
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


Welcome to another dive into Indiana SEA No. 1. In this episode, we will explore section 5 and 6, which outlines the new requirements for teacher licensure in Indiana. I want to make it clear from the beginning I am not against professional development that helps equip teachers with knowledge to improve their instruction and improves the quality of education students receive. I do, however, do not agree with the way state legislators have mandated this professional development. With that being said, let’s dig into section 5.
Section 5 starts out with a mandate that is not new. I believe this was part of House Bill 1558. It states that:
No later than July 1, 2024, the state board shall establish and require a literacy endorsement for individuals first licensed after June 30, 2025, to teach a content area involving literacy instruction, including special education, in pre-kindergarten through grade 5.
Anyone enrolled in college, working on their bachelor's in elementary education, is required to get their literacy endorsement before they can receive their teaching license. Colleges are supposed to have added training in this area that is aligned with the science of reading to their coursework. Students then must pass the praxis exam before applying for their first teaching license.
This requirement better equips new teachers with the knowledge and skills they need to teach literacy. I do not have any issues with this. My opinion is, this training is one of a few courses taught in college that will prepare a student for their teaching career.
The next requirement under section 5. Part b states that:
Except as provided in section 19.8(a) of this chapter, beginning July 1, 2027, the department may not renew a practitioner license or an accomplished practitioner license, or a comparable license under prior rules, issued to an individual who:
Based on the content area for which the individual is licensed, including special education, provides literacy instruction to students in pre-kindergarten through grade 5 unless the individual receives a literacy endorsement under this section.
Let’s pause and recap here. Anyone who holds an Indiana teacher's license for pre-K-5th grade, must obtain a literacy endorsement by July 1, 2027, in order to renew their teaching license. Without a literacy endorsement, you cannot renew your teaching license. The intent is to equip all teachers with the knowledge and skills to effectively teach literacy skills, however, this is not how to go about it.
Frist of all, the state put out a free course in December for educators to equip them with Science of Reading training. Anyone who completes the course, housed in the INLeanring Lab by May 31st, can apply for a $1,200 stipend. The course is worth 25 PGP (professional growth points). To renew your license, a teacher must accumulate 90 PGPs over the course of five years.
Most teachers are going to jump on this opportunity because they not only get several PGPs, but they will be paid for it. Just so everyone is aware, most PGPs teachers earn to keep their license are not free, and they do not get paid for it. The school pays for it, or the teacher pays for it out of pocket. The fact that the state incentivized this professional development already had many current teachers taking part in it.
With this requirement the state has certain requirements for obtaining your literacy endorsement. Part c states:
To be eligible to receive a literacy endorsement, an individual must meet the following:
Complete 80 hours of evidence based professional development that is:
Aligned to the science of reading and
Approved by the department.
Demonstrate proficiency in scientifically based reading instruction skills aligned to the science of reading on a written examination or through other procedures prescribed by the department in accordance with this section.
Parts D-H cover the details of what the professional development and examination should include. There are several things to cover in this section. First, let’s talk about the 80 hours of professional development. That is, two-thirds of the credit hours needed to obtain your bachelor’s degree in education. What is being demanded is that teachers who have already completed their bachelor’s and some even their master’s degrees in education now have to maintain a full-time teaching position while at the same time being a full-time college student again. These same individuals have husbands, wives, and children of their own to take care of. And we expect to get high quality instruction from individuals who are being stretched to the max?
Second, we have educators who have been teaching 15 years or more. Their experience far outweighs what they will gain from this state mandated professional development. Many will toss in the towel because it isn’t worth the stress, especially when they are only a few years away from retirement. We have a teacher shortage. An unintended outcome of this legislation is that more teachers leave the field with no one waiting to take their place.
Third, this does not just affect the teachers who teach in grades pre-kindergarten through 5. It is anyone, including gym, music, art teachers and administrators, who want to maintain their teaching license in case they choose or have to go back into the general education classroom.
Section 6 does provide for a waiver. Let’s look at what it says.
An individual described in section 19.7(b) (that’s teachers) who cannot comply with the requirements of section 19.7 of this chapter may apply for a waiver fromm the department in a form and manner prescribed by the department.
(b) If the department determines that an individual cannot comply with the requirements of section 19.7 of this chapter, the department may grant the individual a waiver that provides an exception to the requirements.
(c) The department may grant a waiver under this section to an individual that:
Is not more than one year and
Does not extend beyond July 1, 2028
However, the department may extend the waiver described in this subsection if the department determines a hardship exists for the individual in meeting the requirements under section 19.7 of this chapter.
Part D under section 6 covers the process of applying for a waiver. I will not read that to you, but it reads as if there must be a major roadblock for the waiver to be approved. Which means, you must complete the training to maintain your teaching license.
Teachers many of you received an email from the DOE on March 20, 2024, about the opportunity to earn your literacy endorsement for free. Let’s look at the verbiage in this email, as I found it to be misleading.
Indiana Provides Educators A Free Opportunity to Earn a Literacy Endorsement
INDIANAPOLIS –The Indiana Department of Education today announced that eligible educators can now enroll in a free professional development course designed to help them earn Indiana’s Literacy Endorsement. Eligible educators will receive up to $1,200 in stipends for completion of the course.
“For the first time ever, Indiana educators can add a literacy endorsement to their existing license, and the state has provided a way for educators to earn this distinction free of charge while also earning a stipend for their time spent completing the course,” said Dr. Katie Jenner, Indiana Secretary of Education. “The literacy endorsement, created by state law in 2023, provides educators with tools focused on evidence-based instruction rooted in science of reading, ensuring more students across the state gain essential literacy skills necessary for future success.”
This course, tailored specifically for Indiana educators, is certified by the International Dyslexia Association and is aligned to Indiana Academic Standards and science of reading. By participating, educators will continue to improve upon existing knowledge allowing for enhanced instructional practices in the fundamental elements of early reading and writing.
Indiana educators who hold an active Pre-K through grade six or special education license are invited to enroll in the newly-developed course, offered by Keys to Literacy. The free course will be available through June 2025. The program’s instructional practices are designed to seamlessly integrate into classroom lessons with any curriculum or published literacy program.
Funding is allocated in the state’s biennial budget to allow educators to enroll in the 80-hour course, participate in the Praxis licensing exam, and, ultimately, earn the Indiana Literacy Endorsement. Following completion of the exam, beginning in August 2024, educators can apply to add the literacy endorsement to their license. Additional information will be available this spring for educators who have completed the necessary 80-hour professional development on science of reading through a different provider.
To support schools and educators, as well as parents and families in preparing students with foundational reading skills, Indiana continues to make historic investments in literacy, totaling over $170 million. Below are examples of how this investment continues to positively impact students –
· Launched a new data visualization tool with key literacy data to empower educators, parents and families, community leaders and policymakers with the information needed to continue improving state and local literacy rates.
· Increased school-level science of reading instructional coaching and support for educators through the Indiana Literacy Cadre. Participation in 2023 grew nearly five-fold, with 199 total schools opting into cohorts one and two.
· Provided over 105,000 hours of learning support and tutoring services to over 20,000 students through Indiana Learns, regardless of a family’s ability to pay.
· Grew the Indiana Learning Lab from 6,000 users in 2021 to over 62,000 users just two years later, including launching the Parent and Family Support Hub, which provides no cost, 24/7 access to resources for parents and families to support their student’s learning.
· Developed online professional development modules supporting Indiana educators with additional science of reading training. Nearly 6,000 educators have signed up to participate, with 1,200 already completed. Eligible teachers receive a $1,200 stipend upon completion.
· Expanded the number of schools opting-in to administer the state’s IREAD assessment for second grade students to 1,099 schools. This allows teachers, parents and families to immediately know if a child is on-track or at-risk when it comes to mastering foundational literacy skills.
· Awarded the Expanding What Works grant to four regional partners serving over 3,000 students to increase access to high-quality summer programming providing supplemental literacy and math instruction using evidence-based strategies.
· Provided $10 million in cash stipends to teachers, instructional coaches and other school staff at all corporations and charter schools who are responsible for the implementation and delivery of early literacy and reading instruction through the Literacy Achievement Grants.
· Increased the implementation of evidence-based instructional practices for over 65,000 students across Indiana through the Competitive Science of Reading grant, which awarded nearly $15 million to 72 school corporations. This is in addition to the multiple other initiatives supporting science of reading.
To learn more about additional literacy supports available to Indiana schools, click here.
###
About Keys to Literacy
Keys to Literacy (KTL) is a leader in providing research-based professional development aligned with a Structured Literacy approach to teach all reading and writing components. KTL has delivered similar training to thousands of teachers across the country.
MEDIA CONTACT:
Molly Williams
Indiana Department of Education
[email protected]
(317) 234-3880
Nowhere in this email does it mention SEA No. 1 and the new literacy endorsement requirements. They use words like opportunity, can, are invited as if it is an option. Why are they not being straightforward?
Why is Keys to Literacy the only approved program now, when we had a list of several vendors for this training? What happened to LETRS, Orton-Gillingham and the others? I have to say this is suspicious to me, that we went down to one vendor. We should be questioning this.
It should also be noted on the Keys to Literacy website under the fine print they state that this training is only free from April 2024- June 2025. So, if teachers want to keep their teaching license and not pay for the required training and exam, they must complete it by June 2025.
Here are my final thoughts. If the state wants to provide professional development on the science of reading, great. Just don’t threaten to take away our teaching license if we don’t complete it. Many educators have already completed the first round of training and their reluctant colleagues are not far behind once they see the value in it.
Teachers, if you want to put an end to this, you are going to have to contact your state legislators. I have put a link in this blog post so you can easily find your representatives and email them. If I were in your shoes, I would also ask your state union reps if they knew about this bill before it passed. I have a feeling most of you were unaware of this bill and what it contained.
We all want quality education for our students, so let’s come together and get it done with educational awareness. You can visit www.educationalawareness.org for more information.
This first episode of the Indiana Senate Enrolled Act 1 series will cover Section 17. A section that is important for parents, teachers, and administrators to understand. It addresses the new requirement that second-grade students take the IREAD assessment, the retention of third-grade students who do not pass the IREAD assessment, and the assessment results required from schools.
Senate Enrolled Ace No. 1 was passed by the house on March 7, 2024, passed by the Senate on March 8, 2024, and signed by the governor on March 11, 2024. You can access the entire bill by clicking on the link provided in this blog post, along with the voting records from both the House and Senate.
Let’s start at the beginning of Section 17. Subsection A states that beginning in the 2024-2025 school year, any third-grade student who has not achieved a passing score on IREAD after the summer administration will be retained unless they meet one of the following exceptions: (These can be found in sub-section c.)
· They have already been retained in third grade.
· The student has an Individualized Education Plan (IEP) that specifies that retention is not appropriate, and the case conference committee has determined that promotion to another grade is appropriate.
o The case conference committee comprises parents, teachers, and administrators. This committee has always had the ability to give a student with an IEP a Good Cause Exemption (GCE). This exempts the student with an IEP from having to retake the IREAD assessment and from facing penalties for not passing it.
o It is my professional opinion that making a student with a learning disability, especially in reading, re-take IREAD has no benefit for the student or educating staff.
· The student is an English language learner who has received services for fewer than two years and a committee consisting of: parents, administrators, and educators determine that promotion is appropriate based on the instructional practices outlined in the student’s Individual Learning Plan (ILP).
o This is a Good Cause Exemption (GCE) provided to a student whose first language is not English and is receiving additional instruction in acquiring English under an Individual Learning Plan (ILP).
o I would like to point out that research shows it takes 7 years for a student to become fluent in English. This legislation requires English learners to be retained after only 2 years of English instruction if they do not pass IREAD.
· The student received a score of proficient or above proficient in grade 3 math on the statewide summative assessment, ILEARN.
o You might think this is bizarre. Why would passing a math test exempt you from the requirements of passing a reading test? I believe this exemption is based on the thinking that if the student is performing at grade level in one of the core academic areas, they should not be held back.
o This highlights the absurdity of retaining a student based on one test score. No educational professional determines to retain a student based off one test score. We take multiple data points into consideration, along with our knowledge of the student and how retention will affect them.
· The student:
o Has received intensive intervention as determined by the department in reading for two or more years, and
o Was retained more than one time throughout kindergarten, grade 1, or grade 2.
I am going to pause and take a moment to give my thoughts on this section as an educator. I would also like to point you the data that informs my decision. So, let’s start there. Visible Learning is a collection of years' worth of educational research that ranks the effectiveness of instructional strategies. You can find two articles covering these ratings with the links in this blog post.
https://visible-learning.org/2022/01/hatties-barometer-of-influence-infographic/
https://visible-learning.org/hattie-ranking-influences-effect-sizes-learning-achievement/
Below is an image that shows the rating scale and where a few of the instructional practices rank. We want to use instructional practices in the blue or Zone of Desired Effects, as these have the highest positive impact on student learning.
As you can see, the red section lists retention under Reverse Effects. Meaning retention has a negative impact on student learning. In my years of experience, I have found that retention can have a positive impact when done in kindergarten or first grade; beyond that, the negatives outweigh the positives.
If research shows that retention has a reverse effect on student learning, why are we putting legislation in that requires schools to retain students in third grade? Furthermore, why are making a retention decision based on one test score? I would also ask, who knows what’s best for a student’s educational needs, their parents and teachers or legislators?
I do want to point out that Section 18 allows for a parent of a student who has been retained in grade 3 to the right to appeal the student’s retention if the parent believes the student meets an exception under section 2(c). Section 2 (c) refers to the exemption given to a student who has an intellectual disability or IEP (Individual Education Plan).
If I am reading this correctly, a parent still does not have much say or power to keep their child from being retained if they do not qualify for a GCE (Good Cause Exemption). As an educator and administrator, I have always said the parent has the last say whether it is in agreement with what I or the committee feels is best for the student’s educational success or not. This legislation removes the parents' right and ability to overturn the retention along with tying the hands of educators who do not think retention will benefit a student.
Section 17 also requires students in second grade to take the IREAD assessment. In addition, students must continue to take the IREAD assessment until:
· They receive a passing score regardless of the student’s grade level, or
· they are in 7th grade.
Schools are to report the following data to parents and use this data to inform their instruction:
· Phonemic Awareness
· Phonics
· Fluency
· Vocabulary
· Comprehension
This is acceptable, however, let me show the data given to schools from the IREAD assessment versus the data from the DIBELS assessment, which assesses all 5 components of reading.
The first image is the report given for a third grader who passed IREAD.
This second image is the report given for a third grader who did not pass IREAD.
The performance levels are the same even though their scores were vastly different. The other issue is that it does not definitively state what reading skills they need to work on. It doesn’t even break the category performance down enough to tell parents and educators if their child met the benchmark or was near the benchmark. This data is not specific or actionable for creating instruction specific to a child’s reading needs.
According to SEA 1 schools are to report how students perform in each of the five components of reading: Phonemic Awareness, Phonics, Fluency, Vocabulary, and Comprehension. However, IREAD does not assess each of these components. It covers comprehension well and briefly touches on phonemic awareness and vocabulary.
Below is a statement from the DOE in response to educators who questioned the data they received from student’s IREAD results. I will say the DOE has been great in responding and providing support where they can.
IREAD-3 reporting category scores were updated in 2024 to reflect performance levels rather than percent correct. Overall proficiency scores for IREAD-3 have not changed. The updated reporting structure considers the number of items a student answers correctly and the item characteristics (the knowledge and skills required by the item). The score report is generated using information from the student assessment that can confirm if the student is At/Near, Below, or Above the required content for each domain. The cut scores used to calculate and determine the reporting category groupings are aligned to the cut scores on the assessment.
Grade 3 has only two overall performance levels: “Pass” and “Did Not Pass.” These are operationalized into three groupings on the reporting categories: Below, At/Near, and Above where At/Near and Above levels correspond more closely to the “Pass” category. Grade 2 has three overall performance levels: “At Risk”, “On Track”, and “Pass” where “On Track” reflects expected student ability at grade 2 and “Pass” reflects the achievement expected at grade 3.
Due to the small number and foundational nature of items in the Reading: Foundations and Vocabulary segment of IREAD-3, most students will fall into either Below or At/Near proficiency for this domain at grade 3. The item characteristics are foundational and therefore do not lend themselves to demonstration of ability above the “Pass” requirement. Students who perform well overall will often see At/Near the standard reflected on this reporting category, and this is accurate as they have demonstrated proficiency for this foundational domain.
Below is a picture of the data that is provided through the DIBELS assessment. It provides data in each of the five reading categories and informs both teachers and parents whether their child is performing well below, below, at, or above the grade level expectation, in each category.
I will provide a deep dive into what each of these data points mean and how they can inform instruction in a later episode. For this episode, I want to point how, even just looking at the snapshot of data, both parents and educators have a better understanding of what reading skills a child needs when compared to IREAD data.
The state has for years provided funding, through the Formative Assessment Grant, for schools to purchase and use the DIBELS assessments. My question is, if we already have an assessment that is far superior to the state assessment, why are we not using it?
The act provides for the literacy intervention of all students who do not pass IREAD. This is a great way to ensure no child falls through the cracks. I believe that any competent school or educator is already engaging in this activity, as evaluating students' comprehension, and adapting instruction is a regular task for teachers.
My Suggestions:
1. Use an assessment like DIBELS that gives both parents and educators more actionable data for instruction and intervention.
2. Remove the requirement of second graders taking a third grade reading assessment, as an assessment like DIBELS is far more informative and less intensive.
3. Remove the retention requirement because our children are not one test score. It should be the educators and parents who look at all aspects of the child and multiple data points that determine whether retention is the best course of action.
4. Provide funding for meeting the educational needs of students through interventions.
5. The perfect plan would be to remove IREAD and use DIBELS in grades K-8.
This is my break down of section 15 of SEA No. 1 accompanied with my opinions from an educator’s viewpoint. There are links to the actual document so you can read through the act and reach out to your state representatives with your concerns. Nothing will change unless we make law makers aware of what really needs to happen in our schools.
I highly encourage parents, educators, and administrators to reach out to your state representatives and ask why they voted for it and share your thoughts. We hold 50% of the blame for this passing because we have not been active participants. Our representatives hold the other 50% for not actively engaging their constituents in the bills being presented. I am sure that if the people who voted for them to represent them had been aware of this bill before it passed, they would have instructed them to vote no.
You can use the link in this blog post to find your representatives and contact them. I believe this bill had good intentions, but without input from educators and parents, it is fundamentally flawed. Let’s come to the table and create a plan together that leads to a better education and future for our children.
Blog & Social Media Items
Fiscal Impact Summary: https://iga.in.gov/pdf-documents/123/2024/senate/bills/SB0001/fiscal-notes/SB0001.08.ENRH.FN001.pdf
House Votes: https://iga.in.gov/pdf-documents/123/2024/senate/bills/SB0001/rollcalls/SB0001.208_H.pdf
Senate Votes: https://iga.in.gov/pdf-documents/123/2024/senate/bills/SB0001/rollcalls/SB0001.81_S.pdf
SEA No. 1: https://iga.in.gov/pdf-documents/123/2024/senate/bills/SB0001/SB0001.08.ENRH.pdf
SEA No. 1 Webpage: https://iga.in.gov/legislative/2024/bills/senate/1/details
From the publisher's feed
The Educational Awareness podcast brings you the information you need to know, to advocate for quality education. Be aware of educational laws in Indiana and how they affect students and teachers.…