Big Idea -
Why is there suffering in this world? Why is life often so full of pain and hardship? How can a God who is all-loving and all-powerful allow evil in the world? These are tough questions, and for anyone who has really suffered, or who is in the midst of great trials and painful life circumstances, these are not just lofty philosophical questions. These become desperate cries from the heart about real-life hurt and injustice. Job is suffering from the loss of everything he had, including his own children, and he is in daily torment from a terrible skin disease with no relief (and no doctors to prescribe any number of modern-day treatments). Job's plight and his desperate question can be summed up in the well-known modern-day version that asks "Why do bad things happen to good people?" If God really is good, loving, and just it seems like a fair question. The Bible points toward the retribution principle - you reap what you sow. Do good get good, do bad get bad. But it doesn’t seem to work out that way. Is the principle wrong? When bad things happen to me, does it mean God is punishing me? When life gets really hard, or I have to suffer through painful things, it feels like God doesn't really love me, or that He doesn't really care. That is undoubtedly how Job felt. But is it true?
In Job 4-21, record two of the three speech cycles that make up the first half of the book. In each cycle, Job's friends each give one speech, and Job responds to each, one by one. The three friends probably represent different voices in society at the time - the traditionalist - we have always done it this way, the theologian - this is what the Bible says, and the practical guy - this is just how it works in life. They might be three different voices, but in the end, they are all three saying the same thing. They fully believe in the principle of sowing and reaping, and therefore, they see Job's suffering in this light. But, they have actually taken it one step further by affirming the opposite - if you are suffering, you must be wicked. It looks like Job is being punished. Therefore, he must have done something wrong. And given the extent of his suffering, it must have been really bad! We know this is not true because we got a peak behind the scenes, but from an earthly vantage point, it sure seems like Job is being punished for something. When bad things happen to us, we can meet with the same voices, either from our friends who think they are helping or from inside our own heads. Job's friends really do think they are helping. They want Job's suffering to stop. In their mind, the solution is simple - just admit your sin, make things right with God, and then God will restore your blessings. They represent the same charge the Challenger made - people only do what is right because God blesses them. But Job repeatedly responds that he is not guilty of any sin. What is more important, while his friends want to help Job by restoring his prosperity, Job is not interested in that. Instead, Job wants to be vindicated. That is, he wants to show that he is not guilty, and he does not care if he ever gets his fortune restored. He really does care only for righteousness for its own sake, and not for its benefits. So, Job proves that God is right and the Challenger is wrong - people can pursue righteousness for its own sake and not for personal gain. Job and his friends also differ on another point. They represent the accusation of the Challenger that God is subverting righteousness by the way He operates in the world. But, as Job holds on to his pure motives in doing what is right, he is forced to accuse God that He is not being truly just in the way He operates in the world. Because God is not treating Job according to the principle of sowing, God is being unjust. This comes much closer to the modern-day dilemma expressed in the phrase, "Why do bad things happen to good people?" It easily becomes an accusation that God is not just or fair in the way He runs the universe.
So, how are we to answer the question, "Why do bad things happen to good people?" How are we to respond when it feels like God is punishing us or doesn't care about us when bad things come into our lives? The speech cycles give us insight into the thinking of Job and his friends in order to point out serious flaws and errors in their thinking. The first error is that both Job and his friends ultimately see a world run by a system or policy rather than a person. The friends see the principle of sowing and reaping administered by justice alone. Job also wants this, but his own experience shows that is not how it works. His only conclusion is that God must not be just. But God does not run the world by policy alone. Any organization run by policy alone becomes inhuman. All become slaves to rules that never bend and cannot take into account individual human circumstances. It is heartless and empty. It is much better when a wise and loving person is leading. A person can bring wisdom, love, justice, and all the other good attributes of their character into play. God rules the universe, not by simplistic and narrow policy, but by bringing all his attributes to the table to wisely govern and rule for the ultimate good. We often do the same thing - seeking a system or policy that explains suffering and evil. Instead, we need to see that God is a person, and He rules over the world as a personal being with many attributes that work in harmony for His good and perfect purposes. Second, when we understand this, we see that God the principle of sowing and reaping is not a matter of God's justice but of grace. The problem was not with the sowing principle but that they turned into a merit system that completely removed God's grace and kindness. When it operates based on justice, everything turns into a commercial transaction - like buying groceries or a car. It is how the merit system works in Buddhism. Every deed or action must result in some kind of payoff of good or evil. In the triangle of tension, we must replace "justice" with grace. That means we God does bless us, but it is never based on earning it or having the right to His blessings. Rather, all is a gift of His grace and goodness. Third, When we replace "justice" with grace, it can appear that God works in the world in purely arbitrary and random ways. Some people randomly get good, others get evil. It can look like God is playing some kind of cosmic roulette. But we need to trust God and see that life and the problem of good and evil are far more complicated than we can imagine. Job and his friends made God too small and the problems far too simplistic. Job believed that both good and bad come from the hand of God, which is true at one level, but it is overly simplistic and leaves out many other important factors. So, we need to trust the wisdom of God that sees all, knows all, and comprehends the problem and the complex answers in ways that are far beyond our ability to grasp. The best example of this is how the justice and purpose of God were accomplished on the cross. The cross was both an incredible injustice and, at the same time, the most perfect justice in all of human history. All this means that in the end, when we suffer or when we reflect on the bad things that have come into our life, our response should be one of seeking God the person, growing to know Him more in all His attributes, and trusting in His grace and wisdom, rather than seeking justice, or logical explanations. Second, we can summarize this section by applying Matthew 6:33, seek first the kingdom of God and His righteousness, and all these things will be added to you.