Title: “Unqualified Teachers” Part 2
Text: James 3:5b-12
FCF: We often struggle bridling our tongue.
Prop: Because the tongue is by nature destructive and hard to control, we must not flippantly desire to be teachers.
Scripture Intro: LSB
[Slide 1] Turn in your bible to James chapter 3.
Last week we began James’ next lack. A lack that God is using trials to purge from James’ audience. In that process, if their faith is genuine, it will persevere and will be matured.
This next lack is their lack of control over their tongue.
But in order to understand what James is saying… we have to remember all that he has said. Particularly what he has said recently.
If we don’t put James 2:14-26 behind this entire discussion. If we aren’t thinking with the backdrop of comparing a dead and lifeless profession with a faith proven by obedience and good works. Then we will quickly start to wonder if James has some sort of split personality disorder. Why?
Because, he plays hopscotch with several themes throughout this chapter.
Is the tongue a good thing or bad thing? Is one able to control it or not? What does our control or lack of control imply?
For instance – in this discussion of the tongue – last week the tongue was capable of guiding the church. It was the gateway to bridling the entire person. Certainly – a good thing, yes?
Yet today James will paint it as a very terrible thing.
And just when we think that we can say – yes our tongues are capable of both great good and great evil – James says – IT OUGHT NOT BE THIS WAY! It should be one way or the other.
That is why, as one commentator aptly observed, this passage is a riddle. A riddle that we must seek to solve.
I am in James 3, I’ll begin reading in verse 1 again. I am reading from the Legacy Standard Bible, but you can follow along in the pew bible on page 1362 or in whatever version you prefer.
Transition:
[Slide 2] Add 5 to 9 and get 2. The answer is correct, so what am I? This is an example of a riddle. The nature of a riddle is to make a statement that seems to not make sense. In order to solve such a discrepancy, you must perceive the statement as more than the sum of its parts. In this case, the statement appears to be a simple math problem. We add 9 to 5 and get 14. Yet the answer is 2. But what if we weren’t adding raw integers, but were adding something else? Have you figured out the answer?
[Slide 3] Yes! A clock. A clock only uses up to the integer 12. Adding 5 to 9 would take us past 12 and reset us at 1 before taking us to 2. In a similar way, James will make statements in this context that seem to contradict what he has already said. Therefore, we must look for missing pieces of information, in order to solve the riddle.
I.) Because the tongue is by nature destructive, we must not flippantly desire to be teachers. (5b-6)
a. [Slide 4] 5b – Behold how great a forest is set aflame by such a small fire!
i. James interrupted a series of illustrations about the tongue to comment that the tongue, though being a small member, boasts of great things.
ii. We saw last week that this statement is either neutral or even a positive statement.
iii. Afterall, the illustrations he has made up to this point have been positive.
1. A small bit controls the whole horse guiding it in the way it should go.
2. A small rudder controls the whole ship guiding it in the way it should go.
iv. So, for the tongue to boast of great things – is not necessarily of evil things.
v. As we saw last week, pointed toward teachers, a teacher can use his tongue as an effective tool to guide the whole congregation or even to bridle his entire person.
vi. This week, James continues illustrating the capabilities of the little member called the tongue.
vii. However, this next illustration takes us in an obvious negative direction.
viii. How much fire is necessary to set a whole forest ablaze? How dangerous is a floating ember next to a dry cornfield ready for harvest? How small a spark is required to ignite a powder keg?
ix. This is the image James conjures to our mind.
x. Such a little flame can do an inordinate amount of damage – can it not?
xi. At first, the illustration is not clear. Why is James suddenly talking about forest fires?
b. [Slide 5] 6 – And the tongue is a fire, the very world of unrighteousness;
i. That’s why.
ii. The tongue is a fire.
iii. The tongue is the small member that is able to cause disproportionate catastrophe.
iv. Remember that I said in the introduction that we needed to think about this passage with James 2:14-26 in mind – otherwise we will be very confused. Well, it all starts here.
v. Certainly, if we isolated this one phrase, we could argue that fire is both profitable and destructive. But in the context, James is clearly saying that fire is bad. Very bad actually. Its destructive force reaches heights far beyond its initial creation.
vi. Comparing the tongue directly to fire in this context – we must conclude that the tongue is a terrible thing. For proof of that, we need only keep reading.
vii. This fire that is our tongue, is the very world of unrighteousness.
viii. “the world” is actually a tricky expression. It can mean various things in various contexts.
ix. There is debate on whether it means the order of unrighteousness or the whole of unrighteousness.
x. But as one commentator astutely points out… it doesn’t actually matter because the basic meaning is the same.
xi. The tongue’s sin capacity extends to the full gamut of all that we might call unrighteousness.
xii. A similar expression is stated by Paul when he says that the love of money is the root of all evil.
xiii. There is no category of evil that cannot be reached by the love of money.
xiv. In the same way, there is no category of unrighteousness, no destination of wickedness, that our tongues cannot reach.
xv. If James sees our tongue or our speech as this great evil – how could he have suggested that it was capable of good at all?
xvi. I believe James gives us a clue to interpreting his riddle in the next three phrases.
xvii. Let’s look at what all three say, and then we will try to answer the riddle.
c. [Slide 6] The tongue is set among our members as that which defiles the entire body,
i. At first glance, this seems to be a contrasting statement to the one in verse 2 in this chapter.
ii. In verse 2 James said that if anyone doesn’t sin with his speech then he is perfect and able to control his entire body. Here James says that sinning with our speech defiles our entire body.
iii. However, there are some key differences in these two expressions making them much more different than they are alike.
1. In verse 2 the verse is set as a conditional statement. If A is true then B is true. And also C. But here there is no condition that needs to be met for B to be true.
2. In verse 2, the responsibility of meeting the condition is placed squarely on the shoulders of the individual. If they do not stumble they are perfect and able to control their entire body. However, here, the tongue, the world of unrighteousness, is set or placed or made among our members.
iv. As we interpreted verse 2 last week, a person who does not stumble with their speech is a mature believer – one who is qualified to teach.
v. The counter point here is not that those who stumble with their speech are an immature believer and unqualified to teach. Instead, James seems to be saying that this is every human’s default position.
vi. Our fire of a tongue, that is the very world of unrighteousness, is placed among our members and it defiles us.
vii. [Slide 7] Go with me to Matthew chapter 15. It is quite small on the screen, so it would be best if you want to follow along to turn there yourself. That is page 1110 in the pew bible.
viii. When we studied the book of I John, one of the things that John said in the opening of that letter, was that all that the apostles taught was from Christ. Because Christ was the Word of God given to us.
ix. Therefore, it shouldn’t be difficult for us to find direct links to what Jesus taught in every single context in which the apostles write.
x. Here is what James is getting at.
xi. Let’s read verses 1-20 and I’ll make some comments
1. Notice the context. The Pharisees and Scribes are insinuating that the disciples of Jesus are ritualistically unclean because they have not washed their hands before eating bread. This idea is an addition to God’s law made from their own traditions.
2. Jesus points out that this tradition is not from God by completely ignoring their critique and asking why they choose to obey tradition which violates God’s law. He cites a particular tradition which allows for someone to give a great sum to the temple in order to avoid giving a greater sum to care for their own parents. Such a tradition was formed and applied by the teachers of the law, enabling people to disobey the command of God to honor father and mother.
3. Jesus then calls them hypocrites and cites Isaiah. Notice what Isaiah says. They honor God with their lips but their hearts are far from Him. In vain they worship, teaching as doctrines the commands of men. So they are confessing the right things but living differently. And specifically, they attempt to worship God while simultaneously teaching things that are in conflict with God’s commands. They confess to believe in honoring father and mother but are condoning practices that allows people to get out of helping them.
4. Then Jesus calls the crowd over and says – what goes out of the mouth is what defiles the man. Defilement, true defilement, does not come from outside but from inside. How we speak defiles us. In their case, it was their teaching of things contrary to God’s commands.
5. The Pharisees took great offense to this statement. To which Jesus said – every fake Christian will be judged. Let them alone. They are unqualified false teachers leading ungodly fake Christians to share their doom.
6. Then Peter asks for Jesus to explain the parable. And I’m glad he did. Even though Jesus points out the slowness of his understanding.
7. Jesus’ point is made plain.
8. What passes our mouths, goes into our stomachs and the waste material is released from us and flushed away. But with our hearts, it works in reverse.
9. The heart is evil, and wicked, and desperate. It is unknowable. It is unpredictable. And out of that heart the mouth speaks.
10. Jesus’ point is that mankind is defiled already.
11. Our heart flushes wicked waste through our mouths.
12. Jesus points out elsewhere that those who believe on Him will not be condemned but those who do not believe on Him are condemned already. Meaning that mankind is defiled already and deserving of wrath. Not believing on Christ is not the catalyst for judgment. Not believing is simply a byproduct. A waste product from a heart already defiled. Simply being human is the catalyst for judgment, because we are all born sinners.
xii. [Slide 8] This is exactly what James seems to be saying here. Natural man’s tongue is the exhaust pipe of the pollution producing idol factory of our hearts.
xiii. And that sludge drips from our lips from before we can even form words. We lie, complain, insult, and express unholy anger – while we are infants in diapers.
xiv. And unqualified teachers, who cannot bridle their tongue, will teach traditions of men and promote their own agendas and opinions rather than teaching the commands of God.
xv. What devastation the natural man’s tongue can do!
d. [Slide 9] And sets on fire the course of our existence,
i. All of our existence, all of human history, every moment of every man’s life…
ii. Is set on fire by our potty mouths. As we spew out all that our hearts flush.
iii. We belch and vomit the deepest wickedness of our hearts, blowing the arrogance of our own traditions and it splatters all over ourselves and it even pollutes the church.
iv. How much black sludge does it take to ruin a pure white robe?
v. So, our tongue sets alight our entire existence, but what about after our natural lives?
e. [Slide 10] And is set on fire by hell.
i. Hell, or Gehenna here typically refers to a place of punishment.
ii. The very fire of our tongues is kindled in the flames of our own judgment.
iii. It is difficult to know whether James is saying that the source of the flame is from hell or the end of the flame is to hell. Perhaps – both is actually true.
iv. Doctrines of demons have prevailed in so called churches since the beginning of Christ’s true church. They have led many astray – but make no mistake – one day they will be burned in the very fire which ignited them in the first place.
f. Coming to the end of this verse, we cannot conclude that James is referring to believers with living and saving faith who are unable to control their tongues.
g. Instead, by context and by the closing argument in verses 10-12, which I know we haven’t even gotten to yet – we must understand James to be speaking of someone who may have a profession of faith – like the Pharisees – but who are using their words to teach traditions, opinions, and/or teachings that contradict God’s law. Like the teaching which said we are saved by faith alone and can live as we wish.
h. These teachers or would be teachers are unable to control their tongue. Thus, not only are they unqualified to teach, but also, their holiness is worthless.
i. Remember, pure and undefiled religion before God is the care of widows and orphans in their oppression and keeping yourself unstained from the world. If indeed our tongues, the very world of unrighteousness, are staining and defiling us… then our holiness is worthless. Our religion is fake.
j. [Slide 11] Passage Truth: James teaches that the natural state of man is to be born already defiled. Humans are born in sin. Human tongues are the window to see the true nature of the heart. Furthermore, the natural man’s tongue is capable of great devastation disproportionate to its physical size. Whether that is false teaching, anger, prejudice, quarrels, gossip, lying, backbiting – all these, and many more, leave devastation in their wake.
k. Passage Application: The command for them in this passage is a carryover from last week. Not many of them should become teachers. Why? Because the tongue is capable of great devastation. If they cannot control it, they could destroy themselves and the church.
l. [Slide 12] Broader Biblical Truth: Does the scripture as a whole teach this truth? Jesus says in Matthew 12:37 that a man will be acquitted or condemned by his words. Yet he also teaches that all men are condemned already and that men speak from the wickedness of the heart. Combining these teachings of Christ, we see this exact truth laid out for us. Our tongues prove who we truly are. They do so by wreaking great catastrophe, the very world of unrighteousness, staining ourselves and others. If our mouth speaks from the heart – and our hearts are naturally desperately wicked and unpredictable – then our words will be desperately wicked and unpredictable as well. What great damage natural man’s words can do. If a person is unqualified to teach since they cannot bridle their tongue, they could do great damage to themselves or even the church. Much like the Pharisees had done to the people of their time. As Jesus described them, they held the keys to the kingdom but neither went in themselves nor did they allow any others to go in. Such is the danger of an unqualified teacher who cannot bridle their tongue.
m. Broader Biblical Application: So CBC, we must be very cautious to desire the office or role of teaching Gods’ Word. Certainly, people are looking to teachers as models to follow. But even arrogance and pride can creep into the words spoken allowing for traditions or opinions to take center stage rather than the glorious gospel of Christ.
Transition:
[Slide 13 (blank)] But is the only danger of the tongue in its destructive power? Is there another layer to this onion?
II.) Because the tongue is by nature indomitable, we must not flippantly desire to be teachers. (7-12)
a. [Slide 14] 7 – For every kind of beasts and birds, of reptiles and creatures of the sea, is tamed and has been tamed by mankind.
i. James either speaks here in exaggerated language or is referring to a time long gone.
ii. Perhaps James is referring to Adam in the garden or even Noah who lived with and cared for two of every kind of animal for about a year.
iii. More likely his point is that mankind has set his mind to taming many different animals and has succeeded in doing so. The Greeks actually drew great pride from the human being, a creature capable of reason, being able to dominate all manner of beasts.
iv. But what about the tiny beast within our mouths?
b. [Slide 15] 8 – But no one can tame the tongue;
i. Once again, we feel the strain of the riddle.
ii. James has already said that if anyone is not able to bridle his tongue then his religion is worthless.
iii. James has said that if someone is able to not stumble in speech then he is a mature believer.
iv. So when James says that no one can tame the tongue, we are immediately perplexed.
v. But, much of the groundwork has been laid to help us interpret this rightly.
vi. Natural man, by the exertion of his own will, can tame many beasts – but the small member of his own body – his tongue – he cannot tame.
vii. It is, as we’ve said, an involuntary window into the status of the soul. And man can never truly hide who they are for very long. Eventually their speech will betray them.
viii. Notice how the Pharisees allowed for and taught that you could give a large sum to the temple in order to not give a larger sum to your parents. How does such a teaching arise as acceptable, if it is not set alight by the fire of greed and selfishness?
ix. But even as believers I think we can conclude the same thing. That were it up to us entirely, we would not be able to tame the tongue either.
x. Augustine comments on this passage and I find his insights astute.
xi. [Slide 16] He says, “He [James] said this not in order that we should tolerate this evil but in order that we should ask for divine grace to tame our tongue.”
xii. In other words, of all men who walk this earth, it is only those whom the Lord promises to give grace in time of need, who can actually tame the tongue. But even then, it is only because of the grace of God.
c. [Slide 17] It is a restless evil and full of deadly poison.
i. Why can no natural man control his window into his soul, called his mouth?
ii. Why can a teacher without a bridled tongue not help from teaching things that contradict God’s commands?
iii. Because the tongue is restless. It is unstable. It is unceasing in motion and fickle.
iv. It wants to be open and vent the deepest depravities of our hearts.
v. And we use it to spew death. It infects and infests us and all who are around us.
vi. Words can turn the most loyal of allies into the vilest rebels. Words can demonize and marginalize those whom we should love and respect. Words can lead a revolution against those we have been told to submit to.
vii. The venom of that old snake is alive and well in the tongues of those who are his children.
d. [Slide 18] 9 – With it we bless our Lord and Father, and with it we curse men, who have been made in the likeness of God.
i. Again, the riddle presents itself.
ii. We might be tempted still to cast this in a view that Christians are vacillating between praising God and cursing others.
iii. But we must first see what it means to curse others. Then we can make the conclusions that we need to.
iv. To curse others is to pronounce judgment upon a person. It is to issue a sentence of divine punishment. It is to say, “Go to hell.” It is to say “be accursed.”
v. Jesus mentions something like this in Matthew 5. He says you have heard it said that whoever murders shall be guilty before the court. But I say to you that everyone who says to his brother “Raca” shall be guilty before the Sanhedrin or “you fool” shall be guilty enough to be thrown into hell.
vi. We pointed out in our study of Matthew – which will have been 6 years ago this April (whoa!) – that to call someone a fool is to essentially call them godless, pagan, and deserving of hell.
vii. This is what it means to curse someone.
viii. Therefore, instead of reading this and seeing this as praising the Lord and saying a bad word, or praising the Lord and insulting someone, we should instead see this as praising the Lord and pronouncing eternal judgment on another person.
ix. Have you heard preachers or teachers stand behind a pulpit and wish someone to burn in hell for their sin? Or perhaps they even express their desire that people suffer harm or death for simply not holding to their man made tradition like a version of the bible or a standard of modesty? Have you heard the satisfaction in their voices as they almost revel in the wrathful end of others made in the image of God? Does God even rejoice in the death of the wicked?
x. It is not possible my friends to truly worship God and also act as the judge of those created in His image.
xi. There is one exception to this which if we have time on Wednesday we can discuss that.
e. [Slide 19] 10 – From the same mouth come blessing and cursing. my brothers, these things ought not to be so.
i. If indeed the tongue cannot be tamed by any man – Christian or otherwise. If indeed, no man is able to control his tongue – then James cannot possibly say that this ought not be.
ii. He may desire it to not be this way! In which case he would have said, “I wish this were not so, my brothers!” But to say, “This ought not be so my brothers” reveals that he believes that those with living faith and those with pure and undefiled religion, should be able to bridle their tongue.
iii. Thus, with these words, he implores them to cleanse themselves of the pollution, the double mindedness. These concepts keep repeating themselves in James. To be double minded, to be stained, to be defiled. James calls them to purify themselves. Why? Because only pure and undefiled holiness is acceptable before God.
iv. And now he sets out to prove this by illustrations from nature.
f. [Slide 20] 11 – Does a fountain pour forth from the same opening fresh and bitter water? 12 – Can a fig tree, my brothers, produce olives, or a vine produce figs? Nor can saltwater produce fresh.
i. We are immediately struck by the same imagery that we have seen in Christ’s teaching.
ii. A good tree produces good fruit and a bad tree bad fruit.
iii. Christ cursed the fruitless fig tree for bearing no fruit.
iv. Christ pronounced woes on the Pharisees for being white washed sepulchers full of dead men’s bones.
v. My friends – a fresh water spring produces fresh water and fig trees produce figs.
vi. So also, a true believer with genuine saving faith will be able to bridle his tongue. Not perfectly – but progressively. A man in Christ will master what unbelievers cannot control. And a man or woman qualified to teach, must be a mature believer – meaning he or she bridles their tongue.
vii. But a fake believer, a false teacher, will eventually be known by the way they praise God with their lips and use the same lips to curse others.
g. [Slide 21] Passage Truth: James with the same base layer of teaching makes a separate point from his first. He reveals that it is man’s nature that determines what flows from their mouth. Indeed, he reaffirms this with his closing illustrations. But the point he adds to this, is not the destructiveness of the tongue, but the indomitability of the tongue. The tongue cannot be tamed. At least not by human will.
h. Passage Application: Therefore, many of them must not be teachers. For their tongues will slip from their hold and reap the whirlwind.
i. [Slide 22] Broader Biblical Truth: Do we see this in the rest of scripture? The psalmist asks the Yahweh by His covenant name to place a guard on his mouth and to protect the opening of his lips in Psalm 141:3. Negatively Proverbs 15:2 says that the fool spouts out folly. Proverbs 18:21 says that death and life are in the power of the tongue. Our tongue is devastating and uncontrollable. Indeed, without the divine help of God almighty we would have no hope to bridle it and keep ourselves from spewing our folly. But for those in Christ, we ought to be different.
j. Broader Biblical Application: So CBC, we must not be hasty to desire the office or role of teaching the Word of God. For a teacher uses his tongue often. But to take such an untamable beast from its cage week in and week out, without relying on the grace of God to contain its bite… to remove it from its shackles, in our hubris thinking we have mastery over it – we will surely see it break loose from us. Only those who have learned to tie their tongue with the strands of God’s grace should consider the role of teaching His word.
Conclusion:
[Slide 23 (end)] So, CBC, what have we learned today and how do we live?
We have learned two very important details about the nature of our tongue. And these two concepts are laid upon 1 foundational principle of doctrine that we must believe.
The first concept about our tongue we actually saw last week.
Last week we saw that a tongue that is under control is a sign that a person is mature in their faith. They have a living and saving faith that has produced a maturity in them. Such people ought to be teachers. They have a valuable asset in their speech – able to guide the church in the truth of God’s Word.
But – From this week, we saw how the tongue while being capable of great good, is perhaps even more capable of terrible devastation. Which wouldn’t be so bad if it were not for it being so unpredictable.
The foundational doctrine that we must see through all this is from James – but really – it is from Christ. What comes out of our mouth will either acquit us before God’s judgment or it will condemn us. Why? Because the mouth is a window to the soul. That which a man speaks, so is he.
So what do we do with this text?
I believe it has a few implications for us.
First, given the nature of the responsibility of teaching the Word of God, it puts an immediate pause on any flippant aspirations toward becoming a teacher of God’s Word.
We spoke a little about this last week, but it is a message worthy of repeating. Friends, our church needs teachers of God’s Word. We need people who will be willing to take God’s Word and teach it to others. We need young men to prayerfully consider whether God may be raising them up to be future Elders of our church. We have 6 Elders right now. But who will be our Elders in 20 years? 30? 40? What about Biblical Counselors? Who will engage young women and men with the Word of God teaching them to live upright lifestyles?
Though the need is great for us to have teachers of the Word… greater still is the need for those teachers to be qualified. And one of the primary qualifications of a teacher of God’s Word is that they are able to bridle their tongues. Not only reigning in their doctrine, but even their anger, their prejudice, their quarrelling, their slander, and their curses.
This leads me to a second point of application.
My friends, we are children of God who have been called out of darkness. James makes it plain that we are new creatures in Christ. Our natures have been changed. We have the Spirit of God living in us. This doesn’t mean we will be perfect. But it does mean that we ought to bridle our tongues. It does mean that we ought to praise God with undefiled lips. We ought to use our words to sow peace and love among God’s people. We ought to confess clear doctrines which we have received from the beginning and not venture into fantasy or niche theological hobby horses.
If it is true that your mouth is the vent for your soul – then vent the love, mercy, trust, hope, peace, and grace that God has filled you with. Let your living faith shine through what you say. Don’t grumble or complain, don’t back bite and destroy, don’t criticize and undermine, don’t sow discord or cause strife, don’t drum your opinions or spout your hubris – but instead be a fountain of living water. So that people might come to your words and hear the glorious gospel of Jesus Christ. That He has made you alive and changed you to be His child.
The whole world can fight and squabble. Indeed, see the news? The world of unrighteousness is quite adept at quarreling and spouting their deeply held opinions. How different we would be if we were to lovingly preach Christ crucified for sinners.
If our mouth flows with the waste of our hearts… let the waste be only the mercy and grace of God that is exceedingly abundantly more than we would ever ask or need. May our cup run over. May we use our words seasoned with grace and sweetened with honey, to build one another up and tear down strongholds of the evil one.
May we all aim to be qualified teachers of the Word of God.