Discussion around real estate investing versus mutual fund/index fund investing.
Recap of index fund / ETF investing:
Opening an account with Schwab/Fidleity/Vanguard
Investing in low cost ETF’s/mutual funds
Own a piece of many different companies
Completely passive - you invest and you don’t have to manage anything at all.
On average, you earn roughly 10% per year on the money.
Set it and forget it.Let’s look at the three primary ways you can make money in real estate:
Cash Flow
When you buy an investment property - you’re likely going to put some money down to acquire it.
That money doesn’t really impact your net worth statement. You’re essentially just trading cash for equity in the property.
Assuming you take a loan, you will have a payment amount that includes the debt service (paying down the loan) + taxes
Now let’s say you buy a house, your monthly mortgage with taxes included is $1,500.
Let’s say you’re able to rent that home for $2,400 per month. Your cash flow is $900 per month. That’s income that you’re generating from the property.
Understand that there are other expenses that can occur with maintenance items, etc…. But you get the point…. You CAN generate income through cash flow by owning property.
Appreciation happens when the value of a house goes up over time. We know that on average most homes go up in value about the same amount as inflation, but in some markets and in some years the average home price can rise by much more than the rate of inflation.
It’s estimated that the value of a home went up around 15% or so in the past year.
Appreciation is obviously on the whole home amount, regardless of your loan amount or what you owe… and this can be huge.
Can’t realize all of the appreciation until you sell.
Over time, the renter(s) are paying down your loan. You are thus reducing the loan amount over time and increasing equity in the property.
Increases your net worth on paper, but not money in your pocket until you either refinance or sell.Other things you must consider when buying real estate
Not a passive investment
Must maintain/update the property.
Must deal with tenant issues. Calls at night/holidays/weekends solving problems the client has.
Risk - What if you can’t get a renter, what if the estimates you prepared for STR cash flow are wrong, what if you need cash and the market is down and nobody is buying properties. Are you putting yourself in a bad position financially?
Let’s say you have 100k to invest.
Lance invests in an ETF all 100k. At the end of 30 years he has $1.75M assuming a 10% interest rate return over the 30 year period.
Scott buys a short term rental property for $450,000 in a vacation area. Puts 90,000 down and another 10,000 into furnishing the property.
He manages the property himself and cash flows 15,000 in profit annually from the property (very realistic). His cash flow increases by 3% annually.
At the end of 30 years:
Property is worth ~1.35M (assuming a 3.7% increase in value annually)
His mortgage is paid off
Cash Flow over 30 years is ~700k
Total earned: 2.05M (300k more than passive investing)
What did I give up in that example?? Time!
Consider Liquidity as well - Index funds are more liquid than RE