Critical Science
Download on the App Store

Critical Science episodes

  • A Story of Bacon, Heartburn, and Alleged Cancer

    I love bacon! Actually, I loved cured meats! I also love veggies high in nitrates! And fortunately, for me, all these things love me, too. But for people who suffer from heartburn, could these foods high in nitrates and nitrites actually give them cancer when they take ranitidine/Zantac? Thankfully, the answer is a very clear and resounding no!


    But due to some really bad science fooling a lot of attorneys, we now have a very large class-action lawsuit, that claims that ranitidine/Zantac actually is transformed to a cancer causing chemical in the stomach of heartburn suffers across our country, and giving them cancer.


    In today's episode we talk about why it's important for a laboratory experiment about human health to actually be relevant to how our bodies work, and the levels of chemicals in our bodies. And we talk about the conclusion a US Federal District Court judge in Florida regarding the science cited by the plaintiffs in the ranitidine/Zantac case.

    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    22 min
  • Short Break -- Back in January 2023!

    I'm taking a short break for the holidays, and will be back in January 2023!


    But remember -- just because someone detects a chemical in a food, that doesn't mean it's going to hurt you!

    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    3 min
  • White Hat Bias and Fear

    In old Westerns, you'd see the hero come in wearing white. It was a subtle hint, a subtle clue that this was the hero. The Lone Ranger wore white. He was the hero, there to save the day. Your hero! Your savior!


    We tend to have a bias to lionize those who we believe our there to help us out, to protect us from harm. We believe these saviors and heroes, because they have no reason to harm us -- they're trying to help us! That is white hat bias.


    Today, I'm going to talk about the intersection of white hat bias and fear -- and how groups, I call them the Merchants of Fear, use poorly done science to drive your fear to drive money into their bank accounts.

    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    12 min
  • A Tale of Uterine Cancer, Hair Products, and Bad Stats

    Ever heard of noise? I'm certain you have. In science, when we talk about noise, we're normally talking about the variance or the variability when trying to measure something. In toxicology, that noise is usually the variability associated with a control or unexposed group. If you were to look at heights across a large number of people, you'll no doubt see a distribution that looks kinda like a bell-shaped or "normal" curve. Most people are huddled together near the middle, and then we have some shorter and some taller people -- the tails. Now, consider that distribution, that bell shaped curve, to represent the unexposed population -- our controls.


    In toxicology we're also going to have some exposed group. And again, for the sake of argument, that group will also have a distribution of responses, and let's say it's also a bell shaped curve distribution. Now then, in simplistic terms, if those two distributions overlap completely, so that they're identical, we'd say there is no treatment effect. What needs to happen is for the response in the treated group to be so different from control that we can't conclude that the treated group's response came from the control distribution.


    Said another way: if I randomly sample from the control distribution and get the same response as I'm seeing in the treated, then there's no treatment effect. That's the simplistic way of explaining this (there are some nuances I'm not bringing up).


    Well, in today's episode, we're going to talk about a case where the "signal" (that is the treatment response that NIEHS' scientists say is a real treatment effect) is actually just noise from the control group.


    Here's my analysis report on how I came to this judgement, and you can see the analysis code here.


    But there are other issues with this particular NIEHS study that says hair relaxers, straighteners, and pressing products are linked to uterine cancer. For starters, NIH's press release made a causal statement that, "women who used chemical hair straightening products were at higher risk for uterine cancer compared to women who did not report using these products" -- that's simply not true at all because this study didn't find causality.


    But the other big issue -- the study isn't even representative of the US population of women. 85.6% of the women in the study were white only, and not hispanic or LatinX -- just white. That's way more than we have in the US population. The number of Black or African American women is well below the US population. Same goes for other non-white groups. Which means, these results are not even relevant to the US population of women. We can't translate these results to the US population.


    Listen to today's episode to find out more!

    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    22 min
  • Do Beautiful Parents Have More Girls

    In 2006, Satoshi Kanazawa published a paper where he said very attractive parents will tend to give birth to more daughters. Yep, he said that. He believed that he had evidence of the Trivers-Willard Hypothesis (an evolutionary biology hypothesis) in humans. Want to know more? Curious what Trivers-Willard is all about? Today's podcast is for you!


    But really, this is a story of sex, not necessarily lies (maybe inappropriate analyses), and nope, no videotapes -- but it is a podcast!

    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    16 min
  • Diethylstilbestrol: A Warning from the Past

    In 1948, a year after a trio of judges wrote the Nuremberg Code in response to Nazi experiments on human subjects kidnapped and imprisoned in concentration camps, Olive Watkins Smith published, "Diethylstilbestrol in the prevention and treatment of complications of pregnancy." In this paper, Smith describes how she and her husband convinced obstetricians across the US to treat pregnant women with an experimental drug -- diethylstilbestrol, or DES. Smith convinced these doctors to treat the pregnant women in their care with a drug where no one understood the potential toxicity, long-term harm, or damage this drug would do to them or their children. Olive Smith and her husband George Smith caused hundreds of women to be exposed to DES, in order to support their ultimately flawed hypothesis that estrogen was the key driver to maintaining a healthy pregnancy.


    This is the story of how a pair of scientists, through flawed scientific studies, kicked off a campaign that grew widespread support throughout the scientific community. It's a story of how confirmation bias blinds scientists, and leads to faulty hypotheses and perpetuates flawed understanding of the science. And how confirmation bias, poor study designs, and a lack of scientific integrity ultimately harms millions of people -- in this case millions of pregnant women and their children.


    This is the sad, unfortunate story of diethylstilbestrol.

    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    24 min
  • Skittles, DNA, and the Law

    A couple of weeks ago, a California resident filed a class action lawsuit against Mars, Inc., the maker of Skittles. The plaintiff alleges that Skittles “are unfit for human consumption because they contain titanium dioxide.” The plaintiff alleges that titanium dioxide is a “known toxin.” Well, as a toxicologist, I can tell you, it’s not quite that simple.


    In today's episode of Critical Science, our host, Dr. Lyle Burgoon, explores how we got here -- how we got to the point that someone is suing a candy maker over titanium dioxide. We'll go beyond the headlines. We'll look at how the European Food Safety Authority reached their conclusion that titanium dioxide might or might not cause DNA damage. We'll explore the scientific studies they relied on. We'll critique the science, and help you better understand why titanium dioxide is considered safe by the US FDA and toxicologists around the world.


    And find out why 4,080 is such a critical number!


    All that on Critical Science.

    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    20 min

About Critical Science

From the publisher's feed

Critical Science is focused on a few things I (Dr. Lyle Burgoon) love -- critical thinking (which I don't do enough of at home, ask my family), science, and applied ethics. And ya know what -- even…