whether or not he received a call for season 50!

Jonathan reveals WHY the New Era is actually more difficult, despite popular opinion. 

Plus, he spills his methods of *trying* to prepare for the show back in the day (which may have included bootleg DVD’s)…

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

For the first time, Dolores was fine with a player crying on the show! Is it because she has a soft spot for this person or is Survivor finally cracking her “black heart”?!

Wells thinks the women are dominating this game! With Coach finally gone, will the men be able to turn things around? 

Plus, Dolores wanted to see a “Lady and the Tramp” moment between two players… Was there chemistry there?! 

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Wells is back with Rob Cesternino to recap episode 7 of Survivor 50! As a seasoned Survivor player and long-time fan, Rob shares his thoughts on this week’s big players…

They’re getting into the “Coach” of it all. After watching him on multiple seasons, Rob predicts whether or not his reign will be coming to an end.

Plus, how is Emily’s unhinged gameplay working out in her favor? What player is currently in the best position? Is Billie Eilish actually a Survivor fan?! 

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Wells is joined by legendary gamer, Rob Cesternino, to talk all things Survivor AND Traitors…

When Rob got the call for Survivor 50, what was his response?! What does he have to say about his short-lived time on The Traitors? Is there a chance we could see him back on either show?

Plus, Rob tells us how he was first recruited onto Survivor back in 2002, how he compares New Era to Old Era, and who he’s rooting for in season 50.

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Wells and Dolores are getting whiplash from all of the twists this episode! What was more shocking: the merge, the three eliminations OR the idea that there’s an Applebee’s in Fiji?

Dolores’ ideal reward would consist of soap, shampoo and Cirie’s eyelash tech’s info. How are those things still hanging on?!

Plus, Wells wonders if Christian is actually that entertaining in real life or if it’s all a ruse for television…

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Kim Spradlin Wolfe is back to recap episode 5 of Survivor with Dolores and Wells. This is her first time watching the show in 10 seasons… Is she pleasantly surprised or a bit underwhelmed?!

With two blindsides in one episode, Kim tells us exactly what “Survivor PTSD” looks like. Whether from gameplay, fatigue or simply not eating, she gives us some BTS knowledge that officially turns Dolores off from ever doing this game.

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Kim Spradlin Wolfe, one of the all-time favorite winners in Survivor history, is joining Wells and Dolores to relive her time on the show. Even though she’s a legend to us, apparently her kids don’t find her Survivor performance as commendable… 

Plus, she didn’t get the call for Season 50, but did she want to go back in the first place?! What does she think separates a good Survivor player from a GREAT Survivor player? What was the best life lesson she learned from this game?

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Wells and Dolores are recapping this week’s episode alongside Survivor 49 runner-up, Sophi Balerdi! 

Does Ozzy care more about the game or a shot at a White Lotus cameo?! Was Christian’s move to pick Emily “Flip Flop” over “Machiavellian Mike” a good idea? Will Vatu’s losing streak be over any time soon?

Plus, what did everyone think about this week’s celebrity guest? In a season with so many icons, do celebs need to be added to the mix too?

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Wells and Dolores are joined by Survivor 49 runner-up, Sophi Balerdi! As the fan-favorite underdog, Sophi’s telling them what inspired her to apply for Survivor, how long it took to secure her spot & what it was like to go 11 days without food.

By not betraying her alliance, Sophi lost out on the $1M prize… Is that friendship worth the loss?! How did her gameplay differ from how she originally planned to play? Looking back, what would she change?

 

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.