
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


Last time we spoke about the beginning of the Tikhvin offensive. In the autumn of 1941, a thin road from Leningrad to Moscow braided with mud and grit as two colossal armies pressed toward a grim deadline. On one side, German steel sought a swift triumph; on the other, Soviet resolve rebuilt from ruined lines, shoulder to shoulder with civilians who refused to surrender their city. Cities along the corridor buckled under pressure, Bryansk, Vyazma, Kalinin, yet the Red Army held, taught newcomers, and refused to yield Moscow to the encroaching winter. The Tikhvin Offensive blossomed as a dire race against Rasputitsa and frost. German panzers clawed forward through swamps and forests, sometimes breaking the front and exposing vulnerable flanks. Soviet countermeasures, though hampered by stretched reserves, stitched together new fronts and defensive corridors, buying time for the capital. Civilians endured hunger, cold, and the fear of occupation as fronts shifted like winter winds: planes thundered above, trains groaned along damaged rails, and soldiers traded warmth for survival. The Tikhvin Offensive began, but the war’s winter symphony had only just begun.
This episode is the Wehrmacht Struggled in October Mud
Well hello there, welcome to the Eastern Front week by week podcast, I am your dutiful host Craig Watson. But, before we start I want to also remind you this podcast is only made possible through the efforts of Kings and Generals over at Youtube. Perhaps you want to learn more about world war two? Kings and Generals have an assortment of episodes on world war two and much more so go give them a look over on Youtube. So please subscribe to Kings and Generals over at Youtube and to continue helping us produce this content please check out www.patreon.com/kingsandgenerals. If you are still hungry for some more history related content, over on my channel, the Pacific War Channel you can find a few videos all the way from the Opium Wars of the 1800’s until the end of the Pacific War in 1945.
The German offensive toward Tikhvin fanned out after the 21st. The 12th Panzer Division and the 20th Motorised Division were directed at Tikhvin and made slow but steady progress, with Budogosh falling on the 23rd. Mud and snow created ongoing difficulties, and tanks and trucks were repeatedly lost to the terrain. The level of attrition reached a point that prompted consideration from Hitler about suspending the attack. Leeb and Halder persuaded Hitler to allow the operation to continue. Leeb was granted authorisation to halt the attack at his discretion, provided a bridgehead across the Volkhov River remained intact. To the southeast, the 8th Panzer Division and the 18th Motorised Division were redirected toward Bologoye, with the objective of connecting with Panzer Group 3 from Kalinin. Leeb requested control over Panzer Group 3 and the northern wing of the 9th Army to create a unified command structure for this operation. The request was refused. The offensive proceeded despite the failure of the 3rd Panzer Group to break out of Kalinin. The 18th Motorised Division and the 126th Infantry Division managed to capture Bolshaya Vishera. In response, the 288th Rifle Division and the 267th Rifle Division delayed the German advance long enough to establish a defensive line along the Malaya Vishera River. Supporting offensives by the 2nd and 10th Army Corps toward Vyshniy Volochek and Valday were halted by strong Soviet tank-led counteroffensives.
The 11th and 21st Infantry Divisions were dispatched north along both sides of the Volkhov to cover the German offensive’s flanks and threaten the rear of the 54th Army. North of Kirishi, the 11th Infantry Division was halted by the 285th and 311th Rifle Divisions on the 24th. Recognizing the growing German threat, STAVKA ordered a reshaping of the Soviet force: the 310th Rifle Division and the 4th Guards Division were transferred from the 54th Army to the 4th Army; the 191st Rifle Division moved to Sitomlia; and the 44th Rifle Division was assigned to defend Tikhvin itself. This created a layered defense around the critical railway hub at Tikhvin. The 259th Rifle Division was reassigned to the 52nd Army. The Soviet offensive at Siniavino continued without significant progress, with the objective of drawing German reinforcements away from the Tikhvin front.
Beowulf referred to two German plans to occupy the islands of Saaremaa, Hiiumaa, Muhu, and Vormsi off the eastern coast of Estonia, at the mouth of the Gulf of Riga in the southeastern Baltic region, as part of the broader Barbarossa invasion of the USSR. The proximate trigger for Beowulf planning and execution had been the Soviet Berlin Bombing Offensive. Soviet aircraft staged through an airfield on Ösel, and although the operation had been small and largely ineffective, it prompted German concern. Hitler ordered a reduction of activity on these islands. Their strategic importance had been limited; the northern drive of Barbarossa toward Leningrad had already moved to the north, leaving the islands and their Soviet garrisons largely isolated and vulnerable to smaller craft.
Both Beowulf I and Beowulf II shared the same objective but were based on different starting assumptions. Beowulf I had imagined a rapid German victory in the Baltic states, particularly the seizure of the Courland (Kurland) peninsula as Heeresgruppe Nord advanced toward Leningrad. This would have been a reworking of Operation Albion from World War I, launched from the Courland region of Latvia. In practice, German forces had faced delays crossing into Estonian territory. Beowulf II was the operation actually undertaken, an attack launched from the western coast of Estonia. Diversionary attacks were employed to confuse Soviet defenders Südwind, Westwind, and Nordwind with sub-plans Lel, Nau, and Stimmung designed to mislead. The islands were garrisoned by about 23,700 Soviet troops of the 3rd Rifle Brigade. The German force assigned to the operation consisted of the 61st Infantry Division, reinforced with assault pioneers and artillery. The force was transported from the Estonian coast by about 100 barges and ferries plus roughly 150 smaller assault boats. A joint German–Finnish naval task force covered the landings, including light cruisers Emden, Köln, and Leipzig. During diversionary naval bombardments, the Finnish coastal defense ship Ilmarinen struck a mine off Hanko and sank.
Vormsi was secured on 9 September. The main assault on Muhu began on 14 September; Muhu was connected to Saaremaa Ösel in German by a causeway. Muhu was secured by 16 September, and a bridgehead across the causeway was established the following day. By 23 September, Soviet forces had been pushed back to the Sorve Peninsula, from which they were gradually forced off with assault pioneers and naval gunfire support; the last Soviet troops surrendered on 5 October. The assault on Hiiumaa (Dagö) began on 12 September; defenders retreated to the Takhuna Peninsula, with survivors surrendering on 21 October 1941. Due to Axis naval and air superiority, Soviet forces could not escape; Soviet losses were about 4,700 killed and 19,000 captured. German casualties totaled about 2,850. Afterwards the 61st Infantry Division was redirected to support the offensive toward Tikhvin, while the 217th Infantry Division was reassigned to strengthen the Oranienbaum pocket.
As mud became a larger problem, on 21 October, Beowulf-committed orders had been drafted that all motorised formations abandon their vehicles and temporarily convert to foot infantry with limited artillery. However, this proposal was outright refused by Brauchitsch, who did not believe conditions at the front were so bad that the symbols of modern warfare needed to be abandoned. Yet, senior commanders had already begun implementing similar measures: several formations ordered their advanced battlegroups to abandon vehicles and proceed on foot. Other formations had already been forced to do so due to the practical reality that all their vehicles were stuck, broken down, or out of fuel. The 41st Panzer Corps had been virtually encircled at Kalinin and was subjected to constant attacks from Konev’s Kalinin Front. By 21 October, it had been in continuous combat for 18 days without relief. The remaining elements of the 3rd Panzer Group and supporting infantry corps from the 9th Army had been tied down longer than expected at Vyazma and then slowed to a crawl by mud as they advanced northward. After its aborted attack toward Torzhok, the 1st Panzer Division was stuck on the wrong bank of the Volga and was retreating toward Kalinin. In the span of two weeks, it had lost 63 tanks and had been reduced to 16 operational tanks by 23 October. It had suffered over 800 casualties between 13 and 20 October.
Even with the arrival of elements from the 129th Infantry Division and the 6th Panzer Division, the 9th Army reported that the situation around Kalinin could not be held indefinitely and that the Soviet forces to the south of the city needed to be forced back. The supply situation for the Luftwaffe was so precarious that pilots were throwing bread out of their cockpits as they passed by to provide food. Hitler proposed that the 41st Panzer Corps seize Bezhetsk, over 110 km from Kalinin, shortly after it had failed to take Torzhok, 60 km away. Hitler keenly watched Goebbel’s weekly newsreels and so it is likely his view of the war was highly influenced by his own propaganda output. Furthermore, Bock demanded that another attempt to take Torzhok be planned by the 9th Army. He did not specify whether the Infantry Corps or the 3rd Panzer Group would conduct the operation. Much of the original Mozhaisk Defensive Line had fallen to the Germans, but the Red Army had only been pushed back to a new layer of defensive lines. The Germans remained 80 to 100 km from Moscow. As German formations grew weaker, new formations flowed in to reinforce the defenders. By the end of October, 13 rifle divisions and five tank brigades had arrived, along with several formations raised directly in Moscow. Moreover, the 33rd Army had been inserted into the line between the 5th and 43rd Armies.
The 46th Panzer Corps, positioned at the northern end of the German lines against Moscow, had lacked sufficient fuel to maneuver freely and conduct offensives. They remained on the receiving end of constant Soviet tank and air attacks. Previously, raids were carried out by groups of two bombers with fighter cover; by this time, the VVS had begun launching squadron-strength raids against ground targets as its strength had returned. Additionally, German airfields in the area had become so clogged with mud that planes struggled to reach takeoff speed. To the south, the 40th Panzer Corps pressed headlong down the Smolensk–Moscow highway in largely predictable assaults. Although they were winning battles due to better training, their casualties were becoming prohibitively high and unsustainable. The 2nd Panzer Division assaulted Volokolamsk alongside the 35th Infantry Division. They had managed to capture the rail station just south of the town by the 25th, but Volokolamsk itself remained stubbornly in Soviet hands. The 10th Panzer Division was engaged around Istra but had not managed to seize it. The 57th Panzer Corps had been immobilized outside Kamenskoye all week. Mud deep enough to trap tractors and tanks prevented maneuver, and supply shortages denied them the strength to undertake offensives. The 20th Panzer Division had been left in the rear of the corps due to its severe depletion.
The 4th Panzer Group had been consuming between 1,000 and 1,500 tons of supplies each day, yet it had received only about 200 tons. This forced the Panzer Group to slowly wind down its offensives, as it was unable to sustain them. Similarly, the 4th Army had managed to grind its way toward the Naro-Fominsk area, but was halted by stiffened resistance and ongoing supply shortages. Quartermaster General Eduard Wagner wrote on the 12 of October. ‘The whole front is moving! Unbelievable this theatre of war. Every day I am asked: How far will you get? I always say: So far I have not left anyone in the lurch!’ On the 25th, Soviet counterattacks had slammed into the 4th Army and managed to push German infantry back several kilometers. The 12th Army Corps bore the brunt of the assault and was ordered to go on the defensive. The next day, the counterattack expanded against the 13th and 20th Army Corps. Kluge was forced to commit his two reserve divisions but was unable to stem the Soviet attack and was compelled to request that the Army Group reserve be released. The 19th Panzer Division repositioned itself to save the neighboring infantry divisions from a concentrated attack by Soviet tanks.
Despite some defensive successes, a state of siege had been declared in Moscow on the 20th to ensure the priority flow of resources and reinforcements. There had been a temporary panic in the previous two weeks. Wild rumours and gossip had circulated about the collapse of the Red Army at Bryansk and Vyazma. Some rumours included that Stalin had been removed by a coup d’état or that German paratroopers were in the Red Square or that German troops in Soviet uniforms were already in the city. The population felt betrayed by this apparent retreat of the elite after so much had been demanded of them, which caused a temporary hysteria. Stalin’s declaration that he would remain in the city helped stabilize morale, alongside measures to ensure that shops and the metro system functioned. He also unleashed the NKVD on the city to deal with those who did not accept this metaphorical carrot. However, this unrest had been dealt with by the 20th, so it was unlikely to be related to the declaration of a state of siege.
The Luftwaffe had attempted to bomb Moscow, but by 25 October it had managed to drop only about 1,000 tons of bombs. As a comparison, on a single day in 1944, the RAF dropped approximately 10,050 tons of bombs on the cities of Cologne, Braunschweig , and Duisburg. This occurred as part of Operation Hurricane over the 14th and 15th of October 1944. It represented the largest weight of bombs dropped in a single 24-hour period during World War II. That same month in 1944, the Western Allies dropped a total of 109,975 tons of bombs. For the Moscow bombing, the damage done was utterly negligible, even if the raids proved a hostile and unpleasant experience for the city’s inhabitants. The airframes of the Luftwaffe were ill-suited to such operations, even before the need to substitute payload for additional fuel. Furthermore, the vast majority of raids on Moscow involved only three to ten planes. This campaign likely harmed the Germans more than the Soviets. Large quantities of supplies were required to sustain these raids, and the attrition rate remained high. German planes had an operability rate of only about 40% due to extensive issues caused by the cold, even before the onset of winter.
The aircraft used for these raids were the same ones typically employed for ground-support operations. The pilots who participated in the raids observed the extremely heavy and effective anti-air defences around Moscow. Pilots who had also taken part in the Blitz noted that Moscow’s air defences were far more intense than the London defences during the Blitz in 1940. British Hurricanes and American P-40 Warhawks, known as Tomahawks in Commonwealth and Soviet usage, were flown in the defense of Moscow. While the Hurricane was already approaching obsolescence as a frontline fighter, it was still capable. The Tomahawk was the preferred design among Soviet pilots. Across the entire Eastern Front, the Luftwaffe was losing an average of 268 bombers per month. Production was nowhere near replacement rates, and airframe stockpiles were rapidly depleting. A study by the Inspector General of Fighters, Werner Mölders, into the potentially highly negative effects of winter on the Luftwaffe, was dismissed as alarmist by Göring.
To the south, the 26th Army and NKVD formations defended Tula. The 50th Army had been attempting to withdraw toward Tula but was severely depleted and lacking all heavy equipment. By the 22nd, the 4th Panzer Army had been reinforced by the 3rd Panzer Army, and both were prepared for a new offensive. On the 23rd, the 3rd Panzer Division attacked and gained ground slowly. The 4th Panzer Army was initially ordered to wait until a bridgehead across the Zusha River had been secured before it began its attack. However, the 3rd Panzer was so delayed by conditions and Soviet resistance that by midday the 4th Panzer Army was committed early. By the end of the day, the 3rd Panzer Army had managed to cross the Susha and expand the bridgehead by 6 km. The 4th Panzer Army remained within 3 km of Mtsensk, pinned by entrenched Soviet tanks on nearby high ground. Guderian blamed the lack of success on the 4th Panzer Army not being used as he had intended, while Schweppenburg pointed to the well-concealed Soviet positions that ambushed any German advance.
The offensive was renewed on the 24th with reinforcements from the Großdeutschland regiment. Nevertheless, the 24th Panzer Corps managed only a 3 km advance that day after multiple attacks were repulsed. The ammunition of the 24th Panzer Corps was nearly exhausted, and the 4th Panzer Division had completely run out of fuel. Some formations in Guderian’s 2nd Panzer Army required airlifts of food because their access to supplies had deteriorated to a terrible level. One example was the 43rd Army Corps, which had received no supplies between the 20th and 29th. It was out of rations and nearly out of fodder for the horses, and its area of operations had already been picked clean. The fuel issue was alleviated through an airlift. The mud forced the 4th Panzer to use its tanks as supply vehicles, and all of its wheeled transport was immobilized. However, the Soviet defenders fell back during the night of October 24. This allowed the 24th Panzer Corps to capture Chern, 30 km north of Mtsensk. In their wake, the Soviets had destroyed every bridge possible and laid random minefields. The Germans used Panzer I tanks as sacrificial mine clearers which the other tanks carefully followed behind. A slow pursuit of the retreating Soviet forces toward Tula commenced as rear-area troops desperately attempted to repair roads and bridges. Due to a shortage of trucks to move infantry, the leading battlegroup adopted the Soviet method, with infantry from the Großdeutschland regiment riding on the backs of advancing tanks.
Elsewhere, the 48th Panzer Corps, alongside the 34th and 35th Army Corps, were transferred to the Second Army, which was designated as responsible for the Kursk-Voronezh area. The 48th possessed only one Panzer division. It had been reduced to 11 tanks by the 24th and was stalled 85 km from Kursk, with Voronezh another 200 km distant. The Second Panzer Army was then to be responsible solely for the capture of Tula. Only General Bock opposed such dispersion of his Army Group’s strength, as it was now attacking to the north and south in addition to Moscow. Bock’s War Diary 25th October stated “The splitting apart of the army group together with the frightful weather has caused us to be bogged down. As a result the Russians are gaining time to bring their shattered divisions back up to strength and bolster their defence, especially since they have most of the rail lines and roads around Moscow. That is very bad!’” All the other generals at OKH and OKW either meekly submitted to Hitler’s desire in this case or were so entangled by the lure of victory that they had long disregarded reality. This situation would only worsen in the coming days. Guderian’s Second Panzer Army would also lose the 1st Cavalry Division as it was ordered to be returned to Germany and converted into the 24th Panzer Division. This process would take months to complete and would return to service in Russia in the summer of 1942.
At the same time, four infantry divisions and Corps Headquarters were withdrawn to the west. Many horses had been so weakened and overexerted by the campaign that their health had irreversibly collapsed. During the return train journeys, they often had to halt to unload the horse corpses. The mud, alongside the broken supply network, had deprived the German Army of its primary advantage: mobility. In his war diary, von Bock complained that “the Russians are impeding us far less than the wet and the mud.” Quartermaster General Eduard Wagner wrote on the 20th ‘It can no longer be concealed’ ‘we are hung up in the muck, in the purest sense.’ The rainfall in October 1941 was below average, and the temperature was only 1°C below the long-term average. These conditions were not a surprise to anyone, and any competent staff could have foreseen and mitigated many of the issues caused by the predictable weather.
General Heinrici of the 43rd Army Corps reported taking 36 hours to drive only 35 km, while the 137th Division reported it took 53 hours for three trucks to travel 40 km. Fun fact this was significantly slower than Napoleon’s forces were able to travel during the same period in 1812. It was now taking up to 24 draft horses to move a single artillery gun. Sometimes the mud was so deep that horses could fall up to their necks into the quagmire and become irrecoverably stuck. But mud was not the only problem. The 2,093 trains that reached the eastern front in September had not been nearly adequate to meet demand; in October, only 1,860 trains arrived. Compounding the issue, those trains were further behind the front lines. Many formations were now 300–400 km from their supplying railhead. Even the most fortunate formations attacking Moscow were still about 115 km from their supply hub at Vyazma. This distance would attrit supply vehicles quickly.
Alone, this would have been a logistical catastrophe. The mud severely exacerbated these problems, and no precautions had been taken beforehand to address the conditions. Many formations found that the effort to tow supply vehicles forward through the mud consumed nearly as much fuel as it brought forward. The German logistical machine, numbering over 600,000 supply vehicles in the East, had been reduced to about 75,000 by mid-November. At any one time, roughly half were in repair stations. The Wehrmacht was being demotorised. The Germans were forced to learn how to scrounge from the land, to capture and reconfigure all Soviet vehicles they encountered simply to survive. Most divisions were now reliant on columns of horse-drawn Panje wagons, Luftwaffe air drops, or river barges to move supplies.
The Germans faced an increasing deployment of T-34 and KV-1 tanks by the Soviets, which were also employed with growing competence. German complaints consistently centered on their tank cannons and anti-tank guns’ inability to reliably defeat Soviet tanks at range. By contrast, Soviet tank guns proved highly effective against the armor of even the heaviest German tanks in service. The Germans were forced to rely on heavy artillery or the temporarily attached 88 mm Flak guns in a direct-fire role. This culminated in a Hitler decree ordering that all formations on the Eastern Front be equipped with Flak 88 guns. The T-34 was one of the few pieces of equipment that the Germans feared in 1941, though it appears likely that KV-1 tanks were often misidentified as T-34s in German reports. Soviet artillery would become feared by the Germans; however, in 1941, Soviet ranging and coordination of its fire were poor, heavily restricting the effectiveness of Soviet artillery at this point.
In Ukraine, the first battle of Kharkiv began on the 22nd, as the forward defenses of the city were attacked by the 57th Infantry and the 101st Jäger divisions. The attack occurred despite Hitler’s prohibition against directly assaulting Soviet cities. The Germans were so close to Kharkiv and desperately sought the shelter it provided, in addition to the rail links flowing through the city. Several German formations would make random attacks just to capture a nearby village. They hoped this would afford them shelter from the cold and night but often Soviet forces ensured to destroy as much shelter as possible before retreating. The assault on the city itself commenced the following day. Its start was delayed by mud that slowed the deployment of artillery and anti-tank guns. By the 24th, Kharkiv had fallen into German hands. The city was lightly defended by only the 216th Rifle Division, which was sacrificed to buy time for the 38th Army to fall back. The 216th rifle division had also been recently reformed after being destroyed during the Uman pocket. Therefore, it received no supporting action. The Soviets had no reason to defend the city, its industry, including the large T-34 plant, had already been evacuated.
The 6th Army’s objective had been to reach Kursk and Voronezh, linking up with the Second Army, while the 17th Army was to continue toward Stalingrad. However, on the 22nd this plan was updated. The 6th Army was now tasked with capturing Belgorod to secure rail connections, and the 17th Army with establishing a bridgehead at Izyum. Both armies were then to halt to collect supplies for the winter, an operation estimated to take three weeks. Only after achieving sufficient supplies were they to return to their previous objectives, advancing along rail connections where possible.
The First Panzer Army remained mostly static for the week due to extreme fuel shortages and defending attacks from the 9th Army. The 9th Army was attempting to buy time for the new 56th Army, which fielded six rifle divisions and six cavalry divisions that were still assembling and being transported to Rostov. Manstein received new orders to capture Tuapse and Krasnodar, but first he had to break through the neck of the peninsula. A breach existed in the Soviet defences north of Inshin, but his infantry lacked the speed to truly exploit it before more soviet forces arrived. Mainstein pressed for a mobile division to be allocated to his command, but Kleist refused on the grounds of having sufficient fuel to make the transfer and also make his push to Rostov. He also claimed such a transfer would weaken his forces too much to capture the city. Essentially this forced Hitler to determine if Rostov or Crimea was the priority for forces in the South. Rostov would be chosen as the priority on the 26th. The fighting over the week was so fierce that, on the 25th, Hausen claimed his 54th Army Corps was combat-ineffective; this claim was rejected by Manstein. The arrival of promised Luftwaffe support significantly helped protect ground forces from Soviet air attacks and hinder Soviet defensive efforts. Six fighter groups, three dive-bomber groups, and two Italian fighter groups arrived in Ukraine. These air units were split between the Crimea and Rostov sectors while also providing fighter cover for the 17th and 6th Armies. This week also saw the commander of the Soviet 51st Army, Kuznetsov, replaced by Batov due to poor initial deployment of forces. Vice Admiral Levchenko was placed in overall command of the peninsula to coordinate between the 51st Army and the Independent Coastal Army, which had arrived from Odessa.
German offensives across the Soviet Union had stalled again. If the USSR managed to survive the year, longer-term factors would begin to take effect. An October study by General Georg Thomas, head of the German War Economy Office, suggested that the USSR was not as close to economic collapse as previously thought. Furthermore, American war industry was outstripping German production, which theoretically could be directed to the UK and/or the USSR in its entirety, given the United States’ wartime neutrality-ending stance and eventual Lend-Lease commitments. It was projected that the United States would produce approximately 4,700 combat aircraft, 2,600 armored fighting vehicles, and more than 1,600 artillery pieces in the eight months between October 1941 and May 1942. This output was greater than the entire annual German production at that time. The full details of Allied aid to the USSR were complex enough to warrant a dedicated future analysis. By October, the First Protocol had been signed between the UK, USA, and USSR, promising roughly 400 planes and 500 tanks per month, along with a range of raw materials and other weaponry, though actual deliveries would fall short of these figures. The British had already dispatched two convoys to the USSR prior to the agreement; the second convoy had brought 140 tanks, 100 Hurricane fighters, and 200 universal carriers. These were the Valentine and Matilda models. The Matilda would not be too popular with the Soviets but the Valentine would become loved as a scout tank over time. The Soviets also criticized the low caliber guns on both British models and their relatively poor cross country speed. However these tanks were still capable of matching the fielded German tanks and the Soviets were in desperate need for more tanks. Overall 466 British tanks would be delivered over 1941. Additionally, Britain had begun sharing information from ULTRA intercepts with the Soviet Union. Ultra was the British codename for the signal interception and decryption work done at Bletchley Park However, suspicions in Moscow that the British were willing to fight to the last drop of Soviet blood had begun to surface. This situation had been fueled by the apparent reluctance of the British to actively engage the Germans on the ground in Europe or to send troops into the USSR, while they were nonetheless willing to replace Soviet garrisons in occupied Iran. The fact that sending aid to the USSR was severely hindering British rearmament after their own disasters in 1940 and 1941 was overlooked.Accusations of such strained the British-Soviet relationship, recalling Soviet support for Nazi Germany against the United Kingdom months earlier. While these tensions and other factors placed strain on the alliance, they were not sufficient to fracture it, as both sides recognized their mutual need.
The USSR held a distinctly stronger industrial position than the Germans. For example, the Soviet Union produced over 500 tanks in October, compared with the German output of 387 tanks. The vast majority of Soviet tank production had already shifted to the KV-1, T-34, and T-60 models, and in the last quarter of 1941 alone these three lines accounted for a surge of output: 441 KV-1s, 765 T-34s, and 1,388 T-60s. This shift occurred despite the upheaval caused by evacuating a significant portion of Soviet industry beyond the Urals.
German production priorities had already shifted away from the Army, and it would take months or even years to reverse that shift. Worse for Germany, there was growing concern about the onset of hyperinflation once more. Additionally, crude oil shipments from Romania declined from 375,000 tonnes to 253,000 tonnes during October. This drop mattered greatly because the naval and air war against the Western Allies was consuming substantial amounts of fuel oil and aviation gasoline. The USSR was primarily engaged in a land and air war against the European Axis and, in theory, could dedicate all of its war production to this single conflict. Germany, by contrast, found itself fighting on multiple fronts: a land war against the USSR and, to some extent, the Commonwealth in Africa, while also waging an air and naval war against the Commonwealth and contending with broader resource and industrial pressures. This meant Germany faced intensified demands on its industrial base to sustain operations across Europe, North Africa, and the Atlantic, whereas the USSR could, in principle, concentrate its industrial mobilization on the European Axis front. The result was different production and logistics dynamics for each side, with the USSR able to channel more of its output toward armored, infantry, and airpower suitable for the Eastern Front, while Germany had to balance expansion, occupation administration, and long supply lines across multiple theaters. The Germans increasingly desired the Caucasus oil fields to offset their limited access to oil. This economic strain would contribute to discussions about using Soviet POWs as slave labor.
I would like to take this time to remind you all that this podcast is only made possible through the efforts of Kings and Generals over at Youtube. Please go subscribe to Kings and Generals over at Youtube and to continue helping us produce this content please check out www.patreon.com/kingsandgenerals. If you are still hungry after that, give my personal channel a look over at The Pacific War Channel at Youtube, it would mean a lot to me.
The October 1941 front near Moscow lay in mud and attrition as Germans pressed toward Tikhvin and Moscow while Soviets patched defenses. The German advance, hampered by flooding, fuel shortages, and relentless Soviet counterattacks, stretched logistics and slowed progress; Beowulf operations in the Baltic fizzled under Soviet resistance. By month’s end, German forces faced supply crises, fuel shortages, and mounting casualties, prompting partial redeployments and even discussions of slowing or halting offensives.
By theeasternfrontLast time we spoke about the beginning of the Tikhvin offensive. In the autumn of 1941, a thin road from Leningrad to Moscow braided with mud and grit as two colossal armies pressed toward a grim deadline. On one side, German steel sought a swift triumph; on the other, Soviet resolve rebuilt from ruined lines, shoulder to shoulder with civilians who refused to surrender their city. Cities along the corridor buckled under pressure, Bryansk, Vyazma, Kalinin, yet the Red Army held, taught newcomers, and refused to yield Moscow to the encroaching winter. The Tikhvin Offensive blossomed as a dire race against Rasputitsa and frost. German panzers clawed forward through swamps and forests, sometimes breaking the front and exposing vulnerable flanks. Soviet countermeasures, though hampered by stretched reserves, stitched together new fronts and defensive corridors, buying time for the capital. Civilians endured hunger, cold, and the fear of occupation as fronts shifted like winter winds: planes thundered above, trains groaned along damaged rails, and soldiers traded warmth for survival. The Tikhvin Offensive began, but the war’s winter symphony had only just begun.
This episode is the Wehrmacht Struggled in October Mud
Well hello there, welcome to the Eastern Front week by week podcast, I am your dutiful host Craig Watson. But, before we start I want to also remind you this podcast is only made possible through the efforts of Kings and Generals over at Youtube. Perhaps you want to learn more about world war two? Kings and Generals have an assortment of episodes on world war two and much more so go give them a look over on Youtube. So please subscribe to Kings and Generals over at Youtube and to continue helping us produce this content please check out www.patreon.com/kingsandgenerals. If you are still hungry for some more history related content, over on my channel, the Pacific War Channel you can find a few videos all the way from the Opium Wars of the 1800’s until the end of the Pacific War in 1945.
The German offensive toward Tikhvin fanned out after the 21st. The 12th Panzer Division and the 20th Motorised Division were directed at Tikhvin and made slow but steady progress, with Budogosh falling on the 23rd. Mud and snow created ongoing difficulties, and tanks and trucks were repeatedly lost to the terrain. The level of attrition reached a point that prompted consideration from Hitler about suspending the attack. Leeb and Halder persuaded Hitler to allow the operation to continue. Leeb was granted authorisation to halt the attack at his discretion, provided a bridgehead across the Volkhov River remained intact. To the southeast, the 8th Panzer Division and the 18th Motorised Division were redirected toward Bologoye, with the objective of connecting with Panzer Group 3 from Kalinin. Leeb requested control over Panzer Group 3 and the northern wing of the 9th Army to create a unified command structure for this operation. The request was refused. The offensive proceeded despite the failure of the 3rd Panzer Group to break out of Kalinin. The 18th Motorised Division and the 126th Infantry Division managed to capture Bolshaya Vishera. In response, the 288th Rifle Division and the 267th Rifle Division delayed the German advance long enough to establish a defensive line along the Malaya Vishera River. Supporting offensives by the 2nd and 10th Army Corps toward Vyshniy Volochek and Valday were halted by strong Soviet tank-led counteroffensives.
The 11th and 21st Infantry Divisions were dispatched north along both sides of the Volkhov to cover the German offensive’s flanks and threaten the rear of the 54th Army. North of Kirishi, the 11th Infantry Division was halted by the 285th and 311th Rifle Divisions on the 24th. Recognizing the growing German threat, STAVKA ordered a reshaping of the Soviet force: the 310th Rifle Division and the 4th Guards Division were transferred from the 54th Army to the 4th Army; the 191st Rifle Division moved to Sitomlia; and the 44th Rifle Division was assigned to defend Tikhvin itself. This created a layered defense around the critical railway hub at Tikhvin. The 259th Rifle Division was reassigned to the 52nd Army. The Soviet offensive at Siniavino continued without significant progress, with the objective of drawing German reinforcements away from the Tikhvin front.
Beowulf referred to two German plans to occupy the islands of Saaremaa, Hiiumaa, Muhu, and Vormsi off the eastern coast of Estonia, at the mouth of the Gulf of Riga in the southeastern Baltic region, as part of the broader Barbarossa invasion of the USSR. The proximate trigger for Beowulf planning and execution had been the Soviet Berlin Bombing Offensive. Soviet aircraft staged through an airfield on Ösel, and although the operation had been small and largely ineffective, it prompted German concern. Hitler ordered a reduction of activity on these islands. Their strategic importance had been limited; the northern drive of Barbarossa toward Leningrad had already moved to the north, leaving the islands and their Soviet garrisons largely isolated and vulnerable to smaller craft.
Both Beowulf I and Beowulf II shared the same objective but were based on different starting assumptions. Beowulf I had imagined a rapid German victory in the Baltic states, particularly the seizure of the Courland (Kurland) peninsula as Heeresgruppe Nord advanced toward Leningrad. This would have been a reworking of Operation Albion from World War I, launched from the Courland region of Latvia. In practice, German forces had faced delays crossing into Estonian territory. Beowulf II was the operation actually undertaken, an attack launched from the western coast of Estonia. Diversionary attacks were employed to confuse Soviet defenders Südwind, Westwind, and Nordwind with sub-plans Lel, Nau, and Stimmung designed to mislead. The islands were garrisoned by about 23,700 Soviet troops of the 3rd Rifle Brigade. The German force assigned to the operation consisted of the 61st Infantry Division, reinforced with assault pioneers and artillery. The force was transported from the Estonian coast by about 100 barges and ferries plus roughly 150 smaller assault boats. A joint German–Finnish naval task force covered the landings, including light cruisers Emden, Köln, and Leipzig. During diversionary naval bombardments, the Finnish coastal defense ship Ilmarinen struck a mine off Hanko and sank.
Vormsi was secured on 9 September. The main assault on Muhu began on 14 September; Muhu was connected to Saaremaa Ösel in German by a causeway. Muhu was secured by 16 September, and a bridgehead across the causeway was established the following day. By 23 September, Soviet forces had been pushed back to the Sorve Peninsula, from which they were gradually forced off with assault pioneers and naval gunfire support; the last Soviet troops surrendered on 5 October. The assault on Hiiumaa (Dagö) began on 12 September; defenders retreated to the Takhuna Peninsula, with survivors surrendering on 21 October 1941. Due to Axis naval and air superiority, Soviet forces could not escape; Soviet losses were about 4,700 killed and 19,000 captured. German casualties totaled about 2,850. Afterwards the 61st Infantry Division was redirected to support the offensive toward Tikhvin, while the 217th Infantry Division was reassigned to strengthen the Oranienbaum pocket.
As mud became a larger problem, on 21 October, Beowulf-committed orders had been drafted that all motorised formations abandon their vehicles and temporarily convert to foot infantry with limited artillery. However, this proposal was outright refused by Brauchitsch, who did not believe conditions at the front were so bad that the symbols of modern warfare needed to be abandoned. Yet, senior commanders had already begun implementing similar measures: several formations ordered their advanced battlegroups to abandon vehicles and proceed on foot. Other formations had already been forced to do so due to the practical reality that all their vehicles were stuck, broken down, or out of fuel. The 41st Panzer Corps had been virtually encircled at Kalinin and was subjected to constant attacks from Konev’s Kalinin Front. By 21 October, it had been in continuous combat for 18 days without relief. The remaining elements of the 3rd Panzer Group and supporting infantry corps from the 9th Army had been tied down longer than expected at Vyazma and then slowed to a crawl by mud as they advanced northward. After its aborted attack toward Torzhok, the 1st Panzer Division was stuck on the wrong bank of the Volga and was retreating toward Kalinin. In the span of two weeks, it had lost 63 tanks and had been reduced to 16 operational tanks by 23 October. It had suffered over 800 casualties between 13 and 20 October.
Even with the arrival of elements from the 129th Infantry Division and the 6th Panzer Division, the 9th Army reported that the situation around Kalinin could not be held indefinitely and that the Soviet forces to the south of the city needed to be forced back. The supply situation for the Luftwaffe was so precarious that pilots were throwing bread out of their cockpits as they passed by to provide food. Hitler proposed that the 41st Panzer Corps seize Bezhetsk, over 110 km from Kalinin, shortly after it had failed to take Torzhok, 60 km away. Hitler keenly watched Goebbel’s weekly newsreels and so it is likely his view of the war was highly influenced by his own propaganda output. Furthermore, Bock demanded that another attempt to take Torzhok be planned by the 9th Army. He did not specify whether the Infantry Corps or the 3rd Panzer Group would conduct the operation. Much of the original Mozhaisk Defensive Line had fallen to the Germans, but the Red Army had only been pushed back to a new layer of defensive lines. The Germans remained 80 to 100 km from Moscow. As German formations grew weaker, new formations flowed in to reinforce the defenders. By the end of October, 13 rifle divisions and five tank brigades had arrived, along with several formations raised directly in Moscow. Moreover, the 33rd Army had been inserted into the line between the 5th and 43rd Armies.
The 46th Panzer Corps, positioned at the northern end of the German lines against Moscow, had lacked sufficient fuel to maneuver freely and conduct offensives. They remained on the receiving end of constant Soviet tank and air attacks. Previously, raids were carried out by groups of two bombers with fighter cover; by this time, the VVS had begun launching squadron-strength raids against ground targets as its strength had returned. Additionally, German airfields in the area had become so clogged with mud that planes struggled to reach takeoff speed. To the south, the 40th Panzer Corps pressed headlong down the Smolensk–Moscow highway in largely predictable assaults. Although they were winning battles due to better training, their casualties were becoming prohibitively high and unsustainable. The 2nd Panzer Division assaulted Volokolamsk alongside the 35th Infantry Division. They had managed to capture the rail station just south of the town by the 25th, but Volokolamsk itself remained stubbornly in Soviet hands. The 10th Panzer Division was engaged around Istra but had not managed to seize it. The 57th Panzer Corps had been immobilized outside Kamenskoye all week. Mud deep enough to trap tractors and tanks prevented maneuver, and supply shortages denied them the strength to undertake offensives. The 20th Panzer Division had been left in the rear of the corps due to its severe depletion.
The 4th Panzer Group had been consuming between 1,000 and 1,500 tons of supplies each day, yet it had received only about 200 tons. This forced the Panzer Group to slowly wind down its offensives, as it was unable to sustain them. Similarly, the 4th Army had managed to grind its way toward the Naro-Fominsk area, but was halted by stiffened resistance and ongoing supply shortages. Quartermaster General Eduard Wagner wrote on the 12 of October. ‘The whole front is moving! Unbelievable this theatre of war. Every day I am asked: How far will you get? I always say: So far I have not left anyone in the lurch!’ On the 25th, Soviet counterattacks had slammed into the 4th Army and managed to push German infantry back several kilometers. The 12th Army Corps bore the brunt of the assault and was ordered to go on the defensive. The next day, the counterattack expanded against the 13th and 20th Army Corps. Kluge was forced to commit his two reserve divisions but was unable to stem the Soviet attack and was compelled to request that the Army Group reserve be released. The 19th Panzer Division repositioned itself to save the neighboring infantry divisions from a concentrated attack by Soviet tanks.
Despite some defensive successes, a state of siege had been declared in Moscow on the 20th to ensure the priority flow of resources and reinforcements. There had been a temporary panic in the previous two weeks. Wild rumours and gossip had circulated about the collapse of the Red Army at Bryansk and Vyazma. Some rumours included that Stalin had been removed by a coup d’état or that German paratroopers were in the Red Square or that German troops in Soviet uniforms were already in the city. The population felt betrayed by this apparent retreat of the elite after so much had been demanded of them, which caused a temporary hysteria. Stalin’s declaration that he would remain in the city helped stabilize morale, alongside measures to ensure that shops and the metro system functioned. He also unleashed the NKVD on the city to deal with those who did not accept this metaphorical carrot. However, this unrest had been dealt with by the 20th, so it was unlikely to be related to the declaration of a state of siege.
The Luftwaffe had attempted to bomb Moscow, but by 25 October it had managed to drop only about 1,000 tons of bombs. As a comparison, on a single day in 1944, the RAF dropped approximately 10,050 tons of bombs on the cities of Cologne, Braunschweig , and Duisburg. This occurred as part of Operation Hurricane over the 14th and 15th of October 1944. It represented the largest weight of bombs dropped in a single 24-hour period during World War II. That same month in 1944, the Western Allies dropped a total of 109,975 tons of bombs. For the Moscow bombing, the damage done was utterly negligible, even if the raids proved a hostile and unpleasant experience for the city’s inhabitants. The airframes of the Luftwaffe were ill-suited to such operations, even before the need to substitute payload for additional fuel. Furthermore, the vast majority of raids on Moscow involved only three to ten planes. This campaign likely harmed the Germans more than the Soviets. Large quantities of supplies were required to sustain these raids, and the attrition rate remained high. German planes had an operability rate of only about 40% due to extensive issues caused by the cold, even before the onset of winter.
The aircraft used for these raids were the same ones typically employed for ground-support operations. The pilots who participated in the raids observed the extremely heavy and effective anti-air defences around Moscow. Pilots who had also taken part in the Blitz noted that Moscow’s air defences were far more intense than the London defences during the Blitz in 1940. British Hurricanes and American P-40 Warhawks, known as Tomahawks in Commonwealth and Soviet usage, were flown in the defense of Moscow. While the Hurricane was already approaching obsolescence as a frontline fighter, it was still capable. The Tomahawk was the preferred design among Soviet pilots. Across the entire Eastern Front, the Luftwaffe was losing an average of 268 bombers per month. Production was nowhere near replacement rates, and airframe stockpiles were rapidly depleting. A study by the Inspector General of Fighters, Werner Mölders, into the potentially highly negative effects of winter on the Luftwaffe, was dismissed as alarmist by Göring.
To the south, the 26th Army and NKVD formations defended Tula. The 50th Army had been attempting to withdraw toward Tula but was severely depleted and lacking all heavy equipment. By the 22nd, the 4th Panzer Army had been reinforced by the 3rd Panzer Army, and both were prepared for a new offensive. On the 23rd, the 3rd Panzer Division attacked and gained ground slowly. The 4th Panzer Army was initially ordered to wait until a bridgehead across the Zusha River had been secured before it began its attack. However, the 3rd Panzer was so delayed by conditions and Soviet resistance that by midday the 4th Panzer Army was committed early. By the end of the day, the 3rd Panzer Army had managed to cross the Susha and expand the bridgehead by 6 km. The 4th Panzer Army remained within 3 km of Mtsensk, pinned by entrenched Soviet tanks on nearby high ground. Guderian blamed the lack of success on the 4th Panzer Army not being used as he had intended, while Schweppenburg pointed to the well-concealed Soviet positions that ambushed any German advance.
The offensive was renewed on the 24th with reinforcements from the Großdeutschland regiment. Nevertheless, the 24th Panzer Corps managed only a 3 km advance that day after multiple attacks were repulsed. The ammunition of the 24th Panzer Corps was nearly exhausted, and the 4th Panzer Division had completely run out of fuel. Some formations in Guderian’s 2nd Panzer Army required airlifts of food because their access to supplies had deteriorated to a terrible level. One example was the 43rd Army Corps, which had received no supplies between the 20th and 29th. It was out of rations and nearly out of fodder for the horses, and its area of operations had already been picked clean. The fuel issue was alleviated through an airlift. The mud forced the 4th Panzer to use its tanks as supply vehicles, and all of its wheeled transport was immobilized. However, the Soviet defenders fell back during the night of October 24. This allowed the 24th Panzer Corps to capture Chern, 30 km north of Mtsensk. In their wake, the Soviets had destroyed every bridge possible and laid random minefields. The Germans used Panzer I tanks as sacrificial mine clearers which the other tanks carefully followed behind. A slow pursuit of the retreating Soviet forces toward Tula commenced as rear-area troops desperately attempted to repair roads and bridges. Due to a shortage of trucks to move infantry, the leading battlegroup adopted the Soviet method, with infantry from the Großdeutschland regiment riding on the backs of advancing tanks.
Elsewhere, the 48th Panzer Corps, alongside the 34th and 35th Army Corps, were transferred to the Second Army, which was designated as responsible for the Kursk-Voronezh area. The 48th possessed only one Panzer division. It had been reduced to 11 tanks by the 24th and was stalled 85 km from Kursk, with Voronezh another 200 km distant. The Second Panzer Army was then to be responsible solely for the capture of Tula. Only General Bock opposed such dispersion of his Army Group’s strength, as it was now attacking to the north and south in addition to Moscow. Bock’s War Diary 25th October stated “The splitting apart of the army group together with the frightful weather has caused us to be bogged down. As a result the Russians are gaining time to bring their shattered divisions back up to strength and bolster their defence, especially since they have most of the rail lines and roads around Moscow. That is very bad!’” All the other generals at OKH and OKW either meekly submitted to Hitler’s desire in this case or were so entangled by the lure of victory that they had long disregarded reality. This situation would only worsen in the coming days. Guderian’s Second Panzer Army would also lose the 1st Cavalry Division as it was ordered to be returned to Germany and converted into the 24th Panzer Division. This process would take months to complete and would return to service in Russia in the summer of 1942.
At the same time, four infantry divisions and Corps Headquarters were withdrawn to the west. Many horses had been so weakened and overexerted by the campaign that their health had irreversibly collapsed. During the return train journeys, they often had to halt to unload the horse corpses. The mud, alongside the broken supply network, had deprived the German Army of its primary advantage: mobility. In his war diary, von Bock complained that “the Russians are impeding us far less than the wet and the mud.” Quartermaster General Eduard Wagner wrote on the 20th ‘It can no longer be concealed’ ‘we are hung up in the muck, in the purest sense.’ The rainfall in October 1941 was below average, and the temperature was only 1°C below the long-term average. These conditions were not a surprise to anyone, and any competent staff could have foreseen and mitigated many of the issues caused by the predictable weather.
General Heinrici of the 43rd Army Corps reported taking 36 hours to drive only 35 km, while the 137th Division reported it took 53 hours for three trucks to travel 40 km. Fun fact this was significantly slower than Napoleon’s forces were able to travel during the same period in 1812. It was now taking up to 24 draft horses to move a single artillery gun. Sometimes the mud was so deep that horses could fall up to their necks into the quagmire and become irrecoverably stuck. But mud was not the only problem. The 2,093 trains that reached the eastern front in September had not been nearly adequate to meet demand; in October, only 1,860 trains arrived. Compounding the issue, those trains were further behind the front lines. Many formations were now 300–400 km from their supplying railhead. Even the most fortunate formations attacking Moscow were still about 115 km from their supply hub at Vyazma. This distance would attrit supply vehicles quickly.
Alone, this would have been a logistical catastrophe. The mud severely exacerbated these problems, and no precautions had been taken beforehand to address the conditions. Many formations found that the effort to tow supply vehicles forward through the mud consumed nearly as much fuel as it brought forward. The German logistical machine, numbering over 600,000 supply vehicles in the East, had been reduced to about 75,000 by mid-November. At any one time, roughly half were in repair stations. The Wehrmacht was being demotorised. The Germans were forced to learn how to scrounge from the land, to capture and reconfigure all Soviet vehicles they encountered simply to survive. Most divisions were now reliant on columns of horse-drawn Panje wagons, Luftwaffe air drops, or river barges to move supplies.
The Germans faced an increasing deployment of T-34 and KV-1 tanks by the Soviets, which were also employed with growing competence. German complaints consistently centered on their tank cannons and anti-tank guns’ inability to reliably defeat Soviet tanks at range. By contrast, Soviet tank guns proved highly effective against the armor of even the heaviest German tanks in service. The Germans were forced to rely on heavy artillery or the temporarily attached 88 mm Flak guns in a direct-fire role. This culminated in a Hitler decree ordering that all formations on the Eastern Front be equipped with Flak 88 guns. The T-34 was one of the few pieces of equipment that the Germans feared in 1941, though it appears likely that KV-1 tanks were often misidentified as T-34s in German reports. Soviet artillery would become feared by the Germans; however, in 1941, Soviet ranging and coordination of its fire were poor, heavily restricting the effectiveness of Soviet artillery at this point.
In Ukraine, the first battle of Kharkiv began on the 22nd, as the forward defenses of the city were attacked by the 57th Infantry and the 101st Jäger divisions. The attack occurred despite Hitler’s prohibition against directly assaulting Soviet cities. The Germans were so close to Kharkiv and desperately sought the shelter it provided, in addition to the rail links flowing through the city. Several German formations would make random attacks just to capture a nearby village. They hoped this would afford them shelter from the cold and night but often Soviet forces ensured to destroy as much shelter as possible before retreating. The assault on the city itself commenced the following day. Its start was delayed by mud that slowed the deployment of artillery and anti-tank guns. By the 24th, Kharkiv had fallen into German hands. The city was lightly defended by only the 216th Rifle Division, which was sacrificed to buy time for the 38th Army to fall back. The 216th rifle division had also been recently reformed after being destroyed during the Uman pocket. Therefore, it received no supporting action. The Soviets had no reason to defend the city, its industry, including the large T-34 plant, had already been evacuated.
The 6th Army’s objective had been to reach Kursk and Voronezh, linking up with the Second Army, while the 17th Army was to continue toward Stalingrad. However, on the 22nd this plan was updated. The 6th Army was now tasked with capturing Belgorod to secure rail connections, and the 17th Army with establishing a bridgehead at Izyum. Both armies were then to halt to collect supplies for the winter, an operation estimated to take three weeks. Only after achieving sufficient supplies were they to return to their previous objectives, advancing along rail connections where possible.
The First Panzer Army remained mostly static for the week due to extreme fuel shortages and defending attacks from the 9th Army. The 9th Army was attempting to buy time for the new 56th Army, which fielded six rifle divisions and six cavalry divisions that were still assembling and being transported to Rostov. Manstein received new orders to capture Tuapse and Krasnodar, but first he had to break through the neck of the peninsula. A breach existed in the Soviet defences north of Inshin, but his infantry lacked the speed to truly exploit it before more soviet forces arrived. Mainstein pressed for a mobile division to be allocated to his command, but Kleist refused on the grounds of having sufficient fuel to make the transfer and also make his push to Rostov. He also claimed such a transfer would weaken his forces too much to capture the city. Essentially this forced Hitler to determine if Rostov or Crimea was the priority for forces in the South. Rostov would be chosen as the priority on the 26th. The fighting over the week was so fierce that, on the 25th, Hausen claimed his 54th Army Corps was combat-ineffective; this claim was rejected by Manstein. The arrival of promised Luftwaffe support significantly helped protect ground forces from Soviet air attacks and hinder Soviet defensive efforts. Six fighter groups, three dive-bomber groups, and two Italian fighter groups arrived in Ukraine. These air units were split between the Crimea and Rostov sectors while also providing fighter cover for the 17th and 6th Armies. This week also saw the commander of the Soviet 51st Army, Kuznetsov, replaced by Batov due to poor initial deployment of forces. Vice Admiral Levchenko was placed in overall command of the peninsula to coordinate between the 51st Army and the Independent Coastal Army, which had arrived from Odessa.
German offensives across the Soviet Union had stalled again. If the USSR managed to survive the year, longer-term factors would begin to take effect. An October study by General Georg Thomas, head of the German War Economy Office, suggested that the USSR was not as close to economic collapse as previously thought. Furthermore, American war industry was outstripping German production, which theoretically could be directed to the UK and/or the USSR in its entirety, given the United States’ wartime neutrality-ending stance and eventual Lend-Lease commitments. It was projected that the United States would produce approximately 4,700 combat aircraft, 2,600 armored fighting vehicles, and more than 1,600 artillery pieces in the eight months between October 1941 and May 1942. This output was greater than the entire annual German production at that time. The full details of Allied aid to the USSR were complex enough to warrant a dedicated future analysis. By October, the First Protocol had been signed between the UK, USA, and USSR, promising roughly 400 planes and 500 tanks per month, along with a range of raw materials and other weaponry, though actual deliveries would fall short of these figures. The British had already dispatched two convoys to the USSR prior to the agreement; the second convoy had brought 140 tanks, 100 Hurricane fighters, and 200 universal carriers. These were the Valentine and Matilda models. The Matilda would not be too popular with the Soviets but the Valentine would become loved as a scout tank over time. The Soviets also criticized the low caliber guns on both British models and their relatively poor cross country speed. However these tanks were still capable of matching the fielded German tanks and the Soviets were in desperate need for more tanks. Overall 466 British tanks would be delivered over 1941. Additionally, Britain had begun sharing information from ULTRA intercepts with the Soviet Union. Ultra was the British codename for the signal interception and decryption work done at Bletchley Park However, suspicions in Moscow that the British were willing to fight to the last drop of Soviet blood had begun to surface. This situation had been fueled by the apparent reluctance of the British to actively engage the Germans on the ground in Europe or to send troops into the USSR, while they were nonetheless willing to replace Soviet garrisons in occupied Iran. The fact that sending aid to the USSR was severely hindering British rearmament after their own disasters in 1940 and 1941 was overlooked.Accusations of such strained the British-Soviet relationship, recalling Soviet support for Nazi Germany against the United Kingdom months earlier. While these tensions and other factors placed strain on the alliance, they were not sufficient to fracture it, as both sides recognized their mutual need.
The USSR held a distinctly stronger industrial position than the Germans. For example, the Soviet Union produced over 500 tanks in October, compared with the German output of 387 tanks. The vast majority of Soviet tank production had already shifted to the KV-1, T-34, and T-60 models, and in the last quarter of 1941 alone these three lines accounted for a surge of output: 441 KV-1s, 765 T-34s, and 1,388 T-60s. This shift occurred despite the upheaval caused by evacuating a significant portion of Soviet industry beyond the Urals.
German production priorities had already shifted away from the Army, and it would take months or even years to reverse that shift. Worse for Germany, there was growing concern about the onset of hyperinflation once more. Additionally, crude oil shipments from Romania declined from 375,000 tonnes to 253,000 tonnes during October. This drop mattered greatly because the naval and air war against the Western Allies was consuming substantial amounts of fuel oil and aviation gasoline. The USSR was primarily engaged in a land and air war against the European Axis and, in theory, could dedicate all of its war production to this single conflict. Germany, by contrast, found itself fighting on multiple fronts: a land war against the USSR and, to some extent, the Commonwealth in Africa, while also waging an air and naval war against the Commonwealth and contending with broader resource and industrial pressures. This meant Germany faced intensified demands on its industrial base to sustain operations across Europe, North Africa, and the Atlantic, whereas the USSR could, in principle, concentrate its industrial mobilization on the European Axis front. The result was different production and logistics dynamics for each side, with the USSR able to channel more of its output toward armored, infantry, and airpower suitable for the Eastern Front, while Germany had to balance expansion, occupation administration, and long supply lines across multiple theaters. The Germans increasingly desired the Caucasus oil fields to offset their limited access to oil. This economic strain would contribute to discussions about using Soviet POWs as slave labor.
I would like to take this time to remind you all that this podcast is only made possible through the efforts of Kings and Generals over at Youtube. Please go subscribe to Kings and Generals over at Youtube and to continue helping us produce this content please check out www.patreon.com/kingsandgenerals. If you are still hungry after that, give my personal channel a look over at The Pacific War Channel at Youtube, it would mean a lot to me.
The October 1941 front near Moscow lay in mud and attrition as Germans pressed toward Tikhvin and Moscow while Soviets patched defenses. The German advance, hampered by flooding, fuel shortages, and relentless Soviet counterattacks, stretched logistics and slowed progress; Beowulf operations in the Baltic fizzled under Soviet resistance. By month’s end, German forces faced supply crises, fuel shortages, and mounting casualties, prompting partial redeployments and even discussions of slowing or halting offensives.