A leather mask, a clink of cans, and a key turning in a famous front door—our night at the Lizzie Borden house started playful and got serious fast. We walk you room by room through Fall River’s most talked‑about address, balancing the eerie staging with the ordinary rhythm of a B&B: check‑in chatter, locals with big hearts, and a neighbor who opens the shop just to tell stories. The trip becomes a prism for the case itself, where small details—window washing, a handkerchief, a door latch—matter more than legend.

We revisit 1892 with clear eyes: Andrew’s frugality, Abby’s background, adult daughters navigating status and independence, and Bridget’s place in a home that called her by the last maid’s name. The illness that sweeps the house is likely spoiled mutton, not poison, yet fear sets the stage for two killings hours apart. From morphine to caffeine, from a chaotic search to a trial that boiled skulls and paraded them in court, the investigation shows how limited tools warp outcomes. We pull apart the stubborn question—how could anyone inflict that much damage without wearing the blood?—and weigh the possibilities without forcing a neat answer.

Along the way, we examine how media shapes memory. A detour into Ryan Murphy’s Ed Gein series sparks a frank talk about accuracy, empathy, and why production flair can both illuminate and mislead. After acquittal, Lizzie buys Maplecroft, hosts parties, and endures a rhyme that gets the facts wrong but wins the culture anyway. Standing in those rooms, we find less haunting than history—and a reminder that catchy stories often outlive careful ones.

Press play to explore the real timeline, the class and gender dynamics, the missing forensics, and the way travel puts you closer to truth. If this conversation grabs you, follow the show, share it with a friend, and drop your verdict in the comments—what detail convinced you most?

LET US KNOW WHAT YOU THINK!!!

Ready to explore more shocking true crime cases with us? Subscribe to Drink About Something for new episodes every Friday, and visit drinkaboutsomething.site with links to see all our content, including visual evidence from the cases we cover.

AS ALWAYS D-A-S