When 27-year-old medical student Brian Shaffer walked into the Ugly Tuna Saloona bar on April 1st, 2006 and never walked out it became one of the most haunting modern mysteries in America. Surveillance cameras captured every entrance and exit… except his. Nearly two decades later, new digital analysis, possible sightings, and online sleuth theories continue to ask: how can someone simply vanish from a place surrounded by cameras?

In this episode, we revisit the Brian Shaffer case the last known moments, evolving theories, and the enduring mystery that refuses to fade.

In September 2014, Tammy Kingery, a nurse and mother of three from South Carolina, told her husband she wasn’t feeling well and stayed home from work. By the afternoon, she had vanished leaving behind her phone, purse, and keys. The house was locked from the inside, and a note simply read: “Gone for a walk. Be back soon.” She was never seen again.

In this episode, we explore the haunting details of Tammy’s disappearance, the strange clues left behind, and the unsettling possibilities that have kept her case alive for nearly a decade.

In March 1993, 27-year-old Annie McCarrick an American living in Dublin set out for a day trip to the Wicklow Mountains. She was last seen at a pub in Enniskerry, chatting with an unknown man. She never made it home.

Three decades later, Annie’s disappearance remains one of Ireland’s most haunting mysteries a story woven through missing CCTV footage, strange witness accounts, and whispers of a serial predator. Was she the victim of a random act, a targeted attack, or something that went unnoticed in plain sight?

In August 2013, 19-year-old Bryce Laspisa left his college apartment near Los Angeles and began a strange, meandering journey north toward his parents’ home. He never made it. His car was later found wrecked and abandoned near Castaic Lake, its contents inside but Bryce was gone.

What unfolded next is one of the most baffling missing person cases in modern America. From his final phone calls to erratic behavior and a trail of digital breadcrumbs, Bryce’s disappearance has spawned countless online theories from mental health struggles to something more sinister.

It was a warm summer night in 1995 when six-year-old Morgan Nick attended a Little League game in Alma, Arkansas. Just a few steps away from her mother and friends, she was catching fireflies and then, she was gone. No scream. No trace. No goodbye.

Morgan’s disappearance would shake her small town and eventually lead to sweeping national changes in how missing child alerts were handled. Decades later, theories still swirl from suspected kidnappers to chilling confessions and the hope that she might still be alive.

In August 2013, 25-year-old Tiffany Daniels left her job at Pensacola State College, drove home, and then vanished her car later found abandoned near Pensacola Beach, its doors locked and the sand still clinging to the tires. Inside were her phone, wallet, and bike but no sign of Tiffany.

What happened that summer afternoon? Did she run away, meet with foul play, or stumble into something darker? Her case remains one of Florida’s most haunting modern disappearances a mystery tangled in freedom, faith, and fear.

On June 27th, 1995, popular Iowa TV news anchor Jodi Huisentruit failed to show up for her morning broadcast. Her car was found in the station parking lot keys bent, shoes scattered, signs of a struggle frozen in time. But what really happened between her front door and that parking space? Was it a stalker, a jealous acquaintance, or someone she trusted?

Join us as we unravel the chilling disappearance of Jodi Huisentruit a case that continues to haunt both journalists and true crime followers nearly three decades later.

In August 2016, the Tromp family of Victoria, Australia, suddenly abandoned their home and fled on a bizarre cross-country trip that baffled the nation. With no clear trigger, parents Mark and Jacoba Tromp and their three adult children vanished into the wilderness leaving phones, IDs, and logic behind.

Days later, the family members were found separately, each in a state of confusion and fear. What made the Tromps believe they were in danger? Was it a collective mental breakdown or were they running from something we still don’t understand?

Join us as we unpack one of Australia’s most surreal and unsettling modern mysteries.

In 1985, the Brown family of Port St. Lucie, Florida — mother Carolyn, and her three children Brandon, Barry, and Sheketah vanished without a trace. Their father, James Brown, was left behind, claiming no knowledge of where they went.

Nearly four decades later, the case remains unsolved with no confirmed sightings, no remains, and no clear motive. What happened to the Brown family? Was it a planned disappearance, a family tragedy, or something far stranger?

Join us as we unpack one of Florida’s most haunting family vanishings a case where logic and emotion collide in unsettling ways.

In 2015, Minnesota man Henry McCabe vanished after leaving a voicemail that chilled everyone who heard it. The message contained eerie screams, strange noises, and what sounded like a voice saying, “Stop it.”

Was it a tragic accident, a case of foul play, or something far more mysterious? Join us as we unravel the haunting disappearance of Henry McCabe a case where one recording holds more questions than answers.