In this gripping episode, we delve into the mysterious disappearance of one-month-old Tavish Sutton, who was abducted from his hospital room at Grady Memorial in Atlanta, Georgia, on March 9, 1993. Born to a mother struggling with schizophrenia, Tavish was in foster care and recovering from surgery when he vanished without a trace. Authorities launched an exhaustive investigation, with the FBI profiling a suspect believed to have taken Tavish to raise him as her own. Despite leads, composite sketches, and public appeals, the case went cold, leaving many unanswered questions. Decades later, Tavish’s whereabouts remain unknown, but hope persists that he might still be alive, living under a new identity. Join us as we dive into this unresolved missing person case.

***If you know anything about the disappearance of Tavish Sutton in March of 1993, or his whereabouts today, please call the Atlanta Police Department at 404-546-4235 ***

Sources:

The Atlanta Journal, The Morning Call, Morning Sentinel, The Atlanta Constitution, and The Charley Project

Wanna Connect?

• Follow us on instagram @Cold_and_Missing to keep up with active cases and see pictures discussed in the episode
• Have a case you want us to cover? Want to tell us your thoughts about an episode? Email us at [email protected]

• Wanna support our work? https://www.buymeacoffee.com/ColdandMissing
• Check out our website at www.Coldandmissing.com

Episode Summary:

In this episode, we delve into the tragic and mysterious case of Joyner Ondimu, a 23-year-old Kenyan nursing student living in Newark, Delaware. Known for her big heart, culinary talent, and dedication to helping others, Joyner’s promising life was cut short on February 8, 2005, when she was found murdered in her apartment. The close-knit Kenyan community in Delaware rallied to honor her life and send her body back to Kenya, where the crime garnered international attention. Despite police efforts, Joyner’s case remains unsolved to this day. Join Ali and Eli as we go over this case.

***If you know anything about the murder of Joyner Ondimu in February of 2005 - please contact the New Castle County police cold case squad directly. Det. Josh Smith can be reached at 302-395-8126 or Det. Theresa Williams can be reached at 302-395-8216 ***

Sources;

The News Journal

Wanna Connect?

• Follow us on instagram @Cold_and_Missing to keep up with active cases and see pictures discussed in the episode
• Have a case you want us to cover? Want to tell us your thoughts about an episode? Email us at [email protected]

• Wanna support our work? https://www.buymeacoffee.com/ColdandMissing
• Check out our website at www.Coldandmissing.com

In this episode of Cold and Missing, we dive into the heartbreaking disappearance of 12-year-old Elisa Roberson with her sister Ruby Hall. Elisa vanished from Aransas Pass, Texas, in August 1989. On the evening of August 6, Elisa left home to meet a friend at a nearby elementary school but never arrived. Witnesses saw her on her way, but by the time her family realized something was wrong, Elisa had vanished without a trace. Despite extensive searches, including scent dogs and community efforts, the case went cold. Over the years, there have been leads, anonymous tips, and even an investigation at the family’s former home, but no conclusive answers. Now, over three decades later, Elisa’s family is reigniting their fight for justice, urging new leadership and cold case experts to uncover the truth.

*** If you know anything about the disappearance of Elisa Roberson in August of 1989 or her whereabouts today - place call the Aransas Pass Police department at 361-758-5224 or if you want to leave a tip online you can use the attorney general online tip submission: https://www.texasattorneygeneral.gov/coldcasetips

Wanna Connect?

• Follow us on instagram @Cold_and_Missing to keep up with active cases and see pictures discussed in the episode
• Have a case you want us to cover? Want to tell us your thoughts about an episode? Email us at [email protected]

• Wanna support our work? https://www.buymeacoffee.com/ColdandMissing
• Check out our website at www.Coldandmissing.com

In this year-end recap episode of Cold and Missing, we revisit some of the most compelling cases from our archives, exploring new updates and breakthroughs that have emerged in 2024. We delve into advancements in genetic genealogy and highlight the tireless efforts of law enforcement and advocates keeping these cases alive. Join us as we reflect on the ongoing quest for answers and justice in these unresolved mysteries. This episode is a powerful reminder that no case is truly cold when we keep shining a light on it.

Wanna Connect?

• Follow us on instagram @Cold_and_Missing to keep up with active cases and see pictures discussed in the episode
• Have a case you want us to cover? Want to tell us your thoughts about an episode? Email us at [email protected]

• Wanna support our work? https://www.buymeacoffee.com/ColdandMissing
• Check out our website at www.Coldandmissing.com

In this episode, we explore the mysterious murder of Bruce Cucchiara, a beloved family man, businessman, and community figure in Covington, Louisiana. Bruce’s life was full of success but in April 2012, his life took a tragic turn. On the morning of April 24th, Bruce was found shot in the parking lot of an apartment complex. How he even came to be in that parking lot will have those closest to Bruce wondering why he was there. The case quickly unraveled into a web of questions: was Bruce lured to the complex? Was there a deeper motive behind his death? Join us as we go over this mysterious cold case.

***Anyone with information on Bruce’s case should call Det. Ryan Aucoin 504-658-5300 or you can leave a tip anonymously with Crimestoppers of Greater New Orleans at 504-822-1111***

Sources:

St. Tammany Farmer, The Era-Leader, WGNO, NOPD News, Louisiana Voice, WDSU, And CounterClock Podcast

Wanna Connect?

• Follow us on instagram @Cold_and_Missing to keep up with active cases and see pictures discussed in the episode
• Have a case you want us to cover? Want to tell us your thoughts about an episode? Email us at [email protected]

• Wanna support our work? https://www.buymeacoffee.com/ColdandMissing
• Check out our website at www.Coldandmissing.com

On February 4, 2003, 4-year-old Sofia Juarez went missing in Kennewick, Washington, just hours before her 5th birthday. She had been playing at home with her uncle before asking to go to the store with her grandmother's boyfriend, Jose. But when Jose returned home without her, the family’s frantic search revealed no sign of Sofia. Despite a statewide Amber Alert—the first of its kind in Washington—the search for Sofia, including the use of bloodhounds and extensive neighborhood canvassing, yielded no leads. Over the weeks, the investigation revealed conflicting details, including a witness who reported seeing Sofia being led away by a suspect to a van shortly before her disappearance. Various suspect vehicles and individuals were investigated, yet Sofia’s whereabouts remain unknown. In the years since, the case has included numerous tips, a failed search of a local farm, and even a viral TikTok video that briefly reignited hope. As of late 2024, Sofia’s case remains unsolved, with authorities continuing to investigate every tip. The Juarez family, still seeking answers, continues to hold out hope for Sofia’s safe return.

***If you know thing about the disapperance of SOfia Juarez - or her whereabouts today - please call special investigator Al Wehner at 509-582-1331***

Or you can leave a tip online using the following form:

https://www.go2kennewick.com/FormCenter/Police-Dept-Forms-10/Leave-a-Tip-on-Sofia-Juarez-142

Sources:

The Oregonian, Tri-City Herald, The Columbian, Longview Daily News, The Spokesman-Review, The News Tribune, Statesman Journal, and The Kennewick Police Department Website

Wanna Connect?

• Follow us on instagram @Cold_and_Missing to keep up with active cases and see pictures discussed in the episode
• Have a case you want us to cover? Want to tell us your thoughts about an episode? Email us at [email protected]

• Wanna support our work? https://www.buymeacoffee.com/ColdandMissing
• Check out our website at www.Coldandmissing.com

In this episode, we dive into the chilling and mysterious deaths of two elderly women at Riverside Health Care Center in Missoula, Montana, in 1990. Bertha Scott, an 85-year-old Alzheimer’s patient, was found dead in her bed in May, with initial reports suggesting natural causes. But nearly two months later, 87-year-old Nancy Lagerquist was discovered brutally murdered, her body found in the Clark Fork River after she went missing from the same facility. What initially seemed like isolated incidents soon began to unravel into a sinister pattern, revealing that both women had been victims of violent assaults. As detectives piece together the eerie clues—an open window, a suspicious man seen near the facility, and a mysterious DNA profile—they race against time to uncover the truth. Was there a connection between these two deaths, and if so, who did it? Join us as we explore this unresolved case that continues to haunt Missoula.

***If you know anything about the murder of Bertha Scott and Nancy Lagerquist in 1990 please call the Missoula County Sheriff’s office at 406-258-3302 ***

Sources:

The Missoulian, The Billings Gazette, The Daily Inter Lake, The Havre Daily News, And Great Falls Tribune

Newsnew

Wanna Connect?

• Follow us on instagram @Cold_and_Missing to keep up with active cases and see pictures discussed in the episode
• Have a case you want us to cover? Want to tell us your thoughts about an episode? Email us at [email protected]

• Wanna support our work? https://www.buymeacoffee.com/ColdandMissing
• Check out our website at www.Coldandmissing.com

In May 1989, 9-year-old Jenna Ray Robbins disappeared from her home in Killeen, Texas. On Mother’s Day, while playing with her friend outside, a man in a gray car lured Jenna away with promises of gifts. Local, state and federal officers helped search for Jenna but searchers could not locate her. Though flyers featuring Jenna's image were distributed across the country, and despite tips pouring in from all over, no solid leads emerged. As years passed, her mother held onto hope that her daughter was still alive, and continued to pray for her safe return. Join Ali and Eli as they get into this missing person case.

***If you know anything about the disappearance of Jenna Ray Robbins - or her whereabouts today - please call Bell COunty Crime Stoppers at 254-526-8477***

Sources:

Merced Sun-Star, Fort Worth Star-Telegram, Star Tribune, and Killeen Daily Harold.

Wanna Connect?

• Follow us on instagram @Cold_and_Missing to keep up with active cases and see pictures discussed in the episode
• Have a case you want us to cover? Want to tell us your thoughts about an episode? Email us at [email protected]

• Wanna support our work? https://www.buymeacoffee.com/ColdandMissing
• Check out our website at www.Coldandmissing.com

We wanted to bring you a quick update on the case we covered last week on Pat Shea. Ali had the chance to connect with Pat’s nephew, Kevin Shea, who added additional details about the case and cleared up some facts. Join us for a quick a quick update and correction.

***If you know anything about the murder of Pat Shea in July of 1982 please call the current lead Det. Annamarie Berngozzi 212-239-2256 ***

Wanna Connect?

• Follow us on instagram @Cold_and_Missing to keep up with active cases and see pictures discussed in the episode
• Have a case you want us to cover? Want to tell us your thoughts about an episode? Email us at [email protected]

• Wanna support our work? https://www.buymeacoffee.com/ColdandMissing
• Check out our website at www.Coldandmissing.com

In this episode, we explore the tragic and mysterious 1982 murder of Patricia "Pat" Shea, a beloved 40-year-old physician's assistant from Rockaway Beach, Queens, New York. Pat was known for her kindness and dedication to helping others, including her elderly neighbor with dementia, Aggie. On the evening of July 25th, after returning from a weekend getaway, Pat went to check on Aggie, and the next day, she was found murdered in Brooklyn’s Prospect Park, hogtied, strangled, and left in a conspicuous spot. While the case initially raised suspicions of a serial connection to other strangulation murders in the city, police struggled to find any clear links or leads. Despite an extensive investigation, including witness statements, vague clues, and a mysterious anonymous tip in 2021, Pat’s murder remains unsolved. Her family, particularly her nephew Kevin, continues to seek justice. However, the trail remains cold, and the truth behind Pat’s brutal death still eludes those trying to uncover it.

***If you know anything about the murder of Pat Shea in July of 1982 please call the current lead Det. Annamarie Berngozzi 212-239-2256 ***

Sources:

Daily News, Newsday, The Standard-Star, The Herald Statesman, The Wave, PIX11, and The New York Times

Wanna Connect?

• Follow us on instagram @Cold_and_Missing to keep up with active cases and see pictures discussed in the episode
• Have a case you want us to cover? Want to tell us your thoughts about an episode? Email us at [email protected]

• Wanna support our work? https://www.buymeacoffee.com/ColdandMissing
• Check out our website at www.Coldandmissing.com