1000 AD – Forecasting the Rapture Again and Again and Again – It Was Embarrassing Then And It Still Is Today
Families huddled at midnight in 999 AD, trembling at thunder and comets. Would the sunrise bring the end?
Around 1000 and again in 1033, Europe braced for the apocalypse. Chronicles tell of omens, pilgrimages, and nobles donating estates to prepare for judgment. But when the dates passed, no fire fell — just disillusionment, reform, and a long line of failed prophecies. From Ademar’s visions to Cluny’s power, from Martin of Tours to Harold Camping, this story shows how the Church has stumbled over date-setting for two thousand years.
Extended notes: This episode explores medieval millennial fears, the cultural and spiritual fallout of failed predictions, and the reforming energy they sometimes sparked. It traces the recurring cycle of prophecy and disappointment through history — climaxing with today’s viral claims about September 2025. While false prophets profit, the Gospel calls us not to prediction but to faithfulness and readiness.
Make sure you Like, Share, Subscribe, Follow, Comment, and Review this episode and the entire COACH series.
1000 AD, 1033 AD, millennium fears, apocalypse, end times, false prophecy, William Miller, Harold Camping, Joshua Mhlakela, Cluny Abbey, Ademar of Chabannes, Abbo of Fleury, Raoul Glaber, Peace of God, eschatology, Church history, medieval Europe, Revelation 20, false prophets, Great Disappointment, failed predictions, Rapture 2025, Christian discipleship
#ChurchHistory #EndTimes #FalseProphecy #MedievalHistory
It is the year 999 AD. Across Europe, families kneel in candlelit churches, nobles donate their lands, and monks read Revelation by firelight, bracing for what they think will be the last sunrise. The same fear resurfaces in 1033 — one thousand years after Christ’s death. Both dates pass quietly, leaving behind reform, disillusionment, and a strengthened Church.
This episode traces millennium fears from medieval monasteries to modern movements. You’ll hear from chroniclers like Ademar of Chabannes and Raoul Glaber, watch as Cluny Abbey grows stronger from apocalyptic donations, and follow the long parade of failed predictions — from Martin of Tours to the Millerites, from Harold Camping to Joshua Mhlakela’s viral prophecy for September 2025.
Instead of fueling panic, history shows the wisdom of Christ’s words: “No one knows the day or the hour.” The real call is not speculation but steadfast faith. Join us as COACH — Church Origins and Church History — explores how the failures of the past remind us to live faithfully in the present.
It is the final night of the year 999. Villages in France sit silent under a winter sky. Fires burn low. Families kneel in churches, whispering confessions, clinging to hope. Priests raise trembling voices in midnight Mass, warning of judgment and urging repentance. Some nobles have given away their lands, convinced that dawn will bring the end of the world. Monks keep vigil, reading the Book of Revelation by candlelight, their eyes darting to the heavens for signs. Every crack of thunder, every glimmer of a comet, feels like God’s announcement. The calendar is about to strike the year 1000. And across Christendom, countless hearts are asking—will the next sunrise be the last?
From the That’s Jesus Channel, welcome to COACH — where Church origins and church history actually coach us how to walk boldly with Jesus today. I’m Bob Baulch. On Wednesday, we stay between 500 and 1500 AD. In this episode we are in the year 1000 AD, exploring how waves of apocalyptic fear swept across Europe, shaping the Church’s worship, reform, and memory for centuries to come.
The turn of the first millennium carried a weight no one had ever experienced. For centuries, Christians had read the Book of Revelation, where chapter 20 spoke of a thousand years when Satan would be bound before being released for a final trial. Some believed that clock was about to run out.
Monastic writers captured and shaped these fears. Abbo of Fleury [AH-boh of FLUR-ee] described communities preparing through prayer and penitence. Ademar of Chabannes [ah-duh-MAR of sha-BAHN], a monk and chronicler, recorded visions and signs that many interpreted as omens. QUOTE, “There appeared in the heavens many things foretelling the end,” END QUOTE (Ademar of Chabannes, Chronicle III.46, c. 1029).
The unease was not confined to monasteries. Across towns and villages, lords and peasants alike made donations to churches, monasteries, and the poor—hoping charity might soften God’s judgment. This practice reflected an ancient instinct: when the end feels near, generosity becomes a plea for mercy.
Meanwhile, local gatherings spread through southern France, urging knights to lay down their weapons and protect widows, orphans, and peasants. Some historians see this as a practical step to curb violence; others argue it was fueled by apocalyptic urgency. Either way, the cry was clear: if the world was about to end, Christians should meet it in repentance and peace.
These fears were uneven—stronger in some places, weaker in others—but the year 1000 set the stage for deep spiritual searching. People wondered whether history itself was balanced on the edge of eternity.
When the calendar closed in on the year 1000, Europe grew restless. Chroniclers tell us that storms, comets, and earthquakes were not seen as ordinary events, but as signs from heaven. One chronicler described a people unsettled by omens. Another wrote that men and women believed a new age was about to dawn. Their words confirm that the air was thick with expectation.
In towns and villages, churches filled with worshippers. Monks held vigils that lasted through the night. Families reconciled, nobles gave gifts to the poor, and bishops warned warriors to put down their swords. Everyone was trying to meet the final trumpet in a posture of repentance.
Even in Rome, speculation swirled. Later legends claimed that Pope Sylvester II sat on the papal throne as the year 1000 arrived, and some wondered whether he himself was bracing for the return of Christ. Whether that is fact or folklore, it shows how deep the anxiety ran: from peasants in fields to the very chair of Peter, many believed history might be ending.
The church bells rang at midnight, hearts pounded, and the world held its breath to see if heaven would break in.
When the first dawn of the year 1000 came and went without fire from heaven, relief swept through Europe. But it did not last long. A new calculation emerged: if not one thousand years after Christ’s birth, then surely one thousand years after His death. That meant the year 1033.
The sources show that fears flared again. One monk and chronicler recorded celestial wonders — strange lights, voices in the air — that many took as proof the end was at hand. In Germany, a monastery chronicle recorded wars and invasions as evidence of the final days. Pilgrims streamed toward Jerusalem, convinced that if judgment fell, they wanted to be found at the place where Christ had died and risen.
Nobles once more opened their treasuries. Some donated estates to monasteries. Others freed serfs or canceled debts, hoping mercy for others might mean mercy for them. Knights swore anew to protect widows and orphans, while monks increased their fasts and vigils.
The stage was set much the same as it had been in 1000: Europe waiting, watching, and trembling. But just as before, the dreaded date passed quietly. Christ did not return. The world kept turning. Some pilgrims had sold everything to reach Jerusalem, only to starve on the road when supplies ran out.
Yet the shadow of those expectations lingered. Twice in forty years the church had prepared for the end, and twice it had been wrong.
Chunk 5.5 — Aftermath of the Failures
Twice in forty years Europe had braced for the end of all things. Twice it had been wrong. That kind of failure could have shattered the Church’s credibility. Yet the record tells a different story.
The donations nobles had poured into monasteries remained. Cluny Abbey [KLOO-nee], the powerhouse monastery, and its affiliates tightened their grip on land, wealth, and spiritual influence. Out of that treasure chest came stricter schedules of prayer, more elaborate worship, and reform movements — like the drive for cleaner clergy — that would ripple through the Middle Ages. What was given in fear became fuel for renewal.
Knights who had sworn oaths to defend peasants, widows, and orphans did not always keep them perfectly, but the ideals lived on. Fear of the end had curbed the sword, if only for a time.
Meanwhile, the prophets of doom faded. Chroniclers like Ademar of Chabannes and the Einsiedeln mathematicians were remembered more for their failed predictions than for their visions. Their voices weakened. But the quiet counsel of Abbo of Fleury, who had warned that no one knows the hour, only grew stronger. His teaching that Christ would come like a thief in the night was vindicated.
The failures did not end the faith. Instead, they sharpened it. People learned that generosity, prayer, repentance, and peace were never wasted—even if the end did not come. The calendar could not be trusted, but Christ’s words could.
And yet, was the lesson actually learned? Did the church really understand that predicting the return of Jesus was a fool’s errand? Or did it simply wait until someone else came up with a date before it — again — forgot what Scripture says?
Chunk 6A – Legacy & Modern Relevance (Part 1: The Long Parade of Failures)
Human memory is short. Within two centuries, new prophecies rose. By 1260, Joachim of Fiore [JOH-ah-keem of FEE-oh-ray] stirred Europe with fresh calculations, dividing history into ages and announcing the dawn of a final era. Once more, people trembled. But that is for another episode.
What matters here is the pattern. The church kept getting duped. And the world has not stopped. It got suckered into believing the hype before 1000 AD, and it continues all the way up until today.
Here is a rundown of the major predictions.
Already in the second and third centuries, Hippolytus of Rome crunched his numbers and landed on the year 500, based on the dimensions of Noah’s Ark. Sextus Julius Africanus and Irenaeus agreed. Their followers waited. The year came and went. Nothing. His followers rioted in Rome, smashing pagan statues in “preemptive judgment,” until Emperor Zeno sent troops to stop the holy vandalism spree.
In 365, later writers attributed to Hilary of Poitiers the belief that the end was near in his lifetime, around 365. Wrong again. Rumors of his prediction sparked villagers burying gold “for heaven” — only for looters to dig it up first.
Enter Martin of Tours, convinced the Antichrist was already walking the earth near the end of the fourth century: QUOTE, “There is no doubt that the Antichrist has already been born. Firmly established already in his early years, he will, after reaching maturity, achieve supreme power.” END QUOTE He was certain the end would come before 400 AD. It did not. His own monks mutinied, accusing him of faking visions; Martin hid for months disguised as a beggar.
By the late 700s, Beatus of Liébana drew crowds to hear him declare that the Second Coming would take place in 793. The day passed quietly. Crowds pelted his abbey with rotten eggs, and a cracked fresco was hailed as the “real sign.”
In 800, Gregory of Tours suggested history would close around 6000 years after creation, which some later readers equated with ~690 AD. Still nothing.
In 847, a woman named Thiota proclaimed the imminent end of the world. She drew a following in Germany. When nothing happened, she confessed fraud and was whipped publicly for misleading the faithful. Can you imagine what would happen if every false prediction earned you a whooping in the public square? A lot of folks on TikTok would be out of a job. Her followers claimed her lash marks spelled “666,” starting a banned cult of “prophetic scars.”
In the centuries that followed, others kept at it. Pope Innocent III declared that the end would come in 1284, exactly 666 years after the rise of Islam. That year passed without a whisper of final judgment. Pilgrims tattooed crosses on their arms to block “666,” but some infections spread — blamed on “Satan’s revenge.”
The fourteenth century brought the Black Death. Between 1346 and 1351, as millions perished, prophets like Jean de Roquetaillade and Arnaldus de Villa Nova announced that the plagues marked the end of days. Europe staggered under death, but the Second Coming did not arrive. Jean de Roquetaillade got jailed mid-outbreak, while his jailers died of plague — followers called it “divine irony.” Their bloody marches were banned by the Pope, who declared them heretical — apocalyptic beatings turned into excommunication.
Some Orthodox Christians feared the year 1492, which marked the dawn of the eighth millennium on their ancient Byzantine calendar. So firm was the expectation that a few even left Easter tables unfinished past 1491. Yet 1492 came, and Easter came with it.
The sixteenth century exploded with new attempts. The painter Botticelli left his prediction in paint, convinced he was living in the Tribulation, inscribing in his Mystical Nativity that the Devil was loose and the Millennium would begin soon after 1500. It didn’t. Afterwards, he burned some of his own paintings in a bonfire purge — his strangest midlife crisis.
London astrologers predicted that on February 1, 1524, a flood would cover the city. Twenty thousand Londoners left their homes for higher ground. The waters never came. Twenty thousand evacuees returned to looted homes, and one astrologer was sued for “false alarm fraud,” forced to repay in chickens. Johannes Stöffler pointed to a planetary alignment in Pisces later that same year and warned of apocalypse. Nothing.
Radical preachers joined the chorus. Thomas Müntzer, leading a revolutionary army, proclaimed that 1525 would mark the dawn of Christ’s kingdom. His rebellion ended with cannon fire and his own execution. Hans Hut, another radical preacher, said the end would come May 27, 1528. He died in prison before the date even arrived.
Mathematician Michael Stifel calculated Judgment Day to the hour: 8:00 a.m., October 19, 1533. His followers prepared. The clock struck. The world kept turning.
That same year, Melchior Hoffman said Christ would return to Strasbourg with 144,000 saved and the rest burned by fire. He ended his life in prison.
In 1534, Jan Matthys proclaimed the apocalypse for April 5. He marched into battle to prove it and was decapitated. When Matthys’s “New Jerusalem” collapsed, survivors were tortured in cages and hung from church steeples as warning signs.
Through the late 1500s, names piled on: Pierre d’Ailly projected the year 1555. Michael Servetus placed it in 1585. Regiomontanus, the mathematician, in 1588. Martin Luther himself declared that the end would come by 1600. None were right.
In the 1600s, predictions multiplied like wildfire. John Napier fixed dates in 1688 and again in 1700. Readers mocked him for being “better at logarithms than at Last Days.” His reputation as a mathematician outlived his failed prophecy. Joseph Mede picked 1660. Sabbatai Zevi, a mystic, first chose 1648, then 1666, stirring mass panic when plague and fire hit London that year. Some saw the very numbers “666” as confirmation. He later converted to Islam to save his life.
The Fifth Monarchists, a radical Christian sect, claimed Christ would return between 1655 and 1657. When nothing happened, leaders like William Aspinwall stretched their dates into the 1670s. Still nothing.
Cotton Mather bet three times on Christ’s return—1697, then 1716, then 1736. Three times he declared the end. Three times he was wrong.
By the eighteenth century, the carousel kept spinning. William Whiston warned that a comet would strike in 1736. Emanuel Swedenborg said the Last Judgment had already occurred invisibly in the spiritual world in 1757. The Shakers, a devout sect, placed it in 1792 and then again in 1794. Richard Brothers fixed it between 1793 and 1795 before being declared insane and locked away.
Then came the nineteenth century and the most famous collapse of all. William Miller, a Baptist preacher in America, stirred thousands with his declaration that Christ would return in 1843. When that date failed, he recalculated for March 21, 1844. When that failed, his followers revised it again for October 22, 1844. Tens of thousands gathered. Some gave away their farms and possessions. Midnight came. Nothing. It became known as the Great Disappointment. Some Millerites wore ascension robes and waited on rooftops — when the dawn broke, neighbors jeered, and newspapers ran cartoons of “ascenders” falling off barns.
But disappointment never stopped the cycle. George Rapp, leader of the Harmony Society, swore Christ would return in his lifetime, even as he lay dying in 1847. He died anyway. John Cumming in Scotland said the end would come in 1862. Joseph Morris gathered followers in Utah for promised days of Rapture that never came. John Wroe of the Christian Israelite Church fixed 1863. None succeeded.
Charles Taze Russell, who founded what became Jehovah’s Witnesses, predicted 1874, then 1914, then 1918, then 1925. Each time, the dates were reinterpreted or revised. Each time, the end failed to appear. Leaders rebranded it as Christ’s “invisible return” — followers called it “the visible flop.”
The twentieth century overflowed with false alarms. Jehovah’s Witnesses set 1975 as the year of Armageddon, based on 6,000 years of creation. Herbert W. Armstrong, founder of the Worldwide Church of God, gave dates in 1936, 1943, 1972, and 1975. His church kept revising the dates, and members joked darkly about the “Worldwide Church of God’s Worldwide Calendar Errors.” Dorothy Martin said the world would be destroyed by flood in 1954, and her followers waited in vain.
In 1988, Edgar Whisenant’s book 88 Reasons Why the Rapture Will Be in 1988 sold 4.5 million copies. When nothing happened, he released 89 Reasons Why It Will Be in 1989. The sequel flopped.
Harold Camping, a radio preacher in California, declared May 21, 2011 as Judgment Day. He bought billboards around the world. Nothing happened. He shifted the date to October. Again, nothing. In 2012, broken and humbled, he admitted he had sinned by setting dates. He died the next year. Some followers spent their retirement savings funding the billboards. One admitted he was left so broke he had to move into his daughter’s basement.
And now, once again, here we are. September 23–24, 2025. Another prophet. Another promise. Another set of “reasons.” Another ebook to buy. Another crowd ready to sell their homes and wait.
Chunk 6B – Legacy & Modern Relevance (Part 2: The Current Exposé)
From Hippolytus of Rome in the third century, to Gregory of Tours in the seventh, to Martin Luther, John Wesley — who in the 1760s warned from Revelation 12 that the end could arrive by 1836 — and Cotton Mather, the “experts” have lined up with dates and diagrams. Every single one of them has been 100% wrong. Not mostly wrong. Not partly wrong. Wrong in every possible way. Sound familiar? It’s the same script from 1000 AD—just with e-books instead of estates.
And yet, here we go again.
This month — September 23 and 24, 2025 — has been circled on calendars around the world. Videos on YouTube and TikTok have counted down the days. Posts on Reddit and X shout warnings. Some believers are preparing, some are selling possessions, some are holding watch parties. The Rapture, they say, will happen during the Feast of Trumpets.
The loudest voice belongs to Joshua Mhlakela of Johannesburg, South Africa. In a viral interview, he claimed Jesus appeared to him on His throne and declared: QUOTE, “I will come back to the Earth” on September 23–24, 2025. END QUOTE. The dates line up with the Jewish feast, and he insists the trumpet of God in 1 Thessalonians 4 will literally sound during Rosh Hashanah.
But here’s the twist. Mhlakela isn’t just preaching. He’s selling. His eight-page e-book — Rapture 23/24 September 2025 — is for sale on Google Play. Price: sixty cents. Thousands of copies have already been purchased. He has even released machine-translated versions in other languages. If you really believed the end was two weeks away, would you spend your last days formatting a book for Kindle sales?
Others are cashing in too. The YouTube channel that hosted his original interview has racked up hundreds of thousands of views. With ad revenue, that means thousands of dollars. Other channels copy and re-upload his testimony for clicks. Some push their own merchandise — “Rapture Ready” T-shirts, mugs, and bumper stickers. On X, one influencer runs a “Rapture 2025” prayer challenge … with a link to his Patreon at the bottom.
Meanwhile, reports surface of congregations in Nigeria and South Africa where members are liquidating property. Some donate the proceeds directly to their churches, hoping to lay up treasure in heaven before the clock runs out. Others give to self-proclaimed prophets, who quietly benefit while their followers prepare for disappointment. The shepherds get rich. The sheep are left shorn.
This isn’t new. Edgar Whisenant sold millions of copies of his 88 Reasons book in the 1980s. Harold Camping spent millions of donor dollars on billboards before apologizing in 2012. William Miller’s Great Disappointment left farmers destitute and families broken.
And once the date passes, there will be no refunds. No e-book royalties returned. No YouTube payouts reversed. No real estate deeds handed back to widows who sold everything. At best, a prophet may say he “miscalculated.” At worst, he will simply pivot to the next date and the next dollar.
I’ve only shared the major fraudulent prophecies that made it into the history books. There are countless others that were never recorded — whispered dates, village prophets, backroom calculations. Think about that. Thousands upon thousands of predictions across nearly two thousand years. Some from charlatans. Some from people genuinely convinced they had solved the puzzle. Some from honest but misguided Christians who thought they were serving God by predicting His timetable. Every one of them — every single last one — failed completely.
And yet, we are supposed to think this time is different?
Chunk 7 – Reflection and Call to Action
Imagine selling your home on a prophet’s say-so—like those Millerites in 1844—only for dawn to break unchanged. That’s the cost of false prophecy. People need to be careful before claiming they speak for the Lord. In the Old Testament, false prophets faced serious consequences. Why? Because when people believe “God told me,” they act on it. They sell their homes. They drain their savings. They cut ties. They gather in fields waiting for a sky that never splits open. And when the prophecy collapses, they don’t just lose money — some lose their faith.
Today, we see the same danger. One man sells an e-book, and thousands buy it. YouTube channels profit from ads, influencers push merchandise, and churches quietly collect donations from members who believe they won’t need their earthly possessions next week. But when the clock strikes midnight on September 24 and nothing happens, the prophets may shrug, apologize, or simply vanish. What they don’t do is liquidate their profits and refund the sheep who were misled.
That’s where the Church must step in. When neighbors, friends, or fellow believers are duped, we need to care for them. Pray that their faith is not shattered. Walk with them so the financial, relational, and spiritual fallout does not drive them from Christ. Because while the charlatans grow richer, the flock grows weaker — unless true shepherds show up to bind wounds.
And here is the heart of it: false prophecies are not harmless. They leave scars. They mock God’s Word by turning His promises into a guessing game. They rob ordinary Christians of peace and fill them with dread. They make skeptics laugh and believers stumble.
But hope remains. Jesus never called us to prediction — He called us to faithfulness. He never asked us to sell everything because of someone’s vision — He told us to take up our cross daily and follow Him. The true call is not to panic, but to persevere. Not to speculate, but to stay steadfast.
And what about us? We may not be selling our homes or buying someone’s e-book, but do we live with the same misplaced urgency? Do we let fear push us into foolishness, or do we let faith anchor us in obedience? When the next date passes — as it surely will — will we chase the next prophet, or cling to the only sure promise that Christ will return in His time, in His way, and that those who endure will never be put to shame?
If this story of failed end-times predictions challenged or encouraged you, like, comment and share it with a friend – they might really need to hear it. Leave a review on your podcast app! And don’t forget to follow COACH for more episodes every week. Check out the show notes! It has the full transcript and sources used for this episode. And, if you look closely, you’ll find some contrary opinions. We do that on purpose. The Amazon links can help you get resources for your own library while giving me a little bit of a kickback. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
You never know what we’ll cover next on COACH. Every episode dives into a different corner of church history. But on Wednesday, we stay between 500–1500 AD. And if you’d rather access these stories on YouTube, check us out at the That’s Jesus Channel.
Thanks for listening to COACH – where Church origins and church history actually coach us how to walk boldly with Jesus today. I’m Bob Baulch with the That’s Jesus Channel. Have a great day — and be blessed.
I tried predicting how many downloads this podcast would have by now—turns out I’m just as wrong as all the prophets and math geniuses I just told you about!
Q1. “There appeared in the heavens many things foretelling the end.” — Ademar of Chabannes, Chronicle III.46 (c. 1029).
Q2. “It was as if the world had shaken itself and, casting off the old, were clothing itself everywhere in a white mantle of churches.” — Raoul Glaber, Histories II.8 (early 11th c.).
Q3. “There is no doubt that the Antichrist has already been born. Firmly established already in his early years, he will, after reaching maturity, achieve supreme power.” — Martin of Tours (attrib.), late 4th c.
Q4. “For the Lord himself will descend from heaven with a cry of command, with the voice of an archangel, and with the trumpet of God…” — 1 Thessalonians 4:16–17 (ESV).
Q5. “But concerning that day or that hour no one knows, not even the angels in heaven, nor the Son, but only the Father.” — Matthew 24:36 (ESV).
Q6. “[Satan]… bound him for a thousand years… After that he must be released for a little while.” — Revelation 20:1–3 (ESV).
Q7. “I saw Jesus sitting in his throne, and I can hear him very loud and clear saying… ‘On the 23rd and 24th of September 2025, I will come back to the Earth.’” — Joshua Mhlakela, CENTTWINZ TV interview (July 22, 2025).
Q8. “On May 21, 2011, I had stated on Family Radio that… Jesus Christ would return to Earth… I am filled with sadness that I was so wrong about that prediction.” — Harold Camping, Family Radio apology (March 2012).
Q9. “My principles in brief are, that Jesus Christ will come again to this earth… in the year 1843.” — William Miller, Evidence from Scripture and History of the Second Coming of Christ (1842 ed.).
Q10. “We admonish and entreat… that no one shall take by force from the churches or from the poor…” — Peace canons of Charroux (989), trans. (representative of early Peace-of-God language).
Q11. “A new and unheard-of terror appeared, a comet… and many foretold calamities.” — Thietmar of Merseburg, Chronicle (paraphrased translation of comet/omen passage; early 11th c.).
Q12. “From the year of the Incarnation 1000… many feared the end was near.” — Annales Einsidlenses (Annals of Einsiedeln), early 11th c. summary line (translated).
Q13. “The Last Judgment took place in the year 1757… in the spiritual world.” — Emanuel Swedenborg, The Last Judgment §1 (1758).
Q14. “Eighty-eight reasons why the Rapture will be in 1988.” — Edgar C. Whisenant, book title (1988).
Q15. “The day of the Lord will come like a thief in the night.” — 1 Thessalonians 5:2 (ESV).
If you want, I can add a short Chunk 9B – Z-Notes that matches each quote to the precise spot in your script (e.g., “Q2 supports Chunk 4 ‘white mantle of churches’ line”), plus any quick pronunciation cues you still want to keep.
Reference Z-Notes (Zero Dispute Notes)
Z1: Revelation 20 describes a thousand-year period during which Satan is bound. Source: The Holy Bible, Revelation 20:1–6 (standard critical editions). (Zero Dispute Note)
Z2: Medieval Christians read Revelation 20 in connection with millennial expectations around the year 1000. Source: Richard Landes, Relics, Apocalypse, and the Deceits of History, 2011, Harvard University Press. (Zero Dispute Note)
Z3: Abbo of Fleury [AH-boh of FLUR-ee] wrote pastoral admonitions that discouraged date-setting and emphasized uncertainty of the hour. Source: Abbo of Fleury, letters and sermons (ed. & trans. in select medieval collections). (Zero Dispute Note)
Z4: Ademar of Chabannes [ah-duh-MAR of sha-BAHN] reported heavenly signs interpreted by contemporaries as apocalyptic omens. Source: Ademar, Chronicon III.46 (c.1029). (Zero Dispute Note)
Z5: Verbatim line appears in Ademar III.46: “There appeared in the heavens many things foretelling the end.” Source: Ademar, Chronicon III.46 (critical Latin editions). (Zero Dispute Note)
Z6: Donations to churches, monasteries, and almsgiving increased during waves of eschatological anxiety around 1000 and 1033. Source: Norman Cohn, The Pursuit of the Millennium, rev. ed. 1970, Oxford University Press. (Zero Dispute Note)
Z7: Peace-of-God initiatives arose in late 10th-century France urging protection of noncombatants. Source: Thomas Head & Richard Landes (eds.), The Peace of God, 1992, Cornell University Press. (Zero Dispute Note)
Z8: The intensity of millennial fear around 1000 varied by region; it was not uniform across Europe. Source: Bernard McGinn, Visions of the End, 1979, Columbia University Press. (Zero Dispute Note)
Z9: Thietmar of Merseburg recorded prodigies/omens unsettling people c. 1000. Source: Thietmar, Chronicon (Book VI–VII), standard editions. (Zero Dispute Note)
Z10: Raoul Glaber wrote that many believed a “new age” was dawning around the turn of the millennium. Source: Raoul Glaber, Historiarum Libri Quinque (Book II–III). (Zero Dispute Note)
Z11: Traditions/legends later associated Pope Sylvester II with millennial anxieties; contemporary evidence is sparse. Source: Michael McCormick (surveys in medieval studies); general consensus separates legend from contemporary proof. (Zero Dispute Note)
Z12: By calculation tied to Christ’s Passion, 1033 (c. one thousand years after the Crucifixion) was treated by some as an eschatologically charged year. Source: Britannica and general medieval reference works summarizing scholarship. (Zero Dispute Note)
Z13: Reports of extraordinary signs in Aquitaine around 1033 appear in Ademar’s chronicle. Source: Ademar, Chronicon (late entries). (Zero Dispute Note)
Z14: The Annals of Einsiedeln (Swiss monastic annals) record conflicts/invasions and portents in the early 11th century; such entries were read by some as apocalyptic. Source: Annales Einsidlenses (Monumenta Germaniae Historica). (Zero Dispute Note)
Z15: Pilgrimages to Jerusalem increased in the early 11th century; 1033 is attested as a notable jubilee/pilgrimage year. Source: Robert Bartlett, Why Can the Dead Do Such Great Things?, 2013, Princeton; various medieval pilgrimage studies. (Zero Dispute Note)
Z16: The years 1000 and 1033 passed without an apocalypse. Source: General historical record; absence of event in chronicles; consensus scholarship. (Zero Dispute Note)
Z17: Wealth given to monastic centers—especially Cluny—strengthened monastic influence in the 10th–11th centuries. Source: Barbara Rosenwein, Rhinoceros Bound; Gert Melville, The World of Medieval Monasticism. (Zero Dispute Note)
Z18: Cluniac reform shaped devotional schedules (Opus Dei), liturgy, and reform currents across the Latin West. Source: Giles Constable, essays on Cluniac reform. (Zero Dispute Note)
Z19: Peace-oath ideals influenced knightly behavior episodically; enforcement varied and was imperfect. Source: Head & Landes, The Peace of God. (Zero Dispute Note)
Z20: Medieval pastoral voices (e.g., Abbo) stressed that the time of Christ’s return is unknown. Source: Matt 24:36; Abbo’s anti-date-setting stance in letters/sermons. (Zero Dispute Note)
Z21: Hippolytus of Rome calculated a world chronology ending ca. 500 AD (var. traditions tie this to Christ’s return). Source: Hippolytus, Chronicon fragments; McGinn, Visions of the End. (Zero Dispute Note)
Z22: Irenaeus and Sextus Julius Africanus are associated with schemes that allowed an end circa year 500. Source: Irenaeus, Against Heresies V; Africanus, Chronographiai (fragments via Eusebius/Jerome). (Zero Dispute Note)
Z23: Hilary of Poitiers is linked in later testimony to imminentist expectation in his era (not a precisely dated “365” oracle in his own hand). Source: Jerome/Sulpicius Severus traditions; scholarly consensus qualifies precision. (Zero Dispute Note)
Z24: Martin of Tours is credited with the statement that Antichrist had already been born and expectation before 400 AD. Source: Sulpicius Severus, Dialogi II; McGinn, Antichrist: Two Thousand Years of the Human Fascination with Evil, 1994. (Zero Dispute Note)
Z25: Beatus of Liébana advanced apocalyptic interpretations culminating in 793. Source: Beatus, Commentary on the Apocalypse; historical introductions. (Zero Dispute Note)
Z26: Thiota (847) publicly prophesied the end and was punished after recantation. Source: Contemporary annals noted in R. Landes surveys; MGH sources. (Zero Dispute Note)
Z27: Pope Innocent III speculated that 1284 (≈666 years after Muhammad’s preaching) could mark the end. Source: Innocent III, De Contemptu Mundi; cited in standard apocalyptic timelines. (Zero Dispute Note)
Z28: Black Death (1347–1351) provoked apocalyptic interpretations by figures such as Jean de Roquetaillade and Arnaldus de Villa Nova (late medieval prophetic currents). Source: Cohn, Pursuit of the Millennium; McGinn, Visions of the End. (Zero Dispute Note)
Z29: In Muscovy, the year 1492 (anno mundi 7000 by Byzantine reckoning) was treated by some elites and clerics as ominous. Source: Janet Martin, Medieval Russia; Muscovite chronicles survey. (Zero Dispute Note)
Z30: Botticelli’s Mystical Nativity contains an apocalyptic inscription expressing tribulation-era belief ca. 1500. Source: National Gallery (London) notes; art-historical consensus. (Zero Dispute Note)
Z31: London astrologers forecast a destructive flood for 1 Feb 1524; many Londoners relocated that day; no flood occurred. Source: Contemporary broadsides/chronicles; Ian Mortimer (popular histories summarizing records). (Zero Dispute Note)
Z32: Johannes Stöffler predicted calamity associated with 1524 planetary alignments; it failed. Source: Stöffler’s prognostications summarized in astronomical histories. (Zero Dispute Note)
Z33: Thomas Müntzer proclaimed imminent eschaton during the 1524–1525 upheavals; his revolt was crushed in 1525. Source: Peter Blickle, The Revolution of 1525; primary letters/sermons. (Zero Dispute Note)
Z34: Hans Hut predicted the end for 27 May 1528; he died before the date; the prophecy failed. Source: Anabaptist martyrologies; early modern records summarized in standard histories. (Zero Dispute Note)
Z35: Michael Stifel predicted Judgment Day at 8:00 a.m., 19 Oct 1533; the date passed uneventfully. Source: Stifel’s Ein Rechenbüchlein vom Endchrist; Reformation reference works. (Zero Dispute Note)
Z36: Melchior Hoffman predicted Christ’s return to Strasbourg in 1533 with 144,000 elect; he died in prison; prediction failed. Source: Early Reformation apocalyptic studies; city records. (Zero Dispute Note)
Z37: Jan Matthys proclaimed apocalypse for 5 April 1534 at Münster; he was killed; the regime collapsed in 1535. Source: Münster Rebellion chronicles; standard Reformation histories. (Zero Dispute Note)
Z38: Pierre d’Ailly’s calculations were read by some as pointing to 1555; no apocalypse ensued. Source: d’Ailly, Concordantia Astronomiae cum Theologia; apocalyptic surveys. (Zero Dispute Note)
Z39: Martin Luther voiced expectations that the end would come within his century (often paraphrased as “by 1600”); it did not. Source: Luther’s prefaces/sermons; apocalyptic motif in Reformation scholarship. (Zero Dispute Note)
Z40: John Napier gave dates 1688 and 1700 in his apocalyptic computations. Source: Napier, A Plaine Discovery of the Whole Revelation of St John (1593). (Zero Dispute Note)
Z41: Joseph Mede proposed 1660 within his prophetic timetables. Source: Mede, Clavis Apocalyptica (1627). (Zero Dispute Note)
Z42: Sabbatai Zevi (a Jewish messianic claimant) set expectations for 1648 then 1666; he later converted to Islam; Christian readers tracked these dates. Source: Gershom Scholem, Sabbatai Sevi, Princeton, 1973. (Zero Dispute Note)
Z43: The Fifth Monarchists anticipated Christ’s reign mid-17th century (esp. 1655–1657); it failed. Source: Bernard Capp, The Fifth Monarchy Men, 1972. (Zero Dispute Note)
Z44: Cotton Mather put forward dates 1697, 1716, and 1736; none occurred. Source: Mather’s The Wonders of the Invisible World & later works; Puritan apocalyptic studies. (Zero Dispute Note)
Z45: William Whiston predicted a 1736 cometary catastrophe; it did not happen. Source: Whiston’s writings; Enlightenment popular science histories. (Zero Dispute Note)
Z46: Emanuel Swedenborg taught that the Last Judgment occurred spiritually in 1757, not as a visible world-ending event. Source: Swedenborg, The Last Judgment (1758). (Zero Dispute Note)
Z47: The Shakers anticipated the end in 1792 and again in 1794; it did not occur. Source: Stephen J. Stein, The Shaker Experience in America, 1992. (Zero Dispute Note)
Z48: Richard Brothers predicted the end in the 1790s; he was confined as insane; prophecy failed. Source: J. Hopkins, Richard Brothers: Prophet of ‘The Jews’, biographical surveys. (Zero Dispute Note)
Z49: William Miller predicted 1843, then recalculations leading to 22 Oct 1844; all failed; “Great Disappointment” ensued. Source: David Arthur, A House Divided: Adventism, denominational histories; primary broadsides. (Zero Dispute Note)
Z50: Some Millerites disposed of property in expectation of 1844; many were left disillusioned. Source: Sylvester Bliss, Memoirs of William Miller; contemporary press. (Zero Dispute Note)
Z51: George Rapp of the Harmony Society expected Christ’s return in his lifetime; he died in 1847 without fulfillment. Source: Karl J. R. Arndt, George Rapp’s Harmony Society. (Zero Dispute Note)
Z52: John Cumming published end-time forecasts for the 1860s (incl. 1862); none occurred. Source: Cumming’s prophetic works; Victorian religious press. (Zero Dispute Note)
Z53: Joseph Morris (Morrisites) issued failed 1860s prophetic dates; schism and tragedy followed. Source: Thomas G. Alexander, Utah religious histories; court records. (Zero Dispute Note)
Z54: John Wroe (Christian Israelite Church) set 1860s dates (incl. 1863); failed. Source: Biographies of Wroe; sect histories. (Zero Dispute Note)
Z55: Charles Taze Russell associated prophetic expectations with 1874 (invisible presence), 1914, 1918, and 1925; dates were reinterpreted after failures. Source: Watch Tower publications; secondary histories (Zydek, Penton). (Zero Dispute Note)
Z56: Jehovah’s Witnesses widely promoted 1975 as a significant Armageddon expectation; it failed. Source: Watchtower articles (1966–1975) and later organizational acknowledgments. (Zero Dispute Note)
Z57: Herbert W. Armstrong and the Worldwide Church of God circulated multiple date windows (1930s–1970s); none materialized. Source: WCG literature; evangelical counter-cult histories. (Zero Dispute Note)
Z58: Dorothy Martin (aka Marian Keech) predicted a 1954 flood/apocalypse; the group’s failure became a classic case study in cognitive dissonance. Source: Leon Festinger et al., When Prophecy Fails, 1956. (Zero Dispute Note)
Z59: Edgar Whisenant’s 88 Reasons Why the Rapture Will Be in 1988 sold in the millions and failed; he published revisions (1989, 1993, 1994). Source: Contemporary press; evangelical publishing tallies (figures commonly reported at ~4–4.5M). (Zero Dispute Note)
Z60: Harold Camping forecast May 21, 2011, then October 21, 2011; both failed; in 2012 he issued a written apology for date-setting. Source: Family Radio statements; major media coverage. (Zero Dispute Note)
Z61: The “Revelation 12 sign” dates (2017) were widely circulated online; predicted raptures failed. Source: Digital religion studies; media archives. (Zero Dispute Note)
Z62: The September 23–24, 2025 Rapture date has been publicly claimed by Joshua Mhlakela (Johannesburg) in recorded interviews. Source: Public video interviews posted mid-2025. (Zero Dispute Note)
Z63: Joshua Mhlakela self-published an 8-page e-book titled Rapture 23/24 September 2025 for sale on Google Play at low price-point. Source: Google Play Books listing. (Zero Dispute Note)
Z64: Social-media amplification (YouTube, TikTok, X/Reddit) has driven awareness of the 2025 claim. Source: Platform analytics and visible posting waves (August–September 2025). (Zero Dispute Note)
Z65: Monetization pathways for such claims include ad revenue, donations, merchandise, and micro-priced e-books. Source: Platform policies; prior case studies (Whisenant 1988; Camping 2011). (Zero Dispute Note)
Z66: Reports periodically surface (Africa and elsewhere) of adherents selling possessions ahead of predicted dates; documentation exists across multiple failed-prophecy movements. Source: Press reports; sociological studies of apocalyptic movements. (Zero Dispute Note)
Z67: There is no credible biblical warrant for precise date-setting; Matthew 24:36 explicitly denies knowledge of “day or hour.” Source: The Holy Bible, Matthew 24:36; mainstream exegesis. (Zero Dispute Note)
Z68: Failed prophecies frequently produce pastoral damage: disillusionment, financial loss, relational strain. Source: Festinger et al.; Cohn; case studies in modern sectarian fallout. (Zero Dispute Note)
Z69: Historic Christian teaching calls believers to readiness and faithfulness rather than calendrical prediction. Source: Catechetical summaries; mainstream evangelical, Catholic, and Orthodox catechesis. (Zero Dispute Note)
Z70: The cycle “new date → hype → failure → reframe” is a documented pattern across two millennia of Christian (and para-Christian) apocalypticism. Source: McGinn; Cohn; Landes. (Zero Dispute Note)
Got it — under COACH Rules 28 we need at least 5 POPs (Parallel Orthodox Perspectives) and 5 SCOPs (Skeptical or Contrary Opinion Points).
Here’s a draft set built to fit your millennium-fears episode:
Reference POP (Parallel Orthodox Perspectives)
Reference SCOP (Skeptical or Contrary Opinion Points)
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. Master Amazon Link Coming Soon
Perfect — thanks for uploading the rules. I’ll build Chunks 10–13 exactly as required under COACH Rules — Version 28.
Chunk 10 – Equipment (stagnant)
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. Master Amazon Link Coming Soon
Chunk 11 – Credits (stagnant, verbatim)
Producer: That’s Jesus Channel
Topic Support: Assisted by Copilot (Microsoft Corp) for aligning topics to timelines
Research Support: Assisted by Perplexity.ai (AI Chatbot) for facts and sources
Script Support: Assisted by ChatGPT (OpenAI) for script pacing and coherence
Verification Support: Assisted by Grok (xAI) for fact-checking and validation
Digital License: Audio 1 – Background Music: “Background Music Soft Calm” by INPLUSMUSIC, Pixabay Content License, Composer: Poradovskyi Andrii (BMI IPI Number: 01055591064), Source: Pixabay, YouTube: INPLUSMUSIC Channel, Instagram: @inplusmusic
Digital License: Audio 2 – Crescendo: “Epic Trailer Short 0022 Sec” by BurtySounds, Pixabay Content License, Source: Pixabay
Digital License: Audio Visualizer: “Digital Audio Spectrum Sound Wave Equalizer Effect Animation, Alpha Channel Transparent Background, 4K Resolution” by Vecteezy, License: Free License (Attribution Required), Source: Vecteezy
Production Note: Audio and video elements integrated in post-production without in-script cues.
Chunk 12 – Social Links (verbatim until updated)
Listen on PodLink: https://www.pod.link/1823151072
Official Podcast Webpage (Podbean): https://thatsjesuschannel.podbean.com/
YouTube (That’s Jesus Channel): https://www.youtube.com/@ThatsJesusChannel
YouTube – COACH Playlist: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLJdTG9noRxsEKpmDoPX06VtfGrB-Hb7T4
Facebook Page: https://www.facebook.com/BobBaulchPage
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/thatsjesuschannel
Threads: [ADD URL]
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@thatsjesuschannel
X (Twitter): https://twitter.com/ThatsJesusChan
Pinterest: https://www.pinterest.com/thatsjesuschannel
Website/Show Notes: https://thatsjesus.org
Newsletter Signup: [ADD URL]
Contact: [email protected]
RSS Feed: https://feed.podbean.com/thatsjesuschannel/feed.xml
Discord: [ADD URL]
WhatsApp Channel: [ADD URL]
Telegram: [ADD URL]
Reddit: [ADD URL]
Chunk 13 – Small Group Guide
Summary: Around the years 1000 and 1033, fears of the world’s end stirred Europe. Chronicles speak of omens, pilgrimages, and renewed charity. The failure of those dates reminds us that history is littered with failed prophecies, yet God’s call is for readiness, not speculation.
Application: Live each day as though Christ could return at any moment—not with fear, but with faithfulness in your daily walk.
Prayer Point: Pray for discernment to focus on Christ’s call to readiness rather than speculation about dates and signs.
