On July 3, 2015, 35-year-old Crystal Rogers disappeared from Bardstown, Kentucky a small town that would soon become known for a series of unsettling mysteries.

Her car was later found abandoned along the Bluegrass Parkway with a flat tire. Inside were her keys, phone, and purse.

But Crystal was gone.

As investigators looked deeper, the case became entangled with other strange events in Bardstown including the unsolved murder of a police officer and the suspicious death of Crystal’s father.

In this episode, we examine the timeline of her disappearance, the complex web of people surrounding the case, and why Bardstown’s mysteries have continued to haunt investigators and residents alike.