Originally Aired: July 25, 1946
In Suspense #203, “Can’t We Be Friends,” Michael Gordon (Elliot Lewis) revisits his ex-girlfriend Fran to “make peace,” but rejection curdles into obsession and violence. What begins as a plea for forgiveness becomes a chilling confession of premeditated murder—only for fate to twist the knife one last time. When the police arrive, Michael learns his crime was pointless: Fran had died hours before he fired the gun. Written by and starring Elliot Lewis, this tense psychological study of guilt and delusion unfolds entirely through the killer’s narration, culminating in one of Suspense’s most darkly ironic finales.
Cast: 
Elliot Lewis, Lurene Tuttle, Wally Mayer, Jerry Hausner, Betty Moran, Ervin Lee, Bill Johnston
Tags: 
Suspense, thriller, psychological, noir, crime, ElliotLewis, LureneTuttle, obsession, guilt, irony, murder, radiohorror, oldtimeradio, 1940sradio, classicdrama, fatalmistake, suspensepodcast

Originally Aired: July 25, 1946 In Suspense #203, “Can’t We Be Friends,” Michael Gordon (Elliot Lewis) revisits his ex-girlfriend Fran to “make peace,” but rejection curdles into obsession and violence. What begins as a plea for forgiveness becomes a chilling confession of premeditated murder—only for fate to twist the knife one last time. When the police arrive, Michael learns his crime was pointless: Fran had died hours before he fired the gun. Written by and starring Elliot Lewis, this tense psychological study of guilt and delusion unfolds entirely through the killer’s narration, culminating in one of Suspense’s most darkly ironic finales. Cast: Elliot Lewis, Lurene Tuttle, Wally Mayer, Jerry Hausner, Betty Moran, Ervin Lee, Bill Johnston Tags: Suspense, thriller, psychological, noir, crime, ElliotLewis, LureneTuttle, obsession, guilt, irony, murder, radiohorror, oldtimeradio, 1940sradio, classicdrama, fatalmistake, suspensepodcast

Can’t We Be Friends: A Lover’s Alibi and a Death Too Late

Unravel the Mystery with Suspense! - The Classic Radio Thriller Series
Step back in time to the golden age of radio with ”Suspense!” - the iconic series that captivated audiences from 1942 to 1962 with its thrilling tales and unforgettable performances. Featuring over 900 broadcasts penned by renowned authors and directors, ”Suspense!” brought the finest in thriller and mystery genres to the airwaves.
Broadcast on the CBS Radio Network, ”Suspense!” showcased Hollywood’s brightest stars, including Cary Grant, Humphrey Bogart, Orson Welles, and Marlene Dietrich. Under the masterful direction of William Spier, known as the ”Hitchcock of the airwaves,” the series delivered gripping human dramas that kept listeners on the edge of their seats.
From the eerie introductions by the ”Man in Black” to the evocative scores by Bernard Hermann and Lucian Moraweck, ”Suspense!” was a paragon of radio production excellence. The show’s unique formula of minimal rehearsal and genuine unease created authe...

True Crime

Unravel the Mystery with Suspense! - The Classic Radio Thriller Series Step back in time to the golden age of radio with ”Suspense!” - the iconic series that captivated audiences from 1942 to 1962 with its thrilling tales and unforgettable performances. Featuring over 900 broadcasts penned by renowned authors and directors, ”Suspense!” brought the finest in thriller and mystery genres to the airwaves. Broadcast on the CBS Radio Network, ”Suspense!” showcased Hollywood’s brightest stars, including Cary Grant, Humphrey Bogart, Orson Welles, and Marlene Dietrich. Under the masterful direction of William Spier, known as the ”Hitchcock of the airwaves,” the series delivered gripping human dramas that kept listeners on the edge of their seats. From the eerie introductions by the ”Man in Black” to the evocative scores by Bernard Hermann and Lucian Moraweck, ”Suspense!” was a paragon of radio production excellence. The show’s unique formula of minimal rehearsal and genuine unease created authe...

Share Can’t We Be Friends: A Lover’s Alibi and a Death Too Late

Sign up to save your podcasts

Can’t We Be Friends: A Lover’s Alibi and a Death Too Late

Can’t We Be Friends: A Lover’s Alibi and a Death Too Late

More shows like Suspense - Radio’s Outstanding Theater of Thrills

Suspense OTR

The Great Detectives Present Yours Truly Johnny Dollar (Old Time Radio)

Old Time Radio Mystery, Suspense, & Horror

I Love Old Time Radio

Suspense | Old Time Radio

CBS Radio Mystery Theater | Old Time Radio

Choice Classic Radio Detectives | Old Time Radio

MrBallen Podcast: Strange, Dark & Mysterious Stories

Suspense! Old Time Radio Show!

Suspense