This week on the Marvelists spinoff Catholic Guilt, hosts Peter Melnick and Eddie Wilson kick things off with a little housekeeping: celebrating the official announcement that Wonder Man Season 2 is officially happening (Yahya Abdul-Mateen II and Ben Kingsley are coming back—yes, the bromance continues), geeking out over the brand-new Spider-Man: Brand New Day trailer that just dropped and is already breaking records, and sharing first impressions of the striking teaser poster for the upcoming Marvel Television Special Presentation The Punisher: One Last Kill (Jon Bernthal’s Frank Castle returns May 12 on Disney+—get ready).

Then it’s time to dive headfirst into the Man Without Fear’s long-awaited return. Peter and Eddie break down Daredevil: Born Again Season 2, Episode 1 – “The Northern Star,” where a hidden Matt Murdock takes the fight to the East River, infiltrating the cargo ship Northern Star to uncover and disrupt Wilson Fisk’s illegal weapons smuggling operation. From the tense stealth action aboard the vessel and the dramatic sinking that strikes a blow against Fisk’s regime, to the escalating political tensions in a post-martial-law Hell’s Kitchen and the fresh moral dilemmas that hit extra hard for our Catholic-raised crew, they unpack the season premiere’s high-stakes setup, Matt’s ongoing internal struggle, and how the stakes feel even higher this time around.

Expect plenty of Catholic guilt-fueled debates on justice versus power, classic Murdock self-flagellation, and the hosts wondering how Matt’s faith (or lack thereof) is going to hold up against Fisk’s authoritarian control and the shadows of his past. Plus, as always: spoilers, tangents, bad puns, and way too much enthusiasm for foggy New York rooftops and billy clubs.

New episode of Catholic Guilt drops now—grab your rosary and your nightstick, folks. Daredevil: Born Again Season 2 is back in session.