Newsmakers

Does Trump's Massive $454 Million Penalty Violate His 8th Amendment Rights?


Listen Later

As 2024 presumptive GOP nominee Donald Trump continues to face various court battles, an appeals court granted him at least a temporary reprieve from a $454 million fine. With Trump up against a deadline earlier this week to pay the penalty, the appeals court lowered the sum to a $175 million bond, giving the former president 10 days to secure the monies.

This not only at least temporarily lowered the sum but also relieved Trump from New York Attorney General Letitia James's pledge to seize his assets should he be unwilling or unable to pay the larger penalty. If, in months to come, the appeals court does rule in the attorney general's favor and against Trump, he could still be forced to pay the $454 million bond.

Some critics have claimed the sum is unheard of, with a number of talking heads alleging the massive bond is a violation of the 8th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution, which reads, "Excessive bail shall not be required, nor excessive fines imposed, nor cruel and unusual punishments inflicted." Bradley Jacob, a professor at Regent University School of Law, told CBN News the 8th Amendment is "primarily about criminal law in a criminal court," which is noteworthy considering Trump's case is civil. Jacob went on to explain some of the parameters and confines of the 8th Amendment text.

"You can't give cruel and unusual punishments," he said. "You can't tar and feather someone; you can't impale them on a stake — those kinds of things are not permitted under the Constitution." Jacob continued, "Bail can't be way out of proportion to the crime; if you're going to go on trial for jaywalking, they can't put $10,000 bail on that ... those kinds of issues."

Despite the criminal aspects of the 8th Amendment, Jacon said there have been some court cases indicating excessive fines could also apply to a fine or judgment in a civil case "if the amount of money that's in the judgment is just way out of proportion to the offense." This is why some might be claiming this is the case in Trump's current battle. Hear him explain.

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

NewsmakersBy CBN News

  • 4.8
  • 4.8
  • 4.8
  • 4.8
  • 4.8

4.8

16 ratings


More shows like Newsmakers

View all
Sekulow by Jay Sekulow

Sekulow

1,437 Listeners

Daily Radio Program with Charles Stanley - In Touch Ministries by Dr. Charles Stanley

Daily Radio Program with Charles Stanley - In Touch Ministries

8,869 Listeners

Greg Laurie: A New Beginning by Greg Laurie

Greg Laurie: A New Beginning

3,689 Listeners

VOMRadio by The Voice of the Martyrs

VOMRadio

1,429 Listeners

Understanding the Times by Pastor Josh Schwartz and Ken Mikle

Understanding the Times

2,703 Listeners

Focus on the Family with Jim Daly by Focus on the Family

Focus on the Family with Jim Daly

4,824 Listeners

Focus on the Family Strengthening Marriage Podcast by Focus on the Family

Focus on the Family Strengthening Marriage Podcast

1,885 Listeners

Fearless with Cissie Graham Lynch by Billy Graham Evangelistic Association

Fearless with Cissie Graham Lynch

1,115 Listeners

Allen Jackson Ministries by Pastor Allen Jackson of World Outreach Church

Allen Jackson Ministries

1,616 Listeners

Quick Start by CBN News

Quick Start

190 Listeners

The Becket Cook Show by The Becket Cook Show

The Becket Cook Show

1,117 Listeners

Greg Laurie: Daily Devotions by Greg Laurie

Greg Laurie: Daily Devotions

223 Listeners

Crazy Little Thing Called Marriage by Focus on the Family

Crazy Little Thing Called Marriage

33 Listeners

ReFOCUS with Jim Daly by Focus on the Family

ReFOCUS with Jim Daly

375 Listeners

Navigating Trump 2.0 by CBN News

Navigating Trump 2.0

22 Listeners