Kelsi was 17 when she drove her sister Libby German and her friend Abby Williams to a local hiking trail. She never saw them again. The next day, Delphi, Indiana residents made an awful discovery. Their two bodies were found, turning the small Indiana town upside down. 

Follow Kelsi on Twitter.

Sponsors: 

Download the FREE Upside app and use promo code: CIRCUS to get $5 or more cash back. 

Mejuri.com

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.