Follow us down the garden path as we explore the history of ratcatching, the science of training rats, and how gullible children are.
Recorded by Sarah-Jayne Robinson and Tim Newport at CPAS Podcast Studio.
Edited by Tim Newport. Transcribed by Sarah-Jayne Robinson.
Intro music sampled from "Dance of the Sugar Plum Fairy" by Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0 License
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
--
SJ: [Fairytale music underneath] In the year 1284 a mysterious man appeared in Hameln. [Fairytale music continues]
SJ: Hi, my name's SJ
Tee: And my name's Tee
SJ: And we're Crumbs of Science, a podcast about the science in and around fairytales
Tee: So today we're talking about the Pied Piper of Hamelin, a Brothers Grimm fairytale which was first published in 1816 but the story dates back well before that.
SJ: There's a lot of evidence showing that this event that occurs in the Pied Piper of Hamelin, actually happened. So to give you a rough idea of what was happening around the world in the late 13th Century - Marco Polo was making his journeys around the globe, the Ottoman empire had just been founded and King Edward the First was on the throne in England. The story of the Pied Piper continues - he was wearing a coat of many coloured, bright cloth, for which reason he was called the Pied Piper. He claimed to be a ratcatcher and he promised that for a certain sum that he would rid the city of all mice and rats. The citizens struck a deal, promising him a certain price. The ratcatcher then took a small fife from his pocket, which is a little musical instrument a bit like a flute or a recorder today, and began to blow on it. Rats and mice immediately came from every house and gathered around him. When he thought that he had them all, he led them to the river Wesser, where he pulled off his clothes and walked them into the water. The animals all followed him, fell in, and drowned.
Tee: So here's the thing about, uh, training rats to do things - uh, they can be, rats can be trained. But the, I mean, people do train rats for all sorts of things, uh scientists use them in labs, they, the rats are really smart and they're used for analogues for humans, um, because we have quite similar physiology...physiological reactions to things, um, and they can be trained.
SJ: Could I train rats to follow me when I played my flute?
Tee: You could train rats to follow you, yes, but you couldn't train them to follow you because you're playing a flute or a fife or uh, whatever you've got on hand, um, because when you're training rats, um, it's all about quite simple stimuli and quite simple commands. So, there's an article in the New York Times, uh, from 2016, by Malia Wollan and she interviewed a guy called Mark Harden, from Animals for Hollywood. And the way they train the rats, is they reward them with food and they, uh, when they perform an action after a simple trigger like a click or a light going on, something like that.
SJ: Do you think, that if I laid food in front of rats, that they would run, if I put enough food in, they'd run into water and die?
Tee: I don't think so, like we said, they're actually quite smart, they're not as, yeh, they're not that dumb.
SJ: So, they couldn't sew me a dress and they probably wouldn't follow me when I play my flute, that's very unexciting.
Tee: Music does actually affect rats though. It does, you can, it's not so much useful for training them, but if you want to change the way rats behave or their physiology, a 2018 review of 42 different studies on rats found that rats really were affected...music,...