
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


"The return on AI should be the ability to spend more time with people." So why are so many of us working harder than ever?
In Part 2 of his conversation with Jack Myers, author of Your Third Brain, Chris Heuer turns from who's accountable when AI decides to what AI is doing to the rest of us, and what the return on our investment should be. Chris admits the AI dividend he wrote about two years ago has turned into more work and decision fatigue, and he talks about the six months he spent as a canary in the coal mine unable to even land a job interview, and a friend whose backup plan is the back of a Tesla. Jack, entering his eightieth year, sees an incredible opportunity for those he calls Gen Nexus, the first generation born into an AI world. He explains why thinking and judgment may become a human superpower, and what a Costco taught him about community. They end on the space community managers can hold when AI takes the busywork.
Chapters:
0:00 Three brains
1:19 Welcome back to Part 2
1:58 Back in San Francisco, and human flourishing
2:59 Stories from the book, and 10% of your time
5:43 The science fiction trilogy, and the opposite direction
8:01 The AI dividend we spent on more work
10:37 "Love is the answer"
11:43 Thanks to Higher Logic
12:30 The system, and a canary in the coal mine
15:14 Aging out, and Gen Nexus
19:44 Judgment as a human superpower, and Costco
22:08 Back to community
24:15 Passion, health, and the power to choose
25:39 Your Third Brain and The Tao of Leadership
Part 1, Your Third Brain Should Make You Stronger, Not Just Faster: https://communityassistant.ai/ep005
Part 2 show notes and transcript: https://communityassistant.ai/ep005-part-2
Your Third Brain and The Tao of Leadership: https://jackmyersbooks.com/
The Myers Report, Jack's Substack: https://themyersreport.substack.com/
Practice Notes newsletter: https://practice.communityassistant.ai/
CommunityAssistant.ai is made possible by Higher Logic. Higher Logic sponsors the show; it doesn't control the content.
"Well, the AI told us to do it." When a decision goes wrong, someone has to own it, and it can't be the machine.
Jack Myers, author of Your Third Brain and The Tao of Leadership, joins Chris Heuer for the first of two conversations about what AI is doing to how we think and decide. Jack lays out his three brains: the biological one we're born with, the social one we share, and a third that's co-intelligent with machines, whose job is to make the other two stronger. Chris asks whether a vault of notes is really a second brain, and gets candid about memory, identity and the moment Claude wrote what he was trying to say perfectly. They get into why every company has an AI strategy but few have a human strategy, and the rule Jack gives his clients: never let a decision be made that some human is not accountable for.
In this episode:
Episode page, show notes and transcript: https://communityassistant.ai/ep005 Your Third Brain: https://jackmyersbooks.com The Myers Report, Jack's Substack, with his AI creator trust proposal: https://themyersreport.substack.com Practice Notes newsletter: https://practice.communityassistant.ai/
CommunityAssistant.ai is made possible by Higher Logic. Higher Logic sponsors the show; it doesn't control the content.
"Make-believe numbers" fall apart the moment a CFO asks how you got them. Here's how to measure community health and value with math you can check.
Mark Birch, author of Community in a Box and founder of TribeROI, joins Chris Heuer and Marius Ciortea to talk about what community health really means. They cover why AI can't do the people connecting for you, and how bridge metrics link what happens in your community to the business outcomes your executives care about. Marius shares the one health metric he always starts with: logins, and how often active members come back. Mark explains his C1, C2, C3 framework, the two mistakes that sink most community ROI cases, and why his health score runs on plain math instead of AI guesswork. He also names the metric everyone should retire.
In this episode:
- Marius's one health metric: logins, MAU and DAU
- Why "build it and they will come" is a terrible approach
- Bridge metrics: connecting community signals to business outcomes
- Why proxy metrics fail the CFO test
- Build or lease: when to make your own tools and when to buy
- Start with the ROI, and the one metric to retire
Episode page, show notes and transcript: https://communityassistant.ai/ep004
Get the free Daily Brief skill for Claude and ChatGPT: https://communityassistant.ai/skills/daily-brief/
Practice Notes newsletter: https://practice.communityassistant.ai/
Mark Birch: https://www.linkedin.com/in/startupmark/
TribeROI: https://triberoi.com/
Community in a Box: https://community-in-a-box.com/
CommunityAssistant.ai is made possible by Higher Logic. Higher Logic sponsors the show; it doesn't control the content. Marius Ciortea speaks for himself, not his employer.
Every community manager's morning starts in the forum. Marius Ciortea's Daily Brief hands that read to AI: it ranks what needs you, spots the patterns and drafts replies, while you decide what goes out and who answers. It runs from a chat plan and a browser, free for Claude and ChatGPT.
Chris Heuer and Marius walk through the brief's six sections: top signal, what's changed, needs attention, recurring patterns, the coach's note and suggested actions. They run it live on a beekeeping forum and on a Skool community, talk about why a draft is not a decision, and finish with Marius's favorite extension, routing each question to the expert in the company who should answer it.
Show notes, chapters and full transcript: https://communityassistant.ai/podcast/ep003-start-your-day-with-the-brief/
Get the free Daily Brief skill: https://communityassistant.ai/skills/daily-brief/
CommunityAssistant.ai is made possible by Higher Logic, supporting the practitioners who build the communities that matter. Higher Logic sponsors the show; it doesn't control the content.
Context isn't the data sitting around a person. It's the weaving of that information together to create understanding of their situation. Co-Hosts Chris Heuer and Marius Ciortea discuss why community managers have always been context engineers, and why AI doesn't improve the relationship — it makes the context that does affordable.
Key takeaways
Time & Chapter
00:00 Cold open — four strangers who are the same person
00:50 Welcome, and the Anthropic "pace the frontier" news
04:39 The double-edged sword: $30,000 and 68 days, now three hours
06:28 Three C's, Sea-Doo, and why context is king
07:55 Situatedness, and the etymology of context
09:35 "I've been a context engineer for 20 years"
11:34 The assistant thesis: AI makes context affordable
12:15 Palm's three hats, and the weaving job
14:35 AI doesn't improve the relationship; context does
15:15 A word from Higher Logic
16:03 Marius's daily brief — what it knows before you reply
21:18 Systems thinking, MCP servers, and table stakes
24:11 Aggregate, process, understand, act
25:57 Ten interviews and the expertise knowledge graph
29:01 Access, not a data lake
30:33 Trust, disclosure, and nine hours with AT&T
32:00 Three ways to act: prepared, prompted, drafted — and the easy button
36:43 The whiteboard exercise: two buckets
39:13 Tell the AI where the documentation lives
40:35 Your own personal intelligence system, and next week's tease
42:37 Close
Bloated, off, or wrong. Chris Heuer and Marius Ciortea build a working test for AI slop, then go looking for its edges: the deep expert who cannot write in English, the member who prompts an AI to make him look good, and the community manager who wants a bot to answer every question. What is at stake is trust.
TC Chapter
00:00 Cold open: human slop, and why we're talking about it
00:25 Welcome
01:37 The pilot correction
02:18 Preferring AI answers, not trusting them
02:35 What's at stake is trust
03:19 What is AI slop? Too long to find the useful part
04:07 Bloated, off, or wrong, and the easy button
05:08 Can AI writing not be slop?
05:16 Code is poetry; slop is in the eye of the beholder
06:39 The Druckenmiller op-ed: written by AI
08:55 The PR-firm defense
09:17 Your personal intelligence system
12:22 Where AI writing helps a community: the expert who can't write
14:04 Where it breaks: "make me look good"
14:42 Low effort, low quality, and intent: the LinkedIn problem
16:10 Communities self-police
17:51 "I failed English": provenance, process, intent
19:17 The verification loop
20:44 The evidence under the answer
21:43 Show your work
22:05 The 15-minute conversation was the prompt
22:50 The 8,000-word wall of text
~23:40 Where is AI actually best deployed in a community?
24:00 Sponsor MidRoll - Higher Logic
24:47 Accessibility, enablement, discoverability
25:53 Accessibility runs both ways
28:38 Bad answers proliferate
28:52 The community managers who refuse AI
29:33 "I want a bot that answers all questions." Then what do you have the community for?
31:41 LinkedIn's slop button
33:08 The leaderboard, flipped
33:59 Monday: automated moderation and the Work Map
34:49 Write your community's AI policy, with your community
37:36 Community managers are enablers
39:20 Human-written, AI-backed
40:31 What is a community for? Answers or connection?
41:16 Uniquely human: built on experience
42:28 Revisit your mission, your values, and take your stand
~44:30 Set what the garden should look like
Key takeaways
Community managers spent a decade proving their value in page views and then in engagement. Those numbers are going the wrong way now, and they aren't coming back.
Marius Ciortea thinks that's an opening rather than a loss. In this episode, he makes the case that generative engine optimization is a community job: SEO lived in marketing, and GEO will live in or next to the community team, because your community is usually the only user-generated content your brand actually owns and can influence.
He and host Chris Heuer work through what that means for the person with a queue of unanswered posts and a metrics deck due Friday. How AI systems read a community thread. Which signals make an answer legible to a model: recognized author authority, employee and support attribution, community endorsement, answers marked correct, content that isn't stale. Why the highest-leverage work here isn't a file format but the practice of recognizing authority and retiring outdated material. And what you put in front of your executives when traffic stops being the story.
Chris also introduces the Work Map, an open inventory of the jobs community managers actually do, and identifies GEO as a gap it doesn't yet cover. That one will be getting built in public, with your help.
If the only way you justify your existence has been traffic, you're already in trouble. This episode is about the other way.
Sponsored by Higher Logic and supported by Inflection Point.
Chapters
00:00 Cold open: GEO belongs to community
00:57 Welcome, and why this show exists
03:01 Amplification, not replacement
04:32 Underfunding and the business case problem
05:48 Bots now outnumber humans on the web
07:14 The support question that never reached the forum
08:12 How AI reads a community thread
09:51 Authority signals: badges, staff attribution, upvotes
12:00 Temporality, llms.txt, and ontologies
13:17 The prediction: do the community work, not the file format
15:23 What replaces traffic as the metric
16:26 "If traffic is your only ROI, you're already in trouble"
16:49 Citations, bot-versus-human data, and GEO dashboards
18:11 Why GEO belongs to the community team
20:28 Attribution, and the ad model that's coming
21:34 The Work Map, and owning its gaps
23:51 Why Marius is doing this
26:47 "I've always been lazy": outcome-driven automation
28:54 Translation, humans don't scale, and the reframe
33:09 AI slop, and why the brand doesn't care
35:15 Close
Key takeaways
GEO is a credibility opening for community teams. Community is usually the only user-generated content a brand owns and can influence, which makes the community team the natural home for it.
The signals that make an answer legible to a model are things community managers already control: who answered, their standing, whether the community endorsed it, whether it was marked correct, and whether it's current.
The highest-leverage GEO work is not a technical file. It is about recognizing authority, consistently marking correct answers, and retiring stale content.
More of the web is now crawled by bots than browsed by humans, which breaks the page-views story community managers have been telling executives.
Citation and bot-traffic data is starting to appear in platform back ends, which gives community managers a replacement metric for the traffic they're losing.
Automation in community is not new. Profanity filtering, unanswered-question queues, and translation each moved work off the plate. AI is the next turn of that wheel, not a break from it.
The brand's interest is that the member got a correct answer and can use the product. Insisting that the answer come from the community is the wrong hill to die on.
From the publisher's feed
You got into community for the people, not the busywork.
Community managers are being squeezed from two directions: executives asking why humans are needed at all, and AI eating the…
Each week, host Chris Heuer (30+ years building communities online, offline and in global enterprises) and co-host Marius Ciortea talk with practitioners, builders, and skeptics about which parts of the work belong to AI agents, which stay irreducibly human, and how to tell the difference. The show is supported by the Work Map, an open inventory of nearly 300 community management jobs classified as Human, Agent, or Hybrid.
Topics include AI tools for community managers, agents and automation, member engagement, trust and moderation, community strategy, proving community value, and the future of the profession. If you manage a community and you're deciding what to hand to AI and what to keep, this show is for you.
Sponsored by Higher Logic. Every episode includes actionable tactics you can use. Explore the Work Map and join us at communityassistant.ai.