The long-awaited Bitcoin futures exchange-traded fund (ETF) began trading on the New York Stock Exchange on Tuesday, marking a watershed moment in cryptocurrency's ongoing rollout. The new ETF, dubbed the ProShares Bitcoin Strategy ETF (BITO), joins a small but growing group of funds that provide exposure to digital currency.
The new Bitcoin-linked fund enables traders to speculate on Bitcoin without directly purchasing cryptocurrency or opening an account with a cryptocurrency exchange. Investors can purchase and sell the fund in the same way they would any other stock on the exchange, which simplifies the process of getting started.
"By opening the doors to mainstream investors through Bitcoin ETFs, a large number of investors can participate in Bitcoin indirectly without actually holding the digital asset, alleviating many newcomers' concerns," says Peter Jensen, CEO of blockchain payments company RocketFuel Blockchain.
However, the road to more crypto exchange-traded funds appears to be rocky, according to experts, despite the fact that many fund companies would love a piece of the healthy fees associated with running an ETF based on the trendy asset. And this desire comes at a time when fees on traditional assets such as stocks have been reduced in response to increased competition for new assets.
Here are the few crypto ETFs that are currently available, as well as the funds that traders can anticipate in the future.
Bitcoin ETFs: The funds that are currently available
Bitcoin exchange-traded funds (ETFs) can be classified into two broad categories, depending on how the fund owns the cryptocurrency and provides exposure to investors:
—Physical exchange-traded funds (ETFs) that are backed by actual bitcoins
—ETFs that invest in crypto futures contracts that are traded on an exchange
"At the moment, the SEC is considering the majority of applications for physical ETFs, but there has been an increase in the number of applicants for futures ETFs over the last year or so," says Sui Chung, CEO of CF Benchmarks, a subsidiary of Kraken, a cryptocurrency exchange.
While this may seem like a minor point, the ability to buy and sell cryptocurrency via the ETF structure opens the asset up to new investors.
"Bitcoin ETFs enable mainstream institutional investors to access Bitcoin without having to worry about storing it in hot wallets, which are more vulnerable to hacks, or about the regulatory and fiscal implications associated with buying it directly on a decentralised cryptocurrency exchange," says Kay Khemani, managing director of Spectre.ai, a broker-less trading platform.
While the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) currently favours futures ETFs, including the new ProShares Bitcoin Strategy ETF, there are already a few publicly traded funds.
Existing digital asset funds
Two existing cryptocurrency funds are publicly traded, and both hold it directly.
Bitcoin Trust in Grayscale (GBTC)
The Grayscale Bitcoin Trust began in 2013 as a private investment with a six-month lockup period prohibiting investors from reselling it in the open market during that time. However, some investors have since sold their shares to the market, making the fund available to anyone. The fund charges an annual fee of 2% of assets under management.
The fund's sponsor announced in October that it is considering converting to a Bitcoin spot ETF. The fund would enable investors to track the price of Bitcoin through a familiar exchange-traded fund structure.
Bitwise ten-cryptocurrency index fund (BITW)
The Bitwise 10 Crypto Index Fund is a monthly rebalanced index of the ten largest cryptocurrencies by market capitalisation (excluding stablecoins and certain others). It began trading publicly in 2017 as a private investment for accredited investors. The fund charges an annual management fee of 2.5 percent of assets.
Bitcoin (which accounts for the majority of the fund's assets), Ethereum, Cardano, and Solana are the fund's largest holdings.
Additional cryptocurrency-related funds
At least one fund — the Volt Crypto Industry Revolution and Technology ETF (BTCR) — has circumvented the SEC's preferences and recently gained trading approval.
"The SEC approved Volt Equity's ETF, which circumvents current SEC restrictions by not investing directly in Bitcoin but rather tracking companies that have a majority of their assets in Bitcoin or generate revenue from Bitcoin-related activities," Jensen explains.
ETFs on blockchain technology
For the time being, direct investment in cryptocurrency via publicly traded funds is limited. However, those interested in riding the wave of blockchain technology — the technology that powers these digital currencies — have a few options for investing in funds that own companies riding the wave.
Amplify Transformational Data Sharing ETF (BLOK) is the largest blockchain ETF, with top holdings including Hut 8 Mining (HUT), Marathon Digital Holdings (MARA), and MicroStrategy (MSTR) as of October 2021.
Siren Nasdaq NexGen Economy ETF (BLCN) is another player in this space, with top holdings including Silvergate Capital (SI), Marathon Digital Holdings, and MicroStrategy.
The SEC and cryptocurrency exchange-traded funds
"The SEC has thus far refused to approve any ETFs that invest directly in Bitcoin, despite the fact that numerous asset managers have applied with a similar setup already visible in countries such as Germany, Canada, and Switzerland," Jensen explains.
So what is preventing the SEC from approving additional funds or those that directly own cryptocurrency? Experts cite a variety of reasons.
"Regulatory concerns about ETFs include their fee structures, uncertainty about Bitcoin's true intrinsic value, and, of course, the fact that the underlying asset's regulatory future remains uncertain," Khemani says.
Chris Kline, Bitcoin IRA's COO and co-founder, cites additional reasons.
"According to previous rulings, regulators are concerned about the ability of digital assets to be manipulated, issues of volatility, and a lack of surveillance," Kline explains.
"Previously, regulators were unsure of how cryptos worked," he explains. "As they gained familiarity with the space, the SEC began to grasp how these assets are stored, secured, and reconciled in a manner consistent with traditional finance."
However, another significant reason the SEC prefers futures ETFs over physical ETFs is pre-existing regulation, according to Chung.
"At the moment, the venues where the majority of cryptocurrency trading occurs — exchanges — are not legally required to follow existing capital market regulations, such as the Securities Exchange Act," he explains. "Of course, many platforms — Kraken included — have voluntarily chosen to adhere to these requirements, but the SEC retains reservations about approving a product from a market that is largely outside its jurisdiction."
"However, since Gary Gensler took over as SEC chairman earlier this year, he has expressed a preference for a futures ETF that will hold contracts from the Chicago Mercantile Exchange — a market already regulated by the CFTC's sister agency," Chung notes.
Which cryptocurrency exchange-traded funds (ETFs) are on the horizon?
While the SEC may be dragging its feet on cryptocurrency ETF approvals at the moment, experts believe this is largely temporary and point to already-existing crypto ETFs in Canada and Europe. When the regulatory framework is established, it may eventually result in the creation of a variety of new ETFs, even if some of the most exotic products remain unavailable in publicly traded funds.
"Once the regulatory kinks are worked out, ETFs will follow," Khemani predicts.
"In the case of cryptocurrency ETFs, we are unlikely to see anything other than Bitcoin and Ethereum in the short term, but we are likely to see variation in the future as the SEC begins to regulate the industry more aggressively," says Ben Weiss, CEO and co-founder of CoinFlip, a network of cryptocurrency ATMs.
And when can traders expect to see a slew of new crypto ETFs?
"Crypto ETFs are unavoidable," Kline asserts. "A product of this nature will eventually be developed because there is a market for it, but the timeline remains uncertain."
Increased regulation — which can help create safeguards for cryptocurrency — could also help bring a broader range of fund companies into the crypto space.
"While a number of crypto-specific ETFs have been proposed by firms such as Valkyrie and Kryptoin, a number of new applications have come from traditional players such as WisdomTree, Invesco, and ProShares," Chung notes.
While a clear regulatory framework and industry standards will aid in the development of a wave of crypto ETFs, do not expect the industry to securitize all crypto products.
"ETFs based on more exotic crypto creations such as unregulated decentralised trading exchanges, lenders, staking, or farming high-yield investment programmes are unlikely to be approved in the near future," Khemani says. He argues that these products' inherent security risks preclude them from being classified as traditional ETFs.
While traders await the SEC's approval of cryptocurrency exchange-traded funds, they are not restricted from trading the currencies directly. It's simple to get started with a cryptocurrency exchange like Binance, particularly if you're already familiar with online brokerages. By using a low-cost cryptocurrency exchange, you can avoid some of the hefty management fees levied by existing ETFs, which can be as high as 2% or 2.5 percent of your invested assets per year.
Thus, investors hoping for a robust market for cryptocurrency exchange-traded funds will have to wait until the SEC decides how to proceed.