Hi, I’m Vansin.
Stablecoins are getting a lot of attention.
But when I started looking into them, I realized that different places are making very different rules about them.
The United States is creating a regulatory system for payment stablecoins.
Mainland China is taking a much more restrictive approach.
Hong Kong has created its own stablecoin regulatory framework.
So I started wondering:
“Why does everyone want to control stablecoins?”
Key Ideas
•Who can issue a stablecoin?
The U.S. GENIUS Act establishes rules for permitted payment stablecoin issuers and sets requirements for reserves, supervision, and disclosures.
This made me wonder whether stablecoins are more than just a new kind of technology.
If something can be used to make payments and hold value, who should be allowed to issue it?
•What is actually backing the stablecoin?
The GENIUS Act specifies categories of assets that can be used as reserves for permitted payment stablecoins, including certain forms of cash and short-term U.S. government securities.
This raised another question for me:
If stablecoin issuers hold U.S. government securities as reserves, could the growth of stablecoins also create more demand for U.S. government debt?
I think this is interesting, but I still want to learn more about how large this effect could actually be.
•Why can't payment stablecoins pay yield?
This was one of the things I found hardest to understand.
The law restricts payment stablecoins from paying yield or interest to holders.
I first wondered whether this might be connected to the risks that caused the 2008 financial crisis.
But I don’t have enough evidence to say that.
So for now, I’m treating that as a hypothesis, not a fact.
•Stablecoins and the digital yuan are not the same thing.
China’s digital yuan, or e-CNY, is issued by the People’s Bank of China and is a digital form of China’s legal currency.
That is different from a privately issued stablecoin.
So I started thinking that perhaps one of the most important questions isn’t simply:
“Is it digital money?”
It might be:
“Who is allowed to create it?”
•Why does jurisdiction matter?
Hong Kong has established a regulatory framework for stablecoin issuers and has begun licensing issuers of Hong Kong-dollar stablecoins.
But a Hong Kong regulatory framework does not automatically give Hong Kong the authority to decide the rules for every type of renminbi-linked stablecoin.
That made me think about something bigger:
If a digital asset is issued in one place, used somewhere else, and backed by assets held somewhere else—
“who gets to make the rules?”
My Reflection
When I started researching stablecoins, I thought I was learning about a new kind of cryptocurrency.
But the more I looked at different countries’ rules, the more I realized that I was really learning about something much older:
“money.”
I’m still not sure why every rule exists.
And I still have some hypotheses that I haven’t found enough evidence to prove.
But now I have a bigger question:
“If something starts working like money, who gets to decide whether it is money?”
Thinking Questions
1. Why do governments regulate stablecoins instead of simply banning or ignoring them?
2. What risks does a 1:1 reserve requirement actually reduce?
3. Why might a regulator want to prevent payment stablecoins from paying yield?
4. If a stablecoin is issued in one country and used in another, which country should regulate it?
5. Can a privately issued digital asset become “money” without becoming part of a country’s monetary system?
6. Who should get to decide what counts as money?
Keep Exploring
Read:
•The Future of Money
— Eswar S. Prasad
•Digital Gold: Bitcoin and the Inside Story of the Misfits and Millionaires Trying to Reinvent Money
— Nathaniel Popper
Watch:
•The future of money
— Neha Narula (TED)
Search:
Stablecoin, Regulation, Issuer, Reserve Asset, Jurisdiction, Legal Tender, E‑CNY, GENIUS Act, Digital Currency, Government Securities, Financial Rule
Keywords
Stablecoins, Stablecoin Regulation, GENIUS Act, Payment Stablecoins, E-CNY, Digital Yuan, Hong Kong Stablecoins, Financial Regulation, Digital Money, Cryptocurrency, Monetary Systems
中文導讀
這一集,我原本只是想了解:
「最近穩定幣到底發生了什麼?」
但在研究美國、中國大陸與香港的不同監管方式後,我開始發現,穩定幣可能不只是科技或加密資產的問題。
它還涉及:
誰可以發行?
什麼東西可以作為儲備呢?
誰來承擔風險?
誰有權制定規則?
當然,我也遇到了一些自己還沒有答案的問題。
例如,為什麼美國禁止支付型穩定幣向持有人支付收益?
香港的穩定幣制度又可能如何與更大的金融監管體系連結?
這些問題目前都不能只靠猜測回答。
而這也成為這一集裡我認為最重要的學習:
「有一個合理的解釋,不代表它已經是一個被證明的事實。」
最後,我開始問一個更大的問題:
如果某種東西開始像「錢」一樣運作,那麼,到底誰有權決定它是不是錢呢?
Sources
• U.S. GENIUS Act
• Congressional Research Service
• People’s Bank of China: Progress of Research & Development of E-CNY in China
• Hong Kong Monetary Authority
• People's Republic of China: Notice on Further Preventing and Handling Risks Related to Virtual Currencies
Note: This episode is developed with AI-assisted research and independently verified using public sources.
CBP Notes
Series:
CAW(Children Ask the World)
By Vansin • CBP
Children Ask the World is part of the ”Civilizational Bridge Project (CBP)”, an educational initiative by “Vansin Media”.
Each episode begins with a real question from a young learner. Rather than providing definitive answers, the project encourages evidence-based exploration, long-term thinking, and the habit of asking better questions.
The goal is not simply to learn more facts, but to better understand how the world works.
Disclaimer
This episode is an educational exploration, not financial, legal, or investment advice.
Regulatory frameworks can change, and listeners should consult the relevant primary legal and regulatory sources for current requirements.
Some ideas discussed in this episode are hypotheses or questions raised during the research process and should not be understood as established facts unless supported by the cited sources.
© Vansin Media. All rights reserved.
CBP is a youth-led initiative published under parent-managed editorial oversight.
Children Ask the World (CAW) is an original podcast series under the Civilizational Bridge Project (CBP).
This episode and its accompanying educational materials are intended to support curiosity-driven learning, critical thinking, and long-term cognitive development.
No part of these materials may be reproduced or redistributed without permission from Vansin Media.
This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit vansinmedia.substack.com