Today, your book besties are diving headfirst into The Housemaid by Freida McFadden for an in-depth, spoiler-filled buddy read discussion. If you’ve read the book, seen the movie, or are just here for the opinions… buckle up.

Kat and Amanda talk first impressions, rereading versus first-time reactions, and why The Housemaid works so well as a fast, entertaining thriller- even when some of the twists start to feel predictable. We unpack the book’s shock value, pacing, and what changes when you already know what’s coming, especially when comparing the reading experience to the film adaptation.

The conversation quickly turns to book-to-movie translation issues, including inner monologue loss, perspective shifts, and why certain character motivations feel clearer on the page than on screen. We get into the moral gray areas of Nina’s choices, the question of whether Millie was truly “set up,” and why that interpretation matters more than it initially seems.

Of course, we also spiral into character analysis- Cece’s behavior, Andrew’s deeply unsettling presence, Enzo’s suspicious language choices, and the lingering questions the book leaves behind. Then things get extra opinionated as we discuss casting and costuming decisions, what the movie gets wrong visually, and why “frumpy” does not mean what Hollywood thinks it means.

If you enjoy thrillers, strong reactions, adaptation debates, and bestie-level overthinking, this episode is for you.

💙📚

Want to join our book club? Sign up for our newsletter to stay in the loop. You can signup here

Can I Bring My Book Social Links:

In today’s episode, your book besties are officially closing out their 2025 reading year with a full recap, a sportsballs-legit bookish bracket, and the ultimate question: what was our best read of the year?

Kat goes first, walking through her favorite read from each month, explaining how her wild cards came into play, and narrowing everything down to one standout winner. Amanda follows with her own month-by-month picks, reflecting on romantasy binges, audiobook obsessions, and the book that ultimately stole her heart this year.

Along the way, we talk about reading patterns, surprise favorites, tough eliminations, and why seeing your year laid out in a bracket can change how you think about what you’ve read.

Below are our 2025 reads, separated by bestie... 

Monthly Picks

January: Margot’s Got Money Troubles by Rufi Thorpe

February: A Psalm for the Wild-Built by Becky Chambers

March: Food for Thought by Alton Brown

April: Heir by Sabaa Tahir

May: The Poet X by Elizabeth Acevedo

June: This Is How You Lose the Time War by Amal El-Mohtar and Max Gladstone

July: The Book of Doors by Gareth Brown

August: Leather & Lark by Brynne Weaver

September: Other Birds by Sarah Addison Allen

October: Bury Our Bones in the Midnight Soil by V. E. Schwab

November: The Day Tripper by James Goodhand

December: The Everlasting by Alix E. Harrow

Wild Cards

The Third Gilmore Girl by Kelly Bishop

Water Moon by Samantha Sotto Yambao

Atmosphere by Taylor Jenkins Reid

The Spellshop by Sarah Beth Durst

Kat’s overall favorite of 2025:

Monthly Picks

January: Fourth Wing by Rebecca Yarros

February: Onyx Storm by Rebecca Yarros

March: Women Don’t Owe You Pretty by Florence Given

April: A Walk in the Woods by Bill Bryson

May: The Perfect Marriage by Jeneva Rose

June: Lights Out by Navessa Allen

July: Atmosphere by Taylor Jenkins Reid

August: One True Loves by Taylor Jenkins Reid

September: Say You’ll Remember Me by Abby Jimenez

October: Butcher and Blackbird by Brynne Weaver

November: Yours Truly by Abby Jimenez

December: The Housemaid by Freida McFadden

Wild Cards

A Little Life by Hanya Yanagihara

A Psalm for the Wild-Built by Becky Chambers

Assistant to the Villain by Hannah Nicole Maehrer

The Spellshop by Sarah Beth Durst

Amanda’s overall favorite of 2025:

💙📚

Want to join our book club? Sign up for our newsletter to stay in the loop. You can signup here

Can I Bring My Book Social Links:

Join your besties as we dive deep into Brimstone by Callie Hart- the much-anticipated second book following Quicksilver- 

Kat and Amanda unpack what worked, what didn’t, and why Brimstone feels both more enjoyable and more exhausting than its predecessor. We talk overhype, sequel expectations, and the growing trend of sprawling romantasy worlds that might be doing a little too much. Vampires, infected vampires, gods, the underworld, dragons, shifting identities, surprise villains, and unresolved plotlines all enter the chat- sometimes all at once.

The conversation spirals into pacing issues, emotional fatigue, and whether reader demand (hello, BookTok) is pushing publishers to rush books out before they’re fully ready. We get candid about editing, publishing pressure, typos, ARC feedback, and what it means when a sequel feels like it needed more time to breathe.

Of course, no buddy read episode would be complete without friendly arguments — including whether this series has ever been a slow burn, which characters deserve more page time, and why the emotional weight landed hardest… for a fox.

If you love romantasy, have strong opinions about sequels, or have ever thought, “Maybe this book needed one less plot thread,” this episode is for you.

Want to join our book club? Sign up for our newsletter to stay in the loop. You can signup here

Can I Bring My Book Social Links:

This week’s episode is a full-on Bestie Book Swap chaos round, which means we’re attempting to discuss four different books, half-forgetting what we read, questioning past decisions, and absolutely spiraling along the way. You know… a normal episode.

Kat and Amanda kick things off by revisiting their November swaps (or, was it October...?!): Cinder by Marissa Meyer and The Last Letter by Rebecca Yarros. We talk fairy tale retellings, YA vs. adult reading preferences, overthrowing governments (as one does), and why Amanda has some beef with Cinderella. Then things take an emotional turn as we unpack The Last Letter—from early tears to multiple endings and the very strong opinion that maybe… just maybe… one ending would have been enough.

Next up, December’s swaps bring Kiss of the Basilisk by Lindsay Straube (formerly Split or Swallow) and Remarkably Bright Creatures by Shelby Van Pelt into the mix—two books that could not be more different if they tried. We debate excessive smut, questionable character choices, medieval Bachelor vibes, and whether a book can be both wildly popular and wildly exhausting. On the flip side, we gush about octopus POVs, found family, gentle magic, and the kind of story that makes you almost cry but in the best way possible.

We wrap things up by assigning the next round of swaps- including one book chosen purely for selfish “I need to talk about this immediately” reasons- and tease what’s coming next in our ever-growing reading chaos.

Want to join our book club? Sign up for our newsletter to stay in the loop. You can signup here

Can I Bring My Book Social Links:

This week’s episode was supposed to be our buddy read chat for Wicked… but after attempting both the book and the movie, your book besties made a joint executive decision: we’re tapping OUT. 😂

In this episode, Kat and Amanda share their brutally honest (but still very us) thoughts on Wicked- from confusing worldbuilding to audiobook woes to the shock of discovering that the Broadway sensation is only loosely connected to its source material. We talk DNF guilt, hype that doesn’t land, and why sometimes sitting in silence is better than forcing yourself through a book you’re not vibing with.

Then we pivot into a surprisingly thoughtful conversation sparked by a viral TikTok!

In this episode, sprayed edges, Barnes & Noble avoidance strategies, holiday shopping trauma, and chaotic bestie problem-solving all make an appearance.

It’s a candid, cozy, slightly unhinged chat- aka exactly what you expect from us.

Want to join our book club? Sign up for our newsletter to stay in the loop. You can signup here

Can I Bring My Book Social Links:

In today’s episode, your book besties go full chaos gremlin. Inspired by a random car conversation, we attempt the impossible: take the most popular romance tropes… and flip them.

What starts as “simple enough” spirals quickly into:

It’s messy. It’s unhinged. It’s creative chaos. And it’s exactly why you tune in.

We may or may not have created the blueprint for a bestselling novel- or at least the world’s strangest writer’s room.

Stick around for technical difficulties, accidental tangents, and the moment we realize we were definitely supposed to be taking notes.

Thanks for joining us on this wild trope-flipping adventure. And if you end up writing a book using our ideas… just remember: you owe us money. (Kat said it. It’s legally binding now.)

Want to join our book club? Sign up for our newsletter to stay in the loop. You can signup here

Can I Bring My Book Social Links:

This week, your book besties are diving straight into the world of book-to-movie adaptations- the good, the bad, the chaotic, and the ones we’ll absolutely watch even if we haven’t read the book (yet).

From The Housemaid and The Running Man to Wicked, Frankenstein, People We Meet on Vacation, Project Hail Mary, and even The Odyssey (yes… Nolan’s doing The Odyssey), Kat and Amanda are talking upcoming releases, which ones they plan to read first, and which movies they’ll watch without a second thought.

We’re covering:

And of course… we wrap up with Trope Talk, where the rules are questionable, the arguments are petty, and the tropes? Well, we might be recycling them at this point.

Grab your popcorn (or your TBR cart). It’s adaptation season.

Want to join our book club? Sign up for our newsletter to stay in the loop. You can signup here

Can I Bring My Book Social Links:

Your book besties are back- snacks, spoilers, and all- for a full-on debrief of Tourist Season by Brynne Weaver. In this episode, Amanda and Kat dive deep into Harper and Nolan’s morally gray romance, dissect the connections to the Butcher and Blackbird universe, and debate just how many serial killers one world really needs.

Spoiler warning: If you haven’t read Tourist Season, go read it first — then come back and scream with us.

From raven research and questionable nipple-piercing logistics to emotional moments with Arthur (cue the tears), they cover it all- the spice, the chaos, and the “take me now, murder daddy” energy that only Brynne Weaver can deliver.

Expect laughs, tangents, trope talk, and a few serious questions- like, wait… was there even a hamburger scene? Grab your headphones and join the chaos as we unpack our latest buddy read!

Tropes discussed: enemies to lovers, forced proximity, touch-her-and-die, revenge arc, moral ambiguity, and dark humor.

Want to join our book club? Sign up for our newsletter to stay in the loop. You can signup here

Can I Bring My Book Social Links:

Your Book Besties Talk Body Piercings

It started with a random thought mid-read, and quickly spiraled into one of the most chaotic (and hilarious) tangents yet. This week, your book besties, Amanda and Kat, tackle a burning literary question: why do so many fictional men have body piercings… and is it actually realistic?

From the logistics (and pain!) of piercings in unexpected places to the rise of “book-inspired” tattoos and the possibility of “book-inspired” piercings, nothing is off-limits in this chat. Your besties debate whether hockey players can safely sport piercings on the ice, dive into Reddit rabbit holes, and somehow end up designing their ideal book boyfriends- complete with tattoos, cooking skills, and the occasional pierced… well, you’ll have to listen.

Come for the unfiltered laughs, stay for the book recs and the banter only Amanda and Kat can bring.

Want to join our book club? Sign up for our newsletter to stay in the loop. You can signup here

Can I Bring My Book Social Links:

In this episode, Amanda and Kat are talking Amazon's Scared Sexy collection of novellas. They can barely remember the details from one book... now six?! Yup! Cue the chaos! 

Want to check out these reads yourself? Click here

Want to join our book club? Sign up for our newsletter to stay in the loop. You can signup here

Can I Bring My Book Social Links: