Audio Summaries of the daily Chumash portions In loving memory of Ousher Zelig ben Myer HaLevi Z”L
To sponsor an episode please visit: https://itistaught.com/support-this-project/To get the daily chumash summaries in your email click here https://substack.com/profile/182692001-sarede-rachel-switzer?utm_source=profile-page.Subscribe on SpotifySubscribe on Apple PodcastsPlease consider leaving a review on the platform of your choice! For comments and inquiries, email [email protected]
Warnings Against Idolatry
Moshe foretells of a time when G-d will expel the other nations from the Land of Israel and the Israelites will live there instead.
He warns them not to then become drawn to and curious about those other nations' idolatrous practices. They should understand that it was these practices which caused them to be killed by others so if the Israelites took on these practices, they could also get killed by outsiders.
Generally speaking, the sin of idolatry only incurs the death penalty if the idol is worshiped according to its customary practice. Rashi includes the example of defecating before [Baal] Peor or casting a stone at Mercurius,
However if one does any of the four following practices before an idol, regardless of whether this is the customary way to worship it, one is also liable for the death penalty:
* Slaughtering a sacrifice for the idol.
* Burning a sacrifice for the idol
* Pouring a libation for the idol
* Prostrating oneself before the idol.
Moshe warns them not to do these practices and says that these idolators would burn theirs sons, daughters, fathers and mothers before their idols. Rashi cites Rabbi Akiva who said that he once saw an idolator bind his father before his dog and the dog ate him. Rashi then cites Sifrei who understands the dog to be an idol, either because the idol was actually in the form of a dog or else this was just a demeaning description of the idol. Sifrei interprets the dog "eating" the father as meaning that the idolator burned his father in front of the idol.
Moshe tells the nation to be careful to keep all of G-d's commandments, both positive and negative, regardless of level of gravity. They are not to add to them (Rashi gives the example of putting 5 chapters in the head tefillin instead of 4 or using 5 species of lulav instead of 4 or reciting 4 blessings instead of 3 for the Birkas Kohanim (priestly blessing) nor subtract from them.
Moshe says that if a prophet or "dreamer of a dream" rises up amongst them who gives them a sign from heaven or on earth, one is not to listen to him if he tells them to worship foreign deities. And if one wonders why G-d sent such a person, they should know that this is so G-d would test his love of G-d.
For an example of a sign from heaven (אוֹת) as well as a sign on earth (מוֹפֵת), Rashi cites an incident in Shoftim with Gideon where Gideon asks the angel of G-d to show him a sign to let him know if G-d wanted Israel to be saved through Gideon.
First he spread out a fleece of wool on the threshing floor and said that if dew would only go onto the fleece and leave the rest of the ground dry, he would take this as a sign from heaven (אוֹת) and so it was (See Shoftim 6:17).
Then after squeezing out all of the dew from the fleece, he told G-d that he would do one more test to see a sign on earth (מוֹפֵת), where the fleece would remain dry this time and the dew be on the rest of the ground. And so it was (see Shoftim 6:39).
The Gur Aryeh and the Maskil LeDavid are unsure as to why the first test was called a sign from "heaven" and the second "on earth" but they suppose that maybe it's because dew falls from the heavens.
Rather than follow such a false prophet, they are to follow and fear G-d. They are to keep the Torah, listen to the voice of the true prophets, worship Him in the Mishkan and cleave to His ways, which Rashi cites Sotah 14a to mean: do kindness, bury the dead and visit the sick.
Furthermore, such a false prophet should be put to death since he said things G-d never told him to. If all G-d did would have been to rescue the Israelites from Egypt, that would have been sufficient.
Moshe warns them to resist temptation if even a close relative of theirs tries to persuade them in secret* to abandon the G-d of their forefathers** and worship idols, whether these idols are near or far***, including all of the heavenly bodies. Relatives including in this warning are one's: Brother (either paternal or maternal), son, daughter, wife or father.
*Side note: The text writes "in secret" since this is how such persuasions usually occur, however this would be forbidden just as much if it would be done in public.
**Side note: Rashi comments that the suggestion to abandon the G-d of one's forefathers is especially shameful since even idolatrous nations don't abandon their ancestor's beliefs/practices.
***Side note: Rashi comments that the text stipulates "near or far" to teach that if one comes to know about the idols which are close by, they will see that these have no substance and will understand from this that those further away are similarly lacking in substance.
Such a person must be killed, ideally by the hands of the person he tempted. If this is what is to be done to someone so dear to a person like these relatives, all the more so should one similarly punish someone not close to him who tries to persuade him towards idolatry.
If the person who was tempted by him does not kill him, others must kill the tempter.
He shall not be loved, nor shall you have mercy for him when he pleads for his life begging for forgiveness. He shall not be pitied or try to find merits in his favor and you may not stay silent if you know some condemning information about him.
All of these stipulations are deviations from the commandments to otherwise love (Vayikra 19:8) help (Shmos 23:5) and have pity on (Vayikra 19:18) one's fellow man.
You should not let him go free. If a court acquits him, you must bring him back to be convicted, yet if he is deemed guilty, you may not return him for acquittal.
The method of killing him should be with stoning and this should serve as a learning lesson for the Israelites who should listen to this with fear.
Moshe tells the nation that if they hear people talking about one of the cities which G-d told them to live in (excluding Jerusalem, which no tribe was given to live in) saying that its male inhabitants* have cast aside Torah observance and are leading people to worship idols, they are to investigate** the city and if found guilty, they are to kill the people living in it. If they are unable to carry out a death penalty for them, they must kill them by some other means.
*Side note: It must be the men who led it astray for such a city to be considered wayward.
**Side note: Rashi lists the seven expressions of investigation which are learned from this text, three of which come up here:
* Seeking out - דְרִישָׁה
* Investigating - חֲקִירָה
* Thoroughly - הֵיטֵב
and then two more will come up later in 17:4 and two more in 19:18.
They are to burn all of the possessions (spoils) of this city in its open square, never to be rebuilt again.
By not being attached to anything having to do with destruction (i.e. idolatry), G-d's anger will subside and He will bestow compassion on them and cause them to multiply as He had promised the patriarchs.
Once again, Moshe beseeches the nation to keep G-d's commandments.
Get full access to Sarede’s Substack at sarede.substack.com/subscribe