Criminal Mischief

Criminal Mischief

By 657804True Crime
Download on the App Store
  • Favorites

    241

    Followers

  • Latest release

    3 days ago

  • Typical duration

    37 min

    per episode

  • If it hooks

    47%

    finish an episode

Based on Podcast App listening data

All Criminal Mischief episodes

  • EP | 157 FEAR

    🔪 Criminal Mischief

    “Fear & Fire: The Byron Smith Case”

    Home is supposed to be the one place where the world can’t reach us —

    where we sleep, breathe, and live without fear.

    But what happens when that sanctuary is violated?

    And what happens after the fear curdles into something else?

    This week on Criminal Mischief, Carolyn Ossorio breaks down the chilling case of Byron Smith, a Minnesota homeowner who claimed his house had become a hunting ground for burglars… and that he was simply defending what mattered most.

    Smith said thieves had robbed him not just of valuables, but of peace —

    that he lived in constant dread, waiting for another shadow on the stairs, another shattered window, another invasion.

    So when two intruders entered his basement on Thanksgiving Day,

    Smith didn’t flee.

    He didn’t call 911.

    He waited — armed, recording, and ready.

    What followed would leave a community divided,

    a jury horrified,

    and America asking where the line lies between self-defense and premeditated vengeance.

    Was this a man pushed to the brink by repeated victimization?

    Or a calculating killer who used fear as justification for an ambush?

    The answers — and the tape — tell a story far darker than a simple burglary gone wrong.


    🎧 Listen now

    For reporting that respects victims, examines motive, and never looks away from the truth — even when it’s unsettling.


    🕯️ From the Evio Creative Network

        •    The Devil Within — possession, obsession, and true crime in the shadows

        •    The Devil’s Ledger — the strangest story you’ll hear this week

        •    The Ides of April — immersive historical storytelling by candlelight

        •    Taboo Treasures — forbidden history & cultural archaeology

    Follow: @eviocreative • @thedevilwithinpod


    🛠️ Sponsor Support

    Support the partners who keep investigative storytelling alive:

        •    Quince — elevated essentials without luxury mark-ups

    👉 quince.com/MISCHIEF for free shipping & 365-day returns

        •    Mint Mobile — premium wireless for just $15/month

    👉 mintmobile.com/DEVILWITHIN

        •    ExpressVPN — protect your data and browse privately

    👉 expressvpn.com/DEVILWITHIN for up to four months free

        •    MOOD — legal THC & CBD shipped straight to your door

    👉 mood.com/DEVILWITHIN for 20% off your first order

        •    Ollie Dog Food — fresh, human-grade nutrition for your dog

    👉 ollie.com/IDES for 60% off your first box

        •    Monarch — the most powerful personal finance app

    👉 monarch.com/IDES for 50% off your first year


    📢 Rate & Review

    If you appreciate thoughtful true crime that centers humanity over hype,

    leave a rating and review — it helps more listeners discover Criminal Mischief.

    Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    45 min
  • E | 156 Amityville Horror - The Demon Spawn (BONUS)

    🔪 Criminal Mischief — Amityville Horror - The Demon Spawn

    Presented by the Evio Creative Podcast Network

    It began with a scream in the dark — and ended as one of the most infamous legends in American true crime.

    This week on Criminal Mischief, Carolyn Ossorio takes listeners back to Amityville, Long Island, 1974 — where 23-year-old Ronald DeFeo Jr. murdered his entire family as they slept: his parents, two brothers, and two sisters.

    The killings shocked the nation. DeFeo claimed he heard voices commanding him to act — whispers from inside the house itself. It was a defense that blurred the line between insanity and the supernatural, and launched one of the longest-running cultural debates in modern crime history: was it possession… or pathology?

    Then came the Lutz family.

    Just over a year after the murders, George and Kathy Lutz moved into the DeFeo home — and lasted only 28 days.

    They claimed to hear the same voices. They described green slime oozing from the walls, crucifixes turning upside down, and a demonic pig with glowing red eyes watching them through the windows.

    Whether hoax, haunting, or hysteria, the story became legend — spawning books, documentaries, and one of the most successful horror franchises of all time.

    Carolyn investigates the evidence, the contradictions, and the chilling legacy that still clings to that Dutch Colonial house on Ocean Avenue.


    🩸 In This Episode

        •    The night of November 13, 1974 — the DeFeo murders and the evidence that didn’t add up

        •    Ronnie DeFeo’s shifting claims of demonic possession

        •    The Lutz family’s 28-day ordeal and the birth of The Amityville Horror myth

        •    The psychic investigators who made the story famous — and the skeptics who called it a lie

        •    Why Amityville endures as the ultimate intersection of crime, fear, and faith


    💀 Credits

    Hosted by Carolyn Ossorio

    Produced by Evio Creative

    Sound design and score by [Engineer Name]

    Written by Branden Morgan & Carolyn Ossorio

    For media inquiries or press requests, visit ⁠eviocreative.com⁠ (⁠https://www.eviocreative.com/⁠)


    🕯️ Sponsor Shoutouts

    Support Criminal Mischief and every show in the Evio Creative Podcast Network by visiting our partners:

    🧥 Quince — timeless essentials at honest prices. Visit ⁠https://www.quince.com/MISCHIEF⁠ for free shipping and 365-day returns.

    📱 Mint Mobile — premium wireless for just $15 a month. Visit ⁠https://www.mintmobile.com/DEVILWITHIN⁠ for unlimited talk and text.

    🕵️ ExpressVPN — protect your data everywhere. Visit ⁠https://www.expressvpn.com/DEVILWITHIN⁠ for up to four months free.

    🌿 MOOD — legal THC and CBD gummies shipped nationwide. Visit ⁠https://www.mood.com/DEVILWITHIN⁠ for 20% off your first order.

    🐾 Ollie Dog Food — fresh, human-grade meals for your dog. Visit ⁠https://www.ollie.com/IDES⁠ for 60% off your welcome kit.

    💰 Monarch — take control of your finances at ⁠https://www.monarch.com/IDES⁠ for 50% off your first year.


    🎙️ Network CTA

    Listen to more stories from the Evio Creative Podcast Network, including The Devil Within, The Ides of April, The Devil’s Ledger, and Taboo Treasures.

    Follow @criminalmischiefpod, @eviocreative, and @thedevilwithinpod for episode updates, behind-the-scenes content, and upcoming series announcements.

    Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    36 min
  • E | 156 Amityville Horror - The Demon Spawn

    🔪 Criminal Mischief — Amityville Horror - The Demon Spawn

    Presented by the Evio Creative Podcast Network

    It began with a scream in the dark — and ended as one of the most infamous legends in American true crime.

    This week on Criminal Mischief, Carolyn Ossorio takes listeners back to Amityville, Long Island, 1974 — where 23-year-old Ronald DeFeo Jr. murdered his entire family as they slept: his parents, two brothers, and two sisters.

    The killings shocked the nation. DeFeo claimed he heard voices commanding him to act — whispers from inside the house itself. It was a defense that blurred the line between insanity and the supernatural, and launched one of the longest-running cultural debates in modern crime history: was it possession… or pathology?

    Then came the Lutz family.

    Just over a year after the murders, George and Kathy Lutz moved into the DeFeo home — and lasted only 28 days.

    They claimed to hear the same voices. They described green slime oozing from the walls, crucifixes turning upside down, and a demonic pig with glowing red eyes watching them through the windows.

    Whether hoax, haunting, or hysteria, the story became legend — spawning books, documentaries, and one of the most successful horror franchises of all time.

    Carolyn investigates the evidence, the contradictions, and the chilling legacy that still clings to that Dutch Colonial house on Ocean Avenue.


    🩸 In This Episode

        •    The night of November 13, 1974 — the DeFeo murders and the evidence that didn’t add up

        •    Ronnie DeFeo’s shifting claims of demonic possession

        •    The Lutz family’s 28-day ordeal and the birth of The Amityville Horror myth

        •    The psychic investigators who made the story famous — and the skeptics who called it a lie

        •    Why Amityville endures as the ultimate intersection of crime, fear, and faith


    💀 Credits

    Hosted by Carolyn Ossorio

    Produced by Evio Creative

    Sound design and score by [Engineer Name]

    Written by Branden Morgan & Carolyn Ossorio

    For media inquiries or press requests, visit eviocreative.com (https://www.eviocreative.com/)


    🕯️ Sponsor Shoutouts

    Support Criminal Mischief and every show in the Evio Creative Podcast Network by visiting our partners:

    🧥 Quince — timeless essentials at honest prices. Visit https://www.quince.com/MISCHIEF for free shipping and 365-day returns.

    📱 Mint Mobile — premium wireless for just $15 a month. Visit https://www.mintmobile.com/DEVILWITHIN for unlimited talk and text.

    🕵️ ExpressVPN — protect your data everywhere. Visit https://www.expressvpn.com/DEVILWITHIN for up to four months free.

    🌿 MOOD — legal THC and CBD gummies shipped nationwide. Visit https://www.mood.com/DEVILWITHIN for 20% off your first order.

    🐾 Ollie Dog Food — fresh, human-grade meals for your dog. Visit https://www.ollie.com/IDES for 60% off your welcome kit.

    💰 Monarch — take control of your finances at https://www.monarch.com/IDES for 50% off your first year.


    🎙️ Network CTA

    Listen to more stories from the Evio Creative Podcast Network, including The Devil Within, The Ides of April, The Devil’s Ledger, and Taboo Treasures.

    Follow @criminalmischiefpod, @eviocreative, and @thedevilwithinpod for episode updates, behind-the-scenes content, and upcoming series announcements.

    Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    27 min
  • E | 155 The Devil's Checkmate (Bonus)

    🔪 E | 155 — The Devil's Checkmate ( BONUS)

    In this bonus episode of Criminal Mischief, Carolyn Ossorio and Branden Morgan sit down to unpack the disturbing, decades-long mystery behind the disappearance and murder of Mike Williams.

    They revisit the original episode and go deeper into the investigation — how a simple duck-hunting trip turned into one of Florida’s most confounding cold cases.

    Carolyn reveals what shocked her most about the confession that finally broke the case open, and Branden explores the psychology behind premeditation, cover-up, and the lengths people go to for greed and control.

    It’s an inside look at the making of the episode — the research, the aftermath, and the haunting truth that even in real life, evil rarely looks like what you expect.

    🎧 Listen now to Criminal Mischief — available wherever you get your podcasts.


    ⚖️ From the Evio Network

    Explore the rest of the Evio Creative slate — where truth, myth, and madness intersect:

        •    👹 The Devil Within — True crime and the supernatural collide.

        •    🏺 Taboo Treasures — History’s most forbidden relics.

        •    ⚔️ The Ides of April — Alec Baldwin narrates the turning points of history.

        •    💀 The Devil’s Ledger — Your weekly wrap-up from the underworld.

        •    🔪 Criminal Mischief — Because every crime starts with a plan.

    Visit eviocreative.com for updates, and follow:

    @thedevilwithinpod | @idesofaprilpod | @taboo_treasures | @eviocreative


    🎧 SPONSORS & EXCLUSIVE OFFERS

    Support Criminal Mischief and all Evio shows with these exclusive listener deals:

        •    🧥 Quince — Luxury essentials without luxury markups.

    ➤ https://www.quince.com/MISCHIEF for FREE SHIPPING and 365-day returns.

        •    📱 Mint Mobile — Premium wireless for only $15 a month.

    ➤ www.mintmobile.com/DEVILWITHIN for unlimited talk and text.

        •    🕵️ ExpressVPN — Protect your privacy and data anywhere you go.

    ➤ https://www.expressvpn.com/DEVILWITHIN for up to 4 months FREE.

        •    🌿 MOOD — Legal THC & CBD gummies shipped to your door.

    ➤ https://www.mood.com/DEVILWITHIN for 20% off your first order.

        •    🐾 Ollie Dog Food — Fresh, human-grade meals for your dog.

    ➤ https://www.ollie.com/IDES for 60% off your welcome kit.

        •    💰 Monarch — Manage your money with clarity and control.

    ➤ https://www.monarch.com/IDES for 50% off your first year.


    💀 Criminal Mischief — Evil Is Never Random

    Hosted by Carolyn Ossorio and Branden Morgan.

    A production of Evio Creative.

    Follow, rate, and share wherever you listen — because understanding the darkness is the only way to see the light.

    Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    34 min
  • E | 155 The Devil's Checkmate

    The Devil's Checkmate

    On December 16, 2000, 31-year-old Mike Williams vanished while duck hunting on Florida’s Lake Seminole. His truck was found. His boat was found. But Mike… was gone.

    For years, authorities believed he’d drowned—dragged beneath the surface by alligators. But there was no body. No blood. No real evidence of a struggle.

    What emerged instead was a story of greed, betrayal, and a staged disappearance that unraveled into one of Florida’s strangest and most calculated murders. Criminal Mischief digs into how an insurance plot became a cold-blooded crime—and how, 17 years later, the truth finally surfaced from the swamp.

    🎧 Listen to Criminal Mischief wherever you get your podcasts. New episodes every Friday from Evio Creative.


    🩸 From the Evio Network

    Catch the other shows in the Evio universe of storytelling, true crime, and the paranormal:

        •    👹 The Devil Within — True crime meets the supernatural.

        •    🏺 Taboo Treasures — History’s darkest artifacts and the people who chase them.

        •    ⚔️ The Ides of April — Alec Baldwin narrates history’s bloodiest turning points.

        •    💀 The Devil’s Ledger — A weekly wrap-up from the shadows.

    👉 Visit eviocreative.com and follow:

    @thedevilwithinpod | @taboo_treasures | @idesofaprilpod | @eviocreative


    🎧 SPONSORS & OFFERS

    Support Criminal Mischief and all Evio shows by checking out these exclusive sponsors:

        •    🧥 Quince — Luxury essentials, responsibly made.

    ➤ https://www.quince.com/MISCHIEF for FREE SHIPPING and 365-day returns.

        •    📱 Mint Mobile — Premium wireless starting at $15 a month.

    ➤ www.mintmobile.com/DEVILWITHIN for unlimited talk and text for $15/month.

        •    🕵️ ExpressVPN — The best way to protect your data and privacy.

    ➤ https://www.expressvpn.com/DEVILWITHIN for up to 4 months FREE.

        •    🌿 MOOD — Legal THC and CBD gummies shipped to your door.

    ➤ https://www.mood.com/DEVILWITHIN for 20% off your first order.

        •    🐾 Ollie Dog Food — Fresh, human-grade meals for your dog.

    ➤ https://www.ollie.com/IDES for 60% off your welcome kit.

        •    💰 Monarch — Take control of your financial life.

    ➤ https://www.monarch.com/IDES for 50% off your first year.


    ⚖️ About Criminal Mischief

    From Evio Creative, Criminal Mischief exposes the twisted motives and unseen forces behind real-world crimes. It’s where the line between justice and chaos begins to blur.

    Follow and rate Criminal Mischief wherever you get your podcasts — and remember:

    Evil is never random. It’s methodical. It’s human.

    Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    51 min
  • E|154 The Back Staircase

    🎙️ Criminal Mischief

    The Back Staircase: The Death of Kathleen Peterson

    A fall, a secret, and a story that refused to stay buried.

    In this episode of Criminal Mischief, host Carolyn Ossorio revisits one of the most haunting and polarizing cases in modern true crime — the death of Kathleen Peterson, and the man who claimed it was an accident: her husband, Michael Peterson.

    When Kathleen’s body was found at the bottom of a staircase in their North Carolina mansion in December of 2001, the scene was catastrophic — blood spattered across the walls, head injuries so severe investigators couldn’t believe they came from a fall. What followed would become one of the most debated cases in American criminal history.

    Michael Peterson’s version of events changed under scrutiny. First an accident, then a mystery, then something stranger. A novelist, a veteran, and a husband with more secrets than anyone expected. And when prosecutors unearthed the death of another woman — one connected to Peterson years earlier — the story twisted into something almost unbelievable.

    Through trial transcripts, forensic reports, and archived interviews, Criminal Mischief examines the inconsistencies, the media frenzy, and the theories that still divide both experts and audiences more than two decades later.

    Was Kathleen’s death the result of a tragic fall? Or was it — as some investigators believe — murder disguised as misfortune?


    🕯️ Listen, Follow, and Join the Investigation

    Follow Criminal Mischief for new episodes every week wherever you get your podcasts.

    Visit eviocreative.com (https://www.eviocreative.com/) for more from the Evio Creative Network — including The Devil Within, The Ides of April, and Taboo Treasures.

    Connect with us on social media for behind-the-scenes content, updates, and case discussions.

    📸 @criminalmischiefpod


    💰 Sponsored by QUINCE

    Upgrade your fall wardrobe with Quince — where luxury doesn’t come with a luxury price tag. From Mongolian cashmere to Italian leather, Quince delivers premium essentials directly to you without the designer markup.

    Go to https://www.quince.com/MISCHIEF for FREE SHIPPING and 365-day returns.

    That’s https://www.quince.com/MISCHIEF for free shipping and 365-day returns.

    Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    37 min
  • E|153 A Conversation with Bobby Chacon (Bonus)

    Carolyn and Branden discuss the episode.


    • 💼 Support Our Sponsors

      🖤 Quince — Luxury without the markup.Shop high-quality essentials at ⁠www.quince.com/mischief⁠ for free shipping and 365-day returns.

      🐾 Ollie — Fresh, human-grade dog food delivered to your door.Go to ⁠www.ollie.com/devilwithin⁠ for 60% off your first box.

      💰 Monarch Money — The smart way to manage family budgets and creative income.Visit ⁠www.monarchmoney.com⁠ and use code IDES for 50% off your first year.

      📱 Mint Mobile — Premium wireless for people who hate overpaying.Go to ⁠www.mintmobile.com⁠ and use promo code DEVILWITHIN for unlimited talk and text for just $15 a month.

      📣 Connect

      • Criminal Mischief → ⁠@criminalmischiefpod⁠

      • The Devil Within → ⁠@thedevilwithinpod⁠

      • The Ides of April → ⁠@idesofaprilpod⁠

      • Taboo Treasures → ⁠@taboo_treasures⁠

        • For press & network updates: ⁠www.eviocreative.com⁠ | ⁠[email protected]⁠

          🔥 Criminal Mischief — because the truth doesn’t always make the front page.


          Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

          32 min
        • E|153 A Conversation with Bobby Chacon

          🎙️ CRIMINAL MISCHIEF“Race, Media, and Missing Persons” — with Retired FBI Special Agent Bobby Chacon

          In this week’s episode of Criminal Mischief, host Carolyn Ossorio sits down with retired FBI Special Agent Bobby Chacon — a veteran investigator whose decades of experience span organized crime, counterterrorism, and some of the Bureau’s most challenging missing-persons cases.

          Together, they revisit two haunting investigations: the disappearances of Joyce Chiang and Chandra Levy — two young women whose cases, though eerily similar, were handled very differently by both law enforcement and the media.

          Through candid reflection and hard-earned perspective, Bobby and Carolyn explore how race, class, and public perception shape the urgency — and sometimes the outcome — of national investigations. Why did one case dominate headlines while the other faded into silence? What do these stories reveal about who gets justice, and who gets ignored?

          This is a conversation about crime and consequence — but also about compassion, bias, and the uncomfortable truths that linger long after the cameras move on.

          💬 Featuring

        • FBI insights into the Chiang and Levy investigations

        • How media bias impacts missing persons coverage

        • The human cost of unequal attention

        • Lessons learned from decades in federal law enforcement


          💼 Support Our Sponsors

          🖤 Quince — Luxury without the markup.
          Shop high-quality essentials at www.quince.com/mischief for free shipping and 365-day returns.

          🐾 Ollie — Fresh, human-grade dog food delivered to your door.
          Go to www.ollie.com/devilwithin for 60% off your first box.

          💰 Monarch Money — The smart way to manage family budgets and creative income.
          Visit www.monarchmoney.com and use code IDES for 50% off your first year.

          📱 Mint Mobile — Premium wireless for people who hate overpaying.
          Go to www.mintmobile.com and use promo code DEVILWITHIN for unlimited talk and text for just $15 a month.

          📣 Connect

          • Criminal Mischief → @criminalmischiefpod

          • The Devil Within → @thedevilwithinpod

          • The Ides of April → @idesofaprilpod

          • Taboo Treasures → @taboo_treasures

            • For press & network updates: www.eviocreative.com | [email protected]

              🔥 Criminal Mischief — because the truth doesn’t always make the front page.


              Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

              45 min