Six friends set out for a night of fun in Opp, Alabama, in May 1999, but they never made it home. James “Amp” Reynolds and his friends were last seen leaving the Hideaway Club around 3:15 AM, piling into a newly souped-up Chevy Caprice. When they failed to return, their families immediately raised the alarm. Months of desperate searching led to a heartbreaking discovery—Lamar Stackhouse’s car submerged in the Pea River, with five bodies inside. But one was missing: Amp. Despite extensive searches and mounting theories, no trace of him was ever found. Over two decades later, the mystery of Amp’s disappearance lingers, leaving his family still searching for answers. Join Ali as she goes over this mysterious case.

***If you have any information about James ‘Amp’ Reynolds disappearance in May of 1999 - or his whereabouts today - please call Sargent Simon Bentsen at 251-578-1315 ***

Sources:

The Dothan Eagle, Pensacola News Journal, The Montgomery Advertiser, The Anniston Star, and Birmingham Post-Herald

Wanna Connect?

• Follow us on instagram @Cold_and_Missing to keep up with active cases and see pictures discussed in the episode
• Have a case you want us to cover? Want to tell us your thoughts about an episode? Email us at [email protected]

• Wanna support our work? https://www.buymeacoffee.com/ColdandMissing
• Check out our website at www.Coldandmissing.com