Close of Play

The Ashes are over. England got smashed 4–1 — and now the inquest begins.After another defeat, the focus shifts away from individual moments and onto the bigger picture: preparation, selection, leadership, and whether England’s approach to Test cricket is genuinely fit for touring Australia.In this episode of Close of Play, Sanjay Murthy and former England wicketkeeper Geraint Jones conduct a calm, forensic post-series review — assessing what England got wrong, what (if anything) improved, and where hard decisions now have to be made.This isn’t point-scoring. It’s about accountability, clarity, and what comes next.👇 Subscribe to Close of PlayAccessible, informed cricket conversation — with a sense of humour, even when the verdict is tough.⏱️ TIMESTAMPS00:00 – Now the inquest01:10 – Series ends 4–1: what does it really say?02:45 – Preparation vs execution05:20 – Selection mistakes that compounded08:15 – Leadership under pressure11:00 – What England actually learned14:30 – Who comes out of this stronger?18:05 – Who faces hard questions?22:10 – The Ashes model: broken or fixable?26:00 – What touring Australia now requires30:20 – What must change before the next cycle34:30 – Final verdict#ashes #testcricket #cricketdebate #englishcricket #ashes2025 #closeofplay #cricket #australiacricket #sanjaymurthycricket

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

England finally have something to smile about.

On Day Four of the fifth Ashes Test in Sydney, Jacob Bethell produced one of the moments of the series — a maiden Test hundred that brought belief, balance, and more than a few raised eyebrows in the commentary box.

In this episode of Close of Play, Sanjay Murthy and former England wicketkeeper Geraint Jones break down why Bethell’s innings felt different, how it shifted the mood around the team, and what it means for England’s selections going forward — with a few laughs along the way about comparisons, confidence, and the inevitable overreactions that follow a breakthrough performance.

There’s also plenty of light relief, including What’s in a Name? — our regular game — alongside discussion on Zac Crawley, Ollie Pope, Jamie Smith, Ben Stokes’ captaincy, county form versus white-ball instincts, and the kind of Ashes tangents that remind us cricket doesn’t always have to be doom and gloom.

👇 Subscribe to Close of Play
Daily Test cricket analysis, honest opinions, and the occasional chuckle.

TIMESTAMPS

00:00 – A star is born
01:15 – England finally find calm at No.3
02:55 – Bethell’s hundred: why this felt different
04:45 – Technique, temperament & respect for the ball
07:05 – Why Bethell benefited from being left out earlier
09:20 – Comparisons with David Gower
11:05 – Confidence vs arrogance: England’s problem
13:15 – What Bethell means for Pope
15:20 – Crawley: last chance saloon?
18:10 – County form vs white-ball selection
21:10 – What England must change after this Ashes
24:00 – Will Jacks and decision-making under pressure
26:20 – Fan backlash and boycotts: reality check
29:10 – True or False: Ashes history
31:20 – Cricket Australia vs broadcasters
34:50 – COP THAT: the case against Ben Stokes
37:10 – Defence of Stokes: leadership vs output
39:20 – Is there another Mike Brearley?
41:05 – Final thoughts on Day Four

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

England lost control again on Day Three in Sydney — and it wasn’t just with the ball.

Despite moments of resistance, Australia piled on the pressure through clarity, discipline, and relentless execution, while England continued to look uncertain in their bowling plans, fielding standards, and on-field leadership.

In this episode of Close of Play, Sanjay Murthy and former England wicketkeeper Geraint Jones discuss Ben Stokes’ captaincy, England’s workload management, dropped catches, the absence of clear fielding standards, and why confidence and clarity continue to separate the two sides.

There’s also analysis of Travis Head’s dominance, Steve Smith’s control, Jamie Smith’s series, and what England mustreflect on after another draining day.

👇 Subscribe to Close of Play
Daily Test cricket analysis with clarity, not noise.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

England were taught another hard lesson on Day Two of the fifth Ashes Test.

Despite moments of resistance, Australia once again controlled the tempo of the game, exposing the same tactical and technical flaws that have defined England’s tour so far.

In this episode of Close of Play, Sanjay Murthy and former England wicketkeeper Geraint Jones analyse why England keep losing control in key sessions, how Australia’s bowlers consistently apply pressure, and what England must change if they are to compete away from home.

There’s also discussion on Travis Head’s impact, England’s bowling balance, selection decisions, and whether England are actually learning as the series progresses.

👇 Subscribe to Close of Play
Daily Ashes analysis with clarity, not noise.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Are fans being short-changed by modern Test cricket?

On Day One of the fifth Ashes Test in Sydney, more than 45 overs were lost despite clear skies — reigniting anger among supporters who paid, travelled, and waited to watch Test cricket unfold. In this episode of Close of Play, Sanjay Murthy and former England wicketkeeper Geraint Jones debate whether the game is now too rigid, too cautious, and too driven by commercial priorities.

From bad light rules and lightning protocols, to pitch preparation, spin bowling, batting technique, and Usman Khawaja’s powerful comments on representation and legacy, this is a wide-ranging discussion about who Test cricket is really for in 2026.

👇 Subscribe to Close of Play
Calm, honest cricket conversations — no shouting, no nostalgia.

00:00 – Are Ashes fans being cheated?
01:48 – 45 overs lost at Sydney: unacceptable?
03:55 – Bad light, lightning rules & modern cricket
06:05 – Would this ever happen in white-ball cricket?
08:50 – Optics: blue skies, empty seats
09:55 – England recover from 57–3 to 211–3
10:40 – Duckett & Crawley: progress or illusion?
12:50 – Why Joe Root still stands apart
14:15 – Flat pitches & selection headaches
15:45 – Why spin bowling is disappearing
18:40 – How batters are coached to dominate spin
21:05 – County cricket’s influence on bowlers
23:45 – Does the Ashes scoreline even matter now?
25:15 – Subscriber milestone 🎉
27:05 – True or False: Don Bradman in 1948
29:25 – Usman Khawaja’s retirement & legacy
31:40 – Race, opportunity & representation in cricket
35:15 – The real cost of playing the game
38:35 – Athletes, activism & double standards
41:05 – Listener question answered
43:05 – Toughest fast bowlers faced
50:40 – Final thoughts & Day Two preview

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Does the modern game of cricket still need the West Indies?

Once the most feared force in world cricket, West Indies now sit on the margins of the Test game — and this episode asks the uncomfortable question many fans are thinking but rarely say out loud.

Sanjay Murthy is joined by former Leicestershire cricketer and editor Damian Brandy to explore what really went wrong: from administration and infrastructure, to poor pitches, player incentives, franchise cricket, and the failure to adapt to the modern era.

This is not nostalgia. It’s an honest conversation about whether Test cricket is weaker without a strong West Indies — and whether the decline was inevitable, avoidable, or self-inflicted.

👇 Subscribe to Close of Play

Thoughtful, long-form cricket conversations — we’re pushing towards 200 subscribers.

00:00 – The uncomfortable question: does cricket still need the West Indies?
01:18 – Damian Brandy’s early career & life in professional cricket
02:36 – Big personalities, pressure & mental health in county cricket
04:19 – Would players thrive more in today’s environment?
05:28 – Why this conversation really matters now
06:30 – Excuses vs reality in West Indies cricket
08:29 – Why the legends keep coming back — and why it hasn’t worked
10:07 – Money, World Series Cricket & what never changed
12:23 – Is forced Caribbean unity part of the problem?
13:06 – Asking “why” until you reach the real issue
14:35 – The shocking standard of West Indies pitches
15:42 – How bad wickets destroy batting technique
16:41 – Talent isn’t the issue — development is
17:37 – A 10-year rebuild: what would actually fix it
18:16 – Do young West Indians even want to play Test cricket?
19:50 – What India got right with the IPL
20:49 – Can the CPL genuinely save West Indies cricket?
21:47 – How T20 cricket has changed Test cricket forever
22:20 – Administration vs culture: who’s really responsible?
23:16 – Could West Indies cricket disappear from Tests?
24:18 – Would Test cricket be weaker without them?
25:06 – Final thoughts: legacy, relevance, and reality

#cricket #westindies #ipl

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

England have finally won a Test match in Australia — their first since 2011.

But does this victory actually mean England have learned anything from this Ashes series?

In this episode of Close of Play, Sanjay Murthy and former England wicketkeeper Geraint Jones react to England’s win on a wildly uneven pitch, discuss Jacob Bethell’s role, the return of controlled bowling lengths, and why this result doesn’t necessarily answer the bigger questions about batting, balance, and spin.

From Shoaib Bashir and Will Jacks, to selection headaches for Sydney, pitch preparation, and whether England are clearer about their future than Australia — this is a calm, honest assessment of a rare away win.

👇 Subscribe to Close of Play
We’re closing in on 200 subscribers — daily, thoughtful Ashes analysis without the noise.

00:00 – England finally win in Australia
00:35 – Relief… mixed with doubt
01:13 – Have England actually learned anything?
02:12 – Jacob Bethell’s 40: context matters
03:03 – The ramp, the defence & the Barmy Army
04:29 – Why the pitch dictated everything
05:58 – 10mm of grass: how this wicket went wrong
07:05 – Why defence didn’t matter on this surface
08:12 – No team reached 200: what does that tell us?
09:10 – Bowlers bounce back: Carse & Tongue respond
10:36 – Will Jacks: batter first, spinner second?
12:05 – Shoaib Bashir’s impossible situation
13:53 – Two-day Tests: fair or farcical?
16:43 – What a “good” Test pitch should actually do
18:19 – ICC pitch ratings: flawed logic?
19:52 – Was this wicket fair for cricket?
21:24 – Closing in on 200 subscribers
22:09 – True or False: Ashes absurdities
26:28 – Bob Willis and Ashes history
27:57 – Should fans get something on day three?
31:12 – England clarity vs Australia uncertainty
34:53 – Australia’s batting worries
36:39 – Who’s next for Australia?
38:07 – Listener questions: pressure & distractions
45:00 – Is everything psychological warfare?
47:48 – England leave Australia with a win
48:27 – Final thoughts & New Year sign-off

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

England are under intense pressure — on the pitch, off the pitch, and under the microscope of an Ashes tour in Australia.

In this Day One MCG analysis, Sanjay Murthy and former England wicketkeeper Geraint Jones go beyond the scorecard to discuss what a brutal Ashes tour really feels like for players when results go against you.

From a 20-wicket day, to Brydon Carse’s struggles, Ben Stokes’ captaincy, Harry Brook’s instincts, and the scrutiny around Ben Duckett and team culture — this episode is about pressure, preparation, and reality.

👇 Subscribe to Close of Play
If you value calm, honest cricket insight during the biggest series in the game, hit subscribe — we’re closing in on 200.

00:00 – 20 wickets: chaos at the MCG
01:11 – Christmas on Ashes tour: inside the bubble
04:27 – Why this pitch offered too much
05:51 – England bowlers finally adapting
07:05 – Brydon Carse: no control, no evolution
09:10 – Is Ben Stokes’ captaincy being judged fairly?
10:51 – Has England’s bowling approach finally changed?
11:19 – Why this bowling group is England’s future
13:11 – Analysts, preparation & what’s missing
15:32 – Harry Brook charging Starc: madness or method?
18:03 – England 110 all out: context matters
19:42 – The Ben Duckett video: scrutiny in the modern game
22:23 – Is there a drinking culture problem in cricket?
26:47 – What players are really dealing with off the pitch
30:44 – Away Ashes vs home pressure
32:01 – Road to 200 subscribers
34:18 – True or False: Warner, Curran & MCG drama
36:32 – Rob Key fronts up: honesty vs results
41:39 – Aggression vs “dumb” cricket
43:29 – Why no one wants a two-day Test
44:39 – Shane Warne: genius and theatre
46:39 – Session-by-session verdict
48:25 – Final thoughts: pressure tells all

#Ashes #EnglandCricket #TestCricket #CricketDebate #CricketShorts #Shorts

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

The Ashes are gone — not after five Tests, but after 10 days.

In this Day Five analysis, Sanjay Murthy and former England wicketkeeper Geraint Jones break down where England’s tour unravelled, why Australia managed the series better, and how preparation, adaptability, and decision-making ultimately decided everything.

From batting time and run rates, to selection, culture, and leadership, this episode explains why England were outplayed — and what must change before the next Ashes cycle.

👇 Subscribe for daily Ashes analysis
Straight-talking cricket insight, without noise or nostalgia.

00:00 – Ashes done in 10 days: final verdict
01:02 – Why Australia played the situation better
02:15 – Batting time: the stat that explains the series
03:03 – Why England never controlled the new ball
04:02 – Run rates, tempo & game management
05:18 – “If they’re learning, it’s too late”
06:33 – Preparation failures exposed
07:10 – One-pace England vs adaptable Australia
08:28 – How Australia controlled first & second innings

09:37 – Risk strategy thrown back in England’s face
10:36 – Fatigue, day five & mental toll
12:53 – 2005 vs 2006-07: how Ashes cycles turn
15:53 – Personnel loss vs structural failure
18:06 – Culture, confidence & the McCullum model
19:18 – Backroom staff, scrutiny & accountability
21:15 – Is culture overrated if results don’t follow?
22:26 – Subscriber thanks + True or False
24:16 – 1912 Ashes oddity explained
27:26 – Is a 5–0 whitewash inevitable?
28:20 – Plan A failed — where was Plan B?
30:36 – Signs of progress… too late
32:56 – McCullum’s messaging: clarity lost?
36:54 – Why wholesale change is a mistake
39:12 – Should McCullum’s role change?
41:24 – Thinkers vs doers: the Ferguson model
43:29 – Listener question: preparation & analysts
47:10 – Aussie perspective: brutal honesty
49:18 – Winning vs “entertainment” cricket
51:52 – The dismissal that summed up the series
52:24 – Final thoughts: learn, adapt, move forward

#Ashes #EnglandCricket #TestCricket #AustraliaCricket #CricketAnalysis

#Ashes2025 #CloseOfPlay

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

For the first time this series, England showed signs of proper Test cricket thinking.

Day four brought application, patience, and smarter decision-making — even if the result now feels inevitable. Sanjay Murthy and former England wicketkeeper Geraint Jones break down what finally changed, why it happened too late, and what this performance tells us about England’s preparation, mentality, and future selection.

From Zac Crawley’s discipline, to Alex Carey’s elite wicketkeeping, to the unseen mental toll players now face in the social-media era — this episode goes beyond the scorecard.

👇 Subscribe for daily Ashes analysis
Straight-talking cricket insight, without shouting or spin.

YouTube https://youtu.be/fxxis0qnsKY

00:00 – Uncharted territory: analysing day four
00:53 – England finally apply themselves
01:35 – Is this proper Test cricket too late?
02:30 – Why Australia’s discipline forced England to adapt
03:30 – How hard is it really to win in Australia?
04:53 – Crawley at the press conference: pressure and reality
06:55 – Why England weren’t “surprised” — just slow to adapt
08:50 – Fatigue, franchise cricket & touring realities
11:46 – Why players don’t play grade cricket anymore
13:53 – Cooperation between boards: fantasy vs reality
14:52 – Alex Carey: the standout of the Test
16:19 – Elite wicketkeeping explained (posture & technique)
19:44 – Duckett, bounce & technical limitations
21:26 – Should batters be selected by conditions?
23:14 – Why bowlers are treated differently to batters
24:24 – Geraint Jones on coaching Zac Crawley as a child
26:07 – Talent, patience & Crawley’s Test career
29:49 – Why players are backed longer now
30:39 – Subscribe & Ashes True or False
31:18 – Famous cameraman catch myth
33:13 – Mental health, criticism & the modern player
36:41 – Why commentary criticism hits harder than fans think
39:44 – Social media, entitlement & abuse
45:33 – What England must do on day five
46:27 – The Barmy Army & player responsibility
48:03 – Final thoughts: fight, pride & standards

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices