I have heard people say that the reason they would never become a Christian is because there are too many hypocrites in the Church. Some have gone so far as to suggest that the Church is full of hypocrites or that all Christians are hypocrites. Just as bad news travels fast, so the stories of false or unfaithful Christians travel far and wide. A few famous or infamous examples of phony believers result in us all being painted with the same brush. My response to the charge that all Christians are hypocrites is a resounding yes!
The word hypocrite is defined by Webster as: 1. A person who puts on a false appearance of virtue or religion; or 2. A Person who acts in contradiction to his or her stated beliefs or feelings. In other words a hypocrite is a fake or a failure. So actually, you cannot become a follower of Jesus without first admitting to being a failure. Thus by definition, we are all hypocrites. This continues to be the case, even after salvation. Do we truly love God with are our hearts, souls and minds? Do we truly love our neighbours as ourselves? We want to, we know we should, we make efforts in that direction but … we fail. Fortunately, Jesus has made a provision for our failures in that He continues to forgive. "[B]ut if anyone does sin, we have an advocate with the Father – Jesus Christ, the Righteous one" (1 John 2:1).
Fakers on the other hand, those hypocrites defined by Webster in the first part of his description, are by definition not real followers of Jesus. Since one must put off the pretense of righteousness in order to be truly righteous. These are the folks that Jesus addresses in Luke chapter 11 and 12. The Pharisee kind of hypocrisy was the "fake it" kind. They pretended to be spiritual with ulterior motives. They played to the crowd. This is exactly what Jesus was warning his disciples about in Luke 12:1-7. The presence of the crowd prompts this very private admonition.
To paraphrase, Jesus is saying: "Don't fear man, fear the Lord. There is a fate worse than death, it is hell and the Lord is the only one who has the authority to cast people into hell." Right after this warning Jesus comforts his disciples with the fact that every hair on their heads is numbered and that God cares for them. The connection at first between the "Fear of the Lord" and the "Loving Care of the Lord" is not apparent but I believe the juxtaposition is very intentional. To fear the Lord means to respect his authority and stand in awe of his majesty. This is incredibly good news when we realize he is on our side. He cares for us. Our fear of God varies proportionately to our fear of man. When our fear of God goes up, our fear of man goes down. When our fear of man goes down, our temptation toward fakery goes down. Hypocrisy of the faking kind is a direct result of our lack of Godly fear.
Questions for Discussion:
1. Slide 2-3. What do you think prompts people to make so much of hypocrisy in the Church? What motivates this kind of gossip?
2. Slide 4-7. Why was Jesus so hard on the Pharisees in the Sermon on the Mount and Luke 11? What do you think motivated the Pharisees to act this way? Does Jesus give us insight into their motivation?
3. Slide 8-9. Discuss the difference between being a "fake" and being a "failure."
4. Slide 10. Discuss the logic of rejecting the Gospel because of the behavior of some bad examples in the Church. Discuss this question: "But what will you do with the claims of Jesus?" How is this the "central question?"
5. Slide 15-16. How afraid are people of how others think of them? What fuels this fear? What is the antidote to what might be called "Fear of Man?"
6. Slide 17-19. How is the Lord's loving care over us connected to our Fear of the Lord? Define "Fear of the Lord." How can we enhance a healthy Fear of the Lord?