Decoffinated: Ghost Stories & Unsolved Mysteries

Send us Fan Mail

Unlocking the truth behind Houdini's Death

Harry Houdini's death has been blamed on one punch for almost 100 years. But a retired surgeon believes the official story was rewritten, and the man who threw that punch spent the rest of his life paying for it. 

In October 1926, a McGill student named J. Gordon Whitehead asked Houdini if he could really take any punch to the stomach. Nine days later, Houdini was dead, on Halloween. Or was he? Dr. Larrian Gillespie believes Houdini actually died on October 30th, that the punch wasn't what killed him, and that a $50,000 insurance payout helped make Whitehead "the man who killed Houdini." 

This episode on deCOFFINated, we follow the story from a Montreal dressing room to a Detroit hospital bed, through Bess Houdini's Halloween séances, to an unmarked grave that finally got a name. 


🎧 Listen to Decoffinated on Apple Podcasts, Spotify and everywhere else:
https://linktr.ee/decoffinpod?utm_sou

CHAPTERS
00:00 The Legend of Houdini's Death
12:37 The Aftermath of Houdini's Passing
20:43 The Investigation into Houdini's Death
27:21 The Legacy of Houdini and Gordan Whitehead
28:19 Outro


SOURCES & ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The October 30th theory comes from Dr. Larrian Gillespie's research. Houdini historians are still debating it, so check out the sources and decide for yourself. 

Books 
• Dr. Larrian Gillespie, "Houdini: The Man Who Died Twice" (Cipher House Books, 2026) 
• Don Bell, "The Man Who Killed Houdini" (Véhicule Press) 
• Adam Begley, "Houdini: The Elusive American" (Yale University Press) 

Articles & research 
• The New York Times, "Houdini Died on Halloween 100 Years Ago. Some Still Question How." (Oct. 20, 2026) 
• The New York Times archive, 1926–1927 reports on Houdini's death and the insurance claim • John Cox, Wild About Harry (wildabouthoudini.com) • Sworn affidavit of J. Gordon Whitehead, March 16, 1927 (via Houdini's Ghost) 
• Genii Magazine Wiki, "The Houdini Code" 
• Michiganology (Archives of Michigan), "Houdini in Detroit" 


Archives & photo collections 
• Library of Congress, Prints & Photographs Division 
• McCord Stewart Museum, Montreal • Archives of Michigan / Michiganology 
• Chronicling America (historic newspapers) 

Thanks to Dr. Larrian Gillespie, John Cox, Patrick Culliton and George Hardeen, whose research and words appear in this episode.

#Houdini #HarryHoudini #DarkHistory #HalloweenHistory #TrueStory

Connect with me! 

• Socials: https://www.instagram.com/mischaharper/

Send me stories of what you want to hear!

• E-mail: [email protected] 

Send us Fan Mail

Robert the Doll has lived in Key West since 1904, and every year, strangers send him letters apologizing for the bad luck they believe he caused. Why do people keep saying "I'm sorry, Robert"? And who was he, really?

In this episode of Decoffinated, Mischa Harper tells the Robert the Doll story from the beginning: Gene Otto and the doll who took his name, the voodoo curse legend, Anne Otto the concert pianist, Myrtle Reuter and the door that wouldn't open, the reporter who said the doll was listening, and the research that traced Robert to a German toy company and found a real woman behind the legend. Is Robert the Doll really haunted? You decide.

Chapters

0:00 Dear Robert, I’m sorry. Letters to Robert
2:19 The Origins of Robert The Doll

8:53 Gene’s Life and the Doll’s Influence

16:29 The Doll’s Haunting Legacy

20:46 Robert’s Journey to the Museum

23:33 Unraveling the Legend of Robert

27:42 The Ongoing Mystery of Robert the Doll

Sources
David L. Sloan, Robert the Doll: The True Biography of Key West's Haunted Doll (2014), and ghostkeywest.com/robert-the-doll
Atlas Obscura, "The Story Behind the World's Most Terrifying Haunted Doll"
Keys Weekly, "Robert the Doll's Killer Key Lime Pie"
Key West Art & Historical Society, kwahs.org/robert-the-doll

#RobertTheDoll #HauntedDoll #KeyWest #ScaryStories #Decoffinated

Connect with me! 

• Socials: https://www.instagram.com/mischaharper/

Send me stories of what you want to hear!

• E-mail: [email protected] 

Send us Fan Mail

Doppelganger's have long been feared for centuries. We explore the terrifying folklore behind the monster wearing your face.

Coming face-to-face with your own double is more than a myth; it is a primal terror we are breaking down today.

The doppelganger has haunted human storytelling for centuries, appearing in folklore as an ominous sign of impending death or a warning of bad luck. We look at why this specific entity—the monster wearing your own features—creates such a visceral reaction in our survival instincts. It is not just about urban legends; it is about the ancient fear of the shadow self appearing when you least expect it.

Modern paranormal research suggests our brains struggle to categorize these sightings, leading to a profound sense of dread. By examining the patterns behind these reports, we analyze whether these encounters indicate a glitch in reality or if they are simply a psychological phenomenon that we cannot yet fully explain. Understanding the history of the double helps us process why our minds react with such intense hostility.

Find me on Socials! 

Instagram: @mischaharper

Connect with me! 

• Socials: https://www.instagram.com/mischaharper/

Send me stories of what you want to hear!

• E-mail: [email protected] 

Send us Fan Mail

Something weird happens while we’re making this one, and it only makes the subject feel closer: files disappear, apps crash, and suddenly we’re staring straight into the Men in Black phenomenon with a brand-new kind of caution. 
 
 We start by pulling the thread back far beyond the 1950s. Through an archived interview with a South African shaman and keeper of oral knowledge (referenced in our research), we explore claims of ancient contact, “tormentors”, and beings whose features sound unsettlingly similar to modern grey descriptions. That’s where the theme locks in: if the stories share the same shape across continents and centuries, what exactly is repeating, and why?

🎧 Also on Apple Podcasts, Spotify and everywhere else:

https://linktr.ee/decoffinpod?utm_sou

If you’re into UFO history, alien encounter lore, high strangeness, and the question of who controls the narrative after “contact”, this one will stay with you. Subscribe to Decoffinated, share this with a friend who loves paranormal stories, and leave a review with your theory: government, myth, or something not human at all?

Dr. Herbert Hopkins Audio Link 

•  https://fourble.co.uk/podcast/highstrangen
   it is Track 3

Credo Mutwa Interview Link 

• https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aLsKvEgSJjg&t=18s

Time stamps in order: 

(00:00:18)

(00:01:36)

(2:53) to around (10:52) 

(01:56:07)

(02:29:55)

Men in Black - Niagara Falls Hotel Video Link

• https://youtu.be/bcToNxPvZAE?si=3KaJHWcsUwbLoHxn 

Connect with me! 

• Socials: https://www.instagram.com/mischaharper/

Send me stories of what you want to hear!

• E-mail: [email protected] 

Send us Fan Mail

Did a rigged house give the world a blind spot, or did the architecture drive her to do it?

Welcome back to Decoffinated with your host, Mischa Harper. This week, we are stepping into a suffocating 1892 heatwave in Fall River, Massachusetts, to dissect the infamous Lizzie Borden axe murders. But we aren't just retelling the timeline—we are analyzing the crime using the layout of a classic board game: Clue.

The Borden house was a chamber-style maze with bedrooms connected like train cars and absolutely no hallways. It was a space acoustically impossible to hide in, yet visually perfect for a killer to vanish without a trace.

Card by card, we eliminate the rumors from the reality. Why did Andrew Borden brutally slaughter his daughter's pet pigeons? Why did Lizzie actively sort her medical help by ethnicity while her father lay dead on the sofa? And how did high-society class systems play a bigger role in her acquittal than any physical evidence?

Pour a fresh cup, pull up a chair, and let's find out if anyone actually "came in" at all.

If you love the episode, please leave us a 5-star review on Apple Podcasts or Spotify, and follow us on socials to share your theories!

Find my socials: https://linktr.ee/decoffinpod?utm_sou

Connect with me! 

• Socials: https://www.instagram.com/mischaharper/

Send me stories of what you want to hear!

• E-mail: [email protected] 

Send us Fan Mail

Title: Spontaneous Human Combustion: The Mystery of Mary Reeser

Description:

On the morning of July 2, 1951, a Florida landlady reached for a doorknob and found it scalding hot. Inside the apartment, investigators faced a scene that defied physics. 67-year-old Mary Reeser had been completely incinerated into a small pile of ash—except for a single, untouched left foot still resting in its black slipper.

What makes this case truly terrifying isn't just the destruction of her body; it’s the fact that the surrounding room suffered almost zero fire damage. White bedsheets remained pristine, and nearby newspapers never caught fire.

How does a human body burn at thousands of degrees for hours without catching the rest of the house on fire? In this episode of Decoffinated, we dissect the real forensic files. We map out Mary’s final hours, look at the FBI's controversial "wick effect" investigation under J. Edgar Hoover, and explore why elite forensic anthropologists admitted this case genuinely gave them chills.

Turn off the lights, lock your doors, and let’s dive in.

The Mysterious Case of Mary Reeser | Spontaneous Human Combustion

Connect with me! 

• Socials: https://www.instagram.com/mischaharper/

Send me stories of what you want to hear!

• E-mail: [email protected] 

Send us Fan Mail

There's a woman in Trinidad who digs up graves to make an oil that lets her peel off her own skin, a woman on a dark country road who isn't fully human below the knee, and something living in the water that decides, song by song, whether you make it home.

These aren't campfire stories, they're three pieces of real Trinidadian folklore.

I'm Mischa Harper, and this week on the Decoffinated Podcast we are diving intto the stories of the Soucouyant, La Diablesse, and Mama D'Leau. Socials:

 @mischaharper on instagram 

@decoffinpodon Instagram and TikTok

If you enjoyed this one, a rating or review helps more than you'd think — it's how new listeners find the show.

Connect with me! 

• Socials: https://www.instagram.com/mischaharper/

Send me stories of what you want to hear!

• E-mail: [email protected] 

Send us Fan Mail

Detectives called it one of the strangest tips they'd ever taken seriously: a coworker's wife, speaking in a voice that wasn't hers, naming a killer police hadn't found in five months of investigating.

This is the story of Teresita Basa, murdered in her own Chicago apartment in 1977, and the case the press would later nickname "the voice from the grave."

If you're new here, Decoffinated digs into ghost stories, unsolved mysteries, paranormal encounters, and everything that blurs the line between the haunted and the human. New episodes every Wednesday. If you liked this one, follow the show so you don't miss next week's episode, and a rating genuinely helps a small show like this get discovered.

Socials: @mischaharper on instagram 

@decoffinpodon Instagram and TikTok

If you enjoyed this one, a rating or review helps more than you'd think — it's how new listeners find the show.

Connect with me! 

• Socials: https://www.instagram.com/mischaharper/

Send me stories of what you want to hear!

• E-mail: [email protected] 

Send us Fan Mail

Prosecutors called it one of the only times in American legal history a Ouija board was formally entered into evidence, because it was the only thing in the room that explained the motive.

It started like any other night at Brian and Tammy Roach's house in Minco, Oklahoma — a farming town of about 1,400 people. Tammy's mother, Carol Sue Elvaker, was over, like she was most evenings. Fifty-three years old. No criminal history. Nothing that would ever make you look twice at her. So how does a grandmother like that become a murderer?

I'm Mischa Harper, and this week on the Decoffinated Podcast, I'm walking through what happened on February 11th, 2001.

If you're new here, Decoffinated unearths ghost stories, unsolved mysteries, and paranormal encounters — pour a cup and pull up a chair.

Socials: @decoffinpod on Instagram and TikTok

If you enjoyed this one, a rating or review helps more than you'd think — it's how new listeners find the show.

Sources: Oklahoma court records and contemporary news reporting on the Elvaker case.

#TrueCrime #Paranormal #OuijaBoard #TrueCrimePodcast #OklahomaTrueCrime

Connect with me! 

• Socials: https://www.instagram.com/mischaharper/

Send me stories of what you want to hear!

• E-mail: [email protected] 

Send us Fan Mail

The only known case where a ghost's testimony helped convict a murderer.

In 1897, Zona Heaster Shue was found dead at the bottom of the stairs in her West Virginia home. The coroner ruled it natural causes — until her ghost allegedly appeared to her mother and named her killer. What followed became one of the strangest true crime cases in American history.

This is the first episode of Decoffinated, hosted by Mischa Harper — true crime and paranormal stories, told with a little dark humor along the way.

Connect with me! 

• Socials: https://www.instagram.com/mischaharper/

Send me stories of what you want to hear!

• E-mail: [email protected]