By Ali McLaughlin & Eli Sulkowski
Cold and Missing focuses exclusively on cold cases and unsolved missing person cases. Every week Ali and Eli - a husband and wife duo- will bring you either a Cold Case or a unresolved missing pers
... more
4.6
6666 ratings
The podcast currently has 105 episodes available.
In this episode of Cold and Missing, we cover the heartbreaking case of nine-year-old Stephanie Crane, who vanished from Challis, Idaho, on October 11, 1993. After a seemingly ordinary day at school and afternoon bowling, Stephanie was last seen walking back towards the school rather than her towards her home. Concern grew as night fell and she didn't return, prompting her parents to report her missing. The ensuing search mobilized the entire community, but despite extensive efforts—no trace of Stephanie was found. Over the years, the case grew colder, impacting Stephanie's family profoundly, and despite ongoing interest and renewed investigations over the years, her whereabouts remain a mystery.
***If you know anything about the disappearance of Stephanie Crane in October 1993 - or her whereabouts today - please call the Custer county sheriff department at 208-879-2232***
Sources:
The Idaho Statesman, The Times-News, Bonner County Daily Bee, South Idaho Press, The Coeur D’Alene Press, and The East Idaho News
Wanna Connect?
In this episode of Cold and Missing, we delve into the tragic case of 8-year-old Debra "Debbie" Makel, who went missing on October 5, 1973, from Rices Landing, PA. After a seemingly ordinary day at school, Debbie vanished shortly after getting off the bus, leaving her family and community in shock. Despite extensive searches, her body was found two days later, revealing a heartbreaking crime scene that shook the small town. Despite officers running down every lead and tip that came in the case went cold. With advancements in DNA technology, hope remains that new evidence could finally bring justice for Debbie. Join us as we explore the ongoing quest for truth and the enduring impact of this tragedy.
***If you know anything about the murder of Debbie Makel in 1973 please call the PSP Waynesburg Station at 724-627-6151***
Sources:
The Progress, The Evening Standard, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, The Daily Notes, The Daily Courier, The Morning Herald, The Philadelphia Inquirer, The Evening News, The Daily American, Standard-Speaker, The Indiana Gazette, and The Pittsburgh Press
Wanna Connect?
In this episode of Cold and Missing, we delve into the heart-wrenching case of Jaquilla Scales, a 4-year-old girl who vanished from her Wichita home in September 2001. Described by those who knew her as having an “old soul,” Jaquilla lived with her great-grandmother Mattie, her mother Eureka, and her younger brother in a small pink house. On the night of her disappearance, Jaquilla vanished from the bed she was sleeping in. She had been seen throughout the night but by 3am she’s gone. As the search for Jaquilla unfolded, it was overshadowed by the tragic events of 9/11, but efforts continued behind the scenes. Jaquilla’s family have remained firm in their hope that she’ll come home one day. Join us as we go over the mysterious disappearance of Jaquilla Scales.
***If you know anything about the disappearance of Jaquilla Scales in Sept 2001 - or her whereabouts today - please call the Wichita police at 316-268-4379***
Sources:
The Wichita Eagle, The Salina Journal, and The Iola Register,
Wanna Connect?
On May 16, 2003, a shocking crime unfolded at Blue Ridge Savings Bank in Greer, South Carolina. Sylvia Holtzclaw, the head teller known for her dedication to her community, was working a full day due to a coworker’s illness. Tragically, she, along with Dr. James ‘Eb’ Barnes and his wife Maggie Barnes, were murdered during a robbery. Despite the presence of a silent alarm and security footage, the perpetrator - or perpetrators- managed to escape, leaving the police and FBI with few clues. A red car captured on a nearby gas station's camera and an array of leads failed to resolve the case. Over time, various suspects came under scrutiny, but none were definitively linked to the crime. Join Ali and Eli as they go through the case.
***If you know anything about the murder of Sylvia Holtzclaw, Eb Barnes, and Maggie Barnes - please call the FBI office in Greenville at 803-551-4200 or the Greer police department at 864-848-2151***
Sources:
The Greenville News, The Time and Democrat, The State, Anderson Independent-Mail, Sentinel Tribune, The Index-Journal, and The Herald.
Wanna Connect?
In this episode, we dive into the mysterious disappearance of Larissa Sam, a talented 22-year-old mother and aspiring American Idol contestant who vanished on June 21, 2015. Larissa, known for her vibrant personality, was last seen leaving her uncle's house after a late shift at The Classy Chassy - a club in Indianapolis. Her car was found abandoned, but with clues that led to more questions than answers. Despite intense searches, a chilling security video, and multiple leads, including a troubling social media post about her being taken abroad, the case remains unsolved. Her family and the FBI continue their search, hoping for any breakthrough in this heart-wrenching mystery.
***If you know anything about the disappearance of Larissa Sam or whereabouts today - please call the FBI Indianapolis office at 317-595-4000 or the Indianapolis Metropolitan Police Department missing persons unit at 317-327-6160***
To hear Larissa sing check out her video:
https://youtu.be/bBK858_y53I?si=5h_hghtxdyUVU249
Sources:
The Daily Journal, The Indianapolis Star, Tipton County Tribune, WTHR 13, and Fox 59
Wanna Connect?
In this episode, we delve into the unsettling case of Hasan Rahman, a 26-year-old mechanical engineering student from Bangladesh, who was found murdered in Wichita, Kansas, in November 2017. Hasan was known for his kindness and dedication as a community volunteer and part-time pizza delivery driver. He disappeared after making deliveries on a busy Saturday night. His body was discovered in the trunk of his car the following morning, sparking a baffling investigation. Despite a thorough search, including a $10,000 reward from Pizza Hut, no suspects were identified, and the case went cold. Adding to the mystery, his murder was linked to a nearby double homicide of Huong Pham and her son Cody Ha, though the connection remains unclear. With few leads and a community in shock, Hasan’s family and friends are left seeking answers.
***If you know anything about the murder of Hasan Rahman, Huong Pham, and Cody Ha please call Witchita detectives at 316-268-4407***
Sources:
KWCH 12 news, The Wichita Eagle, Los Angeles Times, KSN News, The Sunflower, and Daily Mail
Wanna Connect?
In the summer of 2023, 13-year-old James Yoblonski from Reedsburg, Wisconsin, vanished under mysterious circumstances. On June 12, after a seemingly normal evening, James left his home in the family van, taking a backpack, duffle bags, and several items from his father’s belongings. Surveillance footage tracked him to his father’s business and then to Devil’s Lake State Park, where his abandoned van and makeshift campsite were later discovered. Despite extensive searches by police, including helicopters and canine units, no concrete evidence of James' whereabouts emerged. As weeks turned into months, the search expanded to include electronic and search history analysis, but James remained missing. His father, Bill, believes his son is still alive and desperately wants James to come home. Join Ali and Eli as we get into this heartbreaking case.
***If you know anything about the disappearance of Jason Yoblonski - or his whereabouts today - please call the Sauk County Sheriff’s Office at 608-356-4895 ***
GoFundMe started by James’ dad:
https://www.gofundme.com/f/please-help-to-find-my-son
Sources:
Baraboo News Republic, Wisconsin State Journal, The Post-Crescent, Portage Daily Register, WISN12, and WKOW,
Wanna Connect?
In this episode, we dive into the haunting case of Connie Hiner, a woman whose life seemed to be on the brink of perfection before a shocking tragedy struck. In January 1996, the day she was supposed to start her dream job, Connie was found brutally murdered in her upscale Virginia home. With no signs of forced entry and a crime scene that suggested a crime of passion, the investigation quickly turned the spotlight on her husband, Bob Hiner. Was he involved, or is there another suspect? As we unravel the details, from Connie’s dramatic rise to success and later involvement in a controversial self-help program, this episode covers the only cold case for Fairfax county from 1996.
***If you know anything about the murder of Connie Hiner in January of 1996 please call the Fairfax county police at 703-246-7511***
Sources:
Washington Times, The Washington post, News and Messenger, and The Daily Times
Wanna Connect?
In this episode, we delve into the mysterious disappearance of Kevin Jay Ayotte, a three-year-old boy from Bemidji, Minnesota, in 1982. Kevin, who was partially deaf and unable to vocalize, vanished alongside his beloved puppy, Flash, triggering a massive search effort involving over 200 volunteers and law enforcement agencies, including the FBI. Despite extensive searches spanning thousands of acres no sign of Kevin or his puppy are found. It was initially uncertain whether an abduction or a tragic accident had taken place but over time police do shift to abduction. Listen as we explore the twists and turns of this haunting cold case. .
***If you know anything about the disappearance of Kevin Jay Ayotte - or his whereabouts today - Beltrami County Sheriff's Office (Minnesota) - Missing Persons Unit (1-218-751-9111)
sources:
St. Cloud Times, The Winona Daily News, Star Tribune, The Austin Daily Herald, Argus-Leader, The Bismarck Tribune, The Albert Lea Tribune, Richmond Times-Dispatch, The Evening Times, Transcript-Telegram, News 8 Now, KSTP, and 5 eyewitness news
Wanna Connect?
This episode delves into the tragic and mysterious murder of Julia Niswender, a vibrant 23-year-old student at Eastern Michigan University whose life was cut short in December 2012. Julia, known for her bright personality and close bond with her twin sister Jennifer, was found drowned in her bathtub under suspicious circumstances. Despite initial hesitation to call the crime a murder, Julia's body did show signs of restraint and the crime scene left little question, the case quickly turned into a homicide investigation. Over the years, as police pursued leads and family demanded justice, unsettling details emerged, including DNA evidence and the disappearance of crucial items like a rug from Julia's apartment. Now, a decade later, Julia's family continues to seek answers, advocating for a resolution and questioning the progress of the investigation. This episode explores the chilling details of Julia's case and the ongoing quest for closure.
***If you know anything about the murder of Julie Niswender- please call crime stoppers at 1-800-773-2587***
Sources: WXYZ 7, WTVG, Detroit Free Press, The Herald-Palladium, Livingston County Daily Press and Argus, Lansing State Journal, The Tennessean, The TImes Herald, Battle Creek Enquirer
Wanna Connect?
The podcast currently has 105 episodes available.
3,293 Listeners
2,433 Listeners
15,403 Listeners
3,113 Listeners
3,944 Listeners
1,312 Listeners
4,014 Listeners
8,696 Listeners
708 Listeners
224 Listeners
466 Listeners
704 Listeners
280 Listeners
255 Listeners
236 Listeners