Teaching Martial Arts by Combat Learning

CLP27 - Premodern, Modern, & Transmodern Views of Martial Arts Training w/ Sanko Lewis


Listen Later

Join the email list now: combatlearning.com/newsletter

---
Today I'm joined by Dr. Sanko Lewis, a 5th dan in ITF Taekwon-Do and a martial arts academic residing in South Korea.

In this episode, Sanko walks us through different views of what martial arts are and how they conceive of authority in regard to determining effectiveness in training. He divides these views into three major categories:

- Premodern (or pre-rational), which is the ancient view of martial arts
- Modern (or rational), which encompasses systems founded in the 19th and early 20th centuries, usually from a modernist pedagogical philosophy standpoint
- Transmodern (or trans-rational), which is a view of martial arts that seeks to use rational ideas about training while appreciating premodern traditions.

I think many would classify me as someone who advocates a modern or rational approach to training, but I have a lot of criticism of it. While I do advocate for more scientifically-based training approaches, I do not support a philosophically modernist pedagogy. At any rate, this is a fascinating discussion, and many martial arts that we think of as traditional actually have a foot in more than one of these categories.

Link to original article: https://sooshimkwan.blogspot.com/2020/12/pre-rational-rational-trans-rational.html

Dr. Lewis' follow-up article (concept is mentioned in episode): https://sooshimkwan.blogspot.com/2022/01/what-is-postmodern-martial-art.html


So if you're excited to jump in, hit the subscribe button on your podcatcher and enjoy the show.
---
Find Dr. Sanko Lewis:

Website: sooshimkwan.blogspot.com
---
Produced by Micah Peacock
Intro Theme by Micah Peacock
Outro Music is Synergy by Juche

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

Teaching Martial Arts by Combat LearningBy Josh Peacock

  • 5
  • 5
  • 5
  • 5
  • 5

5

10 ratings


More shows like Teaching Martial Arts by Combat Learning

View all
The Perception & Action Podcast by Rob Gray

The Perception & Action Podcast

105 Listeners

The BJJ Fanatics Podcast by Ryan Ford

The BJJ Fanatics Podcast

440 Listeners

Jack Slack Podcast by Jack Slack

Jack Slack Podcast

401 Listeners

The Michael Shermer Show by Michael Shermer

The Michael Shermer Show

894 Listeners

The Chewjitsu Podcast by Chewjitsu

The Chewjitsu Podcast

572 Listeners

BJJ Mental Models by Steve Kwan

BJJ Mental Models

224 Listeners

The Sonny Brown Breakdown by Sonny Brown

The Sonny Brown Breakdown

33 Listeners

Villaincast - For BJJ Antiheroes by Chris Paines

Villaincast - For BJJ Antiheroes

3 Listeners

Bulletproof For BJJ Podcast by JT & Joey

Bulletproof For BJJ Podcast

167 Listeners

The Adaptable Athlete Podcast by Javier Miller-Estrada

The Adaptable Athlete Podcast

22 Listeners

Sweet Science Of Fighting Podcast by Sweet Science of Fighting

Sweet Science Of Fighting Podcast

5 Listeners

The Simple Man Podcast by Simple Man Podcast

The Simple Man Podcast

36 Listeners

1-800-BJJ-HELP by Josh Lu and Jake Luigi

1-800-BJJ-HELP

11 Listeners

The Everyday Jiu Jitsu Podcast by Matt Kwan

The Everyday Jiu Jitsu Podcast

11 Listeners

Grappling with the World by Andy Grappling

Grappling with the World

0 Listeners