What happens when betrayal doesn’t only shake your relationship — but also your faith, your understanding of God, and your sense of who you are?
In this deeply compassionate conversation, Jane is joined by New Zealand counsellors and spiritual directors Andrew and Susannah Connolly to explore the intersection of betrayal trauma, spiritual abuse, spiritual trauma and spiritual healing.
Andrew and Susanna bring both professional expertise and lived experience to this conversation. Together, they unpack some of the subtle ways spiritual environments, theological beliefs and misuse of authority can diminish a person’s voice, autonomy and ability to trust their own inner knowing.
Spiritual abuse is not always dramatic or immediately obvious. It can look like coercion, gaslighting, shame, misuse of Scripture, or another person claiming authority over what God is saying to you. Over time, this can erode your internal sense of authority and leave you questioning yourself, your faith and even your understanding of God.
One of the most powerful images in this episode describes spiritual trauma as an earthquake. Your faith life and sense of self can feel shattered, with pieces of you buried beneath the rubble — and you may feel as though you are the only rescue crew trying to find yourself again.
But this conversation is also deeply hopeful.
Andrew and Susannah introduce spiritual direction as a gentle space where you can explore your relationship with God without another person telling you what you should believe, hear or experience. Rather than creating dependence on the spiritual director, healthy spiritual direction seeks to strengthen your own relationship with God and move you towards greater freedom, agency and wholeness.
We also explore the sometimes frightening process of deconstruction and reconstruction — letting go of beliefs, expectations or images of God that no longer feel true, while rediscovering the person God created you to be.
In this episode, we talk about:
- What spiritual abuse can look like — including its subtle forms
- The relationship between spiritual abuse and betrayal trauma
- How gaslighting, coercion, shame and misuse of Scripture can affect your sense of self
- The difference between spiritual abuse and spiritual trauma
- Why betrayal can create a profound spiritual crisis
- The image of being “under the rubble” after spiritual trauma
- Deconstruction — and why questioning does not necessarily mean abandoning faith
- The difference between your “true self” and the versions of yourself shaped by outside expectations
- Reconnecting with a God characterised by love, kindness and compassion
- What spiritual direction actually is
- How a spiritual director can witness your journey without becoming the authority over it
- Why agency is such an important part of spiritual healing
- How spiritual direction and counselling can work alongside each other
- Why betrayal-trauma-specific training matters when choosing a counsellor or spiritual director
Susannah describes the healing process as slowly untying the knots that have been wrapped around us — until the box begins to open and we rediscover beauty, love and ourselves.
And importantly, spiritual direction is not a substitute for counselling or trauma treatment. Andrew and Susannah emphasise that the two can work beautifully together, and encourage people impacted by betrayal trauma to ask potential practitioners specifically about their training and understanding of this area.
If betrayal or spiritual pain has left you wondering:
Who am I now?
Can I trust myself?
What do I believe about God?
And is there a way to find my way back?
This episode offers permission to explore those questions gently.
Healing does not have to mean returning to exactly what you believed before. Sometimes it includes reconstructing — coming home to your own God-given self and discovering a relationship with God that makes more room for love, freedom, compassion and truth.
Connect with Andrew & Susannah
Counselling Creatively
Relationship Recovery Center Asia Pacific
APSATS - find a practitioner
A gentle note
This episode discusses spiritual abuse, betrayal trauma, sexual addiction and experiences of spiritual disillusionment. Please care for yourself as you listen and seek appropriate support if anything feels overwhelming.
Spiritual direction can be a meaningful part of healing, but it is not a replacement for counselling, therapy or other professional care when those supports are needed.
Send Jane a note
Support the show
Connect with Jane at Quiet Wisdom
Check out Reclaim your Confidence Group Support