California in Depth

California in Depth

By CivicFMGovernment
Download on the App Store

All California in Depth episodes

  • Why cities are pausing new data centers, and what comes next

    San Francisco, Oakland and San Diego have paused new data centers. Los Angeles County's supervisors referred a motion to have planners draft a ban on large-scale data centers back to its sponsor with no action, San Jose and Burbank have rules or reports in the works, and Pasadena's Planning Commission has a public hearing on data centers set for November 18. Why are they pausing or tightening the rules, and what happens next?

    Pasadena · Legislative Policy Committee, Monday, September 28 · Pasadena's episode

    • State legislative briefing (00:49:18)
      • The city's state legislative advocate said the governor vetoed AB 1383, a costly bill on public safety pensions, and that it's expected back next year (00:49:52)
      • The city's state legislative advocate said new state law bars cities from permitting a data center until it has submitted a water supply plan (00:51:24)
      • The city's state legislative advocate said new wildfire laws double the mortgage forbearance window for LA fire survivors from 12 to 24 months (00:52:44)
      • The city's state legislative advocate said nothing in state law stops the city from regulating data centers on energy or land use (01:00:05)
      • A committee member said the Planning Commission held a study session on data centers in July, and supported some kind of ban or restriction (01:02:34)
      • The committee chair asked staff for a report on the new federal and state laws and whether the city needs its own legislation (01:04:30)
      • Documents: 2026-09-28 Legislative Policy Committee Special Meeting Agenda Notice

        LA County · Board of Supervisors, Tuesday, October 6 · LA County's episode

        • Data center zoning motion referred back to sponsor (00:15:07)
          • The clerk announced that Hilda Solis (Supervisor, First District; Chair) asked for the item to be referred back to her office. (00:15:07)
          • Documents: Agenda, Supplemental, Agenda (assets-us-01.kc-usercontent.com)

            San Francisco · Board of Supervisors, Tuesday, October 6 · San Francisco's episode

            • 45-day citywide moratorium on data centers (00:17:43)
              • The clerk noted that state law requires a four-fifths vote, nine members, and that the urgency ordinance takes effect immediately if passed (00:17:43)
              • A speaker described the 45-day moratorium as an interim measure under state law to give the city time to study data centers' impacts (00:18:26)
              • A speaker listed energy, water, air quality, land use and community impacts as issues to study, along with a clearer definition of data centers (00:18:26)
              • A speaker said the ordinance pauses city approvals of data centers while the Board and Planning develop long-term rules (00:18:26)
              • A speaker explained that Planning must report to the Clerk within 25 days, with a hearing on the report within 35 days of the ordinance taking effect (00:19:29)
              • A speaker thanked co-sponsors Connie Chan (Supervisor, District 1), Jackie Fielder (Supervisor, District 9) and Chyanne Chen (Supervisor, District 11) (00:19:29)
              • Documents: Agenda

                Burbank · City Council, Tuesday, October 13 · Burbank's episode

                • State legislative update from the city's lobbyists (00:29:54)
                  • A speaker flagged two data-center bills requiring water assessments before any data-center permit, which the firm said are the main ones affecting local agencies (00:32:25)
                  • A speaker said she understood council would get an early staff report on data centers in December (00:33:25)
                  • A speaker noted a new law that changes the deadline for answering public records requests from ten days to ten business days (00:38:17)
                  • A speaker said a pension bill letting safety officers retire at 55 failed but is expected back in January (00:38:17)
                  • A speaker reported the city took positions on 28 bills and the final result matched the city's position 61% of the time (00:39:19)
                  • A speaker said the state budget includes $1.2 million for the Burbank Reservoir and for storage of firefighter protective equipment (00:41:22)
                  • Konstantine Anthony (Council Member) asked whether any other state tax credit program is uncapped, in light of the attorney general's push to uncap the film and TV tax credit (00:46:17)
                  • A speaker asked which legislator might carry a bill to expand the film tax credit (00:47:03)
                  • Zizette Mullins (Council Member; Vice Mayor) asked whether the state has done anything about high utility costs for consumers (00:48:37)
                  • A council member asked whether the police department had been briefed on the new state e-bike definitions (00:51:17)
                  • Documents: Agenda

                    Oakland · Rules and Legislation Committee, Thursday, October 22 · Oakland's episode

                    • Scheduling the data center moratorium report and proposed extension (00:06:24)
                      • The city clerk read the reason for skipping committee review: state law requires the council to hear a written report 35 days after the moratorium was adopted, and the report would let the council consider an extension (00:07:28)
                      • The city clerk stated that to meet state deadlines, the item must be on the November 10 council agenda as a public hearing (00:08:34)
                      • Documents: Agenda

                        San Jose · Planning Commission, Friday, October 23 · San Jose's episode

                        • Data centers: background ahead of proposed city standards (01:33:05)
                          • City staff said the standards will come before the commission on November 18, so this session would not present them (01:33:05)
                          • City staff said data centers are already allowed with a special use permit in four industrial and commercial zoning districts, which limits what the city can require (01:35:08)
                          • City staff said the California Energy Commission leads environmental review when backup generation exceeds 50 megawatts (01:36:11)
                          • City staff estimated a 99-megawatt data center brings about $6 million a year in utility user tax (01:39:20)
                          • City staff estimated annual property tax at $500,000 to $1 million for a 99-megawatt data center (01:40:22)
                          • City staff said one-time construction tax is likely closer to $17 million, and a commercial linkage fee and an energy programs fee are being proposed (01:40:22)
                          • City staff said the proposal caps backup generators at 25 hours a year with Tier 4 certification, versus the air district's 50 hours (01:43:17)
                          • City staff said the city's proposed requirements add to state CEQA standards even when the state leads the review (01:44:42)
                          • City staff said council directed the standards in a May rules memo voted in June, and an August memo added community benefits, tax revenue and design (01:45:28)
                          • City staff said the proposal sends all appeals of data center special use permits from the director's hearing to the City Council, bypassing the commission (01:48:49)
                          • A commissioner objected that removing the commission takes away a chance for residents to give input, noting community concern and moratoriums elsewhere (01:53:04)
                          • City staff said the appeal change responds to residents who want controversial data center decisions made by the council (01:53:20)
                          • City staff said council directed staff to develop standards, not a moratorium, and that choice rests with the council (01:56:12)
                          • A commissioner relayed residents' reports that no council members attend the data center listening sessions (01:57:05)
                          • City staff said the full package goes to the commission and then to the City Council on December 8, with materials public November 10 (02:02:17)
                          • City staff said a draft at roughly 80% was presented at a community meeting last week (02:01:08)
                          • City staff said the last community meeting drew over 300 people (02:06:25)
                          • City staff said remaining input opportunities include the Youth Commission on October 26 and an online comment form (02:05:24)
                          • A commissioner praised staff outreach and said he would rather see data centers in San Jose than elsewhere, with safeguards (02:08:53)
                          • City staff estimated about 20 data centers operate in the city, mostly much smaller than the 99-megawatt ones now proposed (02:10:32)
                          • City staff said many projects cap at 99 megawatts to stay under the Energy Commission's small power plant exemption (02:11:24)
                          • City staff said the standards are not streamlining, citing limits on cooling systems and generator hours (02:13:58)
                          • City staff said Santa Clara has so many data centers because its utility costs are lower than neighboring cities (02:14:38)
                          • Public comment (02:14:49)
                            • A commissioner thanked the speaker and invited them to attend the November hearing (02:17:42)
                            • Documents: Agenda

                              San Diego · City Council, Tuesday, October 27 · San Diego's episode

                              • Emergency 45-day moratorium on new data centers (00:42:48)
                                • The mayor's office said the municipal code doesn't define data centers, which are permitted today under rules written for telecom switching stations (00:44:35)
                                • The mayor's office explained the ordinance would set a 45-day moratorium within the city's jurisdiction while rules are written (00:44:35)
                                • The mayor's office acknowledged the moratorium does not settle what happens on the federally owned Navy site and said the city's government affairs team would press Sacramento and Washington (00:45:36)
                                • City staff explained the ordinance takes effect immediately with a four-fifths vote and lasts 45 days, with a possible extension after another noticed hearing (00:47:41)
                                • City staff noted the city has no land use authority over the federal NAVWAR site but said the proposal there shows how immediate the interest in large data centers is (00:50:53)
                                • City staff listed exemptions, starting with accessory server rooms that serve only on-site operations (00:54:04)
                                • City staff said the mayor signed an executive order last Thursday creating a stakeholder working group, whose input will shape Land Development Code amendments returning to council next year (00:55:05)
                                • A councilmember allowed public comment on both the moratorium and the proposal on federal land, calling the federal proposal a separate matter (00:56:55)
                                • A councilmember reminded members the emergency action needs eight yes votes, which is why it was moved from Monday (02:20:08)
                                • City staff explained state law allows 45 days at first, then an extension of up to 10 months and 15 days, then another of up to a year (02:21:22)
                                • A councilmember cited a Voice of San Diego report that a developer was exploring a 400-megawatt data center at the Navy site and called on the congressional delegation to stop it (02:23:49)
                                • A councilmember asked staff about the ordinance's statement that industry representatives were interested in standalone data centers and vacant office space (02:23:49)
                                • City staff answered that staff was mainly citing newspaper reports on the Navy site and possible downtown sites in empty buildings (02:24:27)
                                • The mayor's office said the working group is still being formed and would include labor, community advocates, utility, water, housing, technology, environmental and higher education representatives (02:26:47)
                                • A councilmember objected to including SDG&E in the working group and suggested San Diego Community Power instead (02:27:19)
                                • A councilmember moved the item with added direction, including that staff notify the council within seven days of any inquiry from a prospective data center developer (02:28:34)
                                • A councilmember proposed principles for the permanent policy: no by-right approval, approval only if housing isn't feasible on the site, all-renewable power, no fossil fuel backup, and recycled water for cooling (02:28:34)
                                • A councilmember also asked for working group progress updates, the first within 45 days, and for the Office of Government Affairs to lobby against a large data center at NAVWAR (02:29:35)
                                • A councilmember asked the city attorneys to confirm the added direction wouldn't compromise the moratorium's legal requirements (02:30:26)
                                • A councilmember said he requested legal research on regulating data centers in early August and had been preparing a policy for his committee (02:31:20)
                                • A councilmember described the Navy site proposal as a hyperscale campus of 400 to 500 megawatts, far larger than typical data centers (02:32:22)
                                • A councilmember argued families and small businesses should not pay for data centers' water, power and infrastructure, and cited a recent papal encyclical on concentrated technological power (02:34:36)
                                • A councilmember warned some members might need to leave by 1 p.m. and the item needed eight yes votes (02:36:21)
                                • A councilmember said he was confident the council would extend the moratorium for the following ten and a half months (02:38:09)
                                • A councilmember argued the Navy site, next to the Old Town Amtrak station and transit center, should be used for housing, including for service members (02:38:09)
                                • A councilmember called the Navy site a once-in-a-generation opportunity for housing and transit-oriented development (02:40:16)
                                • A councilmember asked whether the city, not an applicant, decides if a project qualifies for an exemption, and staff confirmed it does (02:41:18)
                                • A councilmember said data centers must cover their own electricity and water costs and create good jobs for local skilled workers, and that she would vote yes (02:42:04)
                                • A councilmember said he supports making things harder for data centers, as speakers urged, but that it will take time to make the required findings (02:44:31)
                                • A councilmember called for studying the leverage the city has through its utility franchise agreement and its role in community power (02:45:32)
                                • A councilmember warned the NAVWAR developer that if the data center proposal is a stalking horse for another agenda, there would be a price to pay (02:45:32)
                                • An attorney for the city clarified for the record that the amendments are part of the motion but won't be written into the ordinance (02:47:08)
                                • City staff said staff had no concerns with the added direction but would look into some items and report back (02:47:29)
                                • Documents: Agenda

                                  Pasadena · Planning Commission, Wednesday, October 28 · Pasadena's episode

                                  • Staff report: one November meeting (02:00:27)
                                    • City staff announced a single November meeting on Wednesday, November 18 (02:01:05)
                                    • City staff listed a study session on safe parking among the items for that meeting (02:01:05)
                                    • Documents: Agenda

                                      San Francisco · Board of Supervisors, Tuesday, October 27 · San Francisco's episode

                                      • Introductions resumed: data center moratorium extension, street trees, AI pension risk, election integrity (01:37:08)
                                        • A supervisor introduced a ten-month, fifteen-day extension of the interim data center moratorium (01:37:25)
                                        • A supervisor argued data centers can place heavy demands on the electrical grid and differ from other commercial development (01:37:25)
                                        • A supervisor pointed to moratoriums adopted by other Bay Area cities, including Richmond and Oakland (01:38:27)
                                        • A supervisor said the board will review the Planning Department's November 10 report and keep working toward stronger regulations (01:40:31)
                                        • A supervisor said Public Works committed at a committee hearing to finish the first pruning cycle by year's end and move to about 25,000 prunings a year (01:41:29)
                                        • A supervisor said the street tree resolution asks for a six-month progress update (01:41:29)
                                        • A supervisor introduced a resolution urging the city and state public employee pension systems to review concentrated and correlated risks from AI investments (01:42:53)
                                        • A supervisor argued taxpayers should not bail out private companies if inflated AI valuations collapse (01:44:02)
                                        • A supervisor introduced a resolution affirming election integrity, supporting election workers and opposing intimidation of election officials and voters (01:45:18)
                                        • Documents: Agenda

                                          This episode is made with AI from each government's own show, which reports from the public recordings of its meetings. Sources are in the show notes.

                                          Report an error · This episode's page

                                          6 min