Every leader has the potential to be a wolf, a sheep, or a shepherd. The question isn’t whether you lead this way, but which role you choose most often. This timeless framework, rooted in Scripture, has shaped my own leadership journey and offers profound insight for how we influence others, and the legacy we leave behind.
In the corporate corridors where I've spent over two decades building teams and driving transformation, I've observed a timeless truth: leadership isn't just about what you accomplish, it's about who you become in the process and how that shapes everyone around you. Recently, while reflecting on the leaders who've most influenced my career, I found myself drawn to an ancient yet remarkably relevant framework found throughout Scripture: the dynamic between the wolf, the sheep, and the shepherd.
This biblical model offers profound insights for modern executives about the ripple effects of our leadership choices. Every day, whether we realize it or not, we choose which of these three archetypes to embody, and that choice reverberates through our organizations in ways both seen and unseen.
The Wolf: Leadership Through Fear and Self-Interest
Jesus spoke of wolves in sheep's clothing (Matthew 7:15), and Paul warned the Ephesian elders about "fierce wolves" who would come among the flock "not sparing the sheep" (Acts 20:29). In the corporate context, wolf-like leadership manifests as leading through intimidation, prioritizing personal gain over collective success, and viewing team members as expendable resources rather than valuable individuals.
I've witnessed wolf-style leaders in action: the CEO who publicly humiliates underperforming executives, the manager who takes credit for team successes while deflecting blame for failures, the director who hoards information to maintain power. These leaders often achieve short-term results through fear-based motivation, but the long-term cost is devastating.
The Wolf's Impact on Others:
* Breeds mistrust and political maneuvering
* Stifles innovation as people become risk-averse
* Generates high turnover and low engagement
Research consistently shows that fear-based leadership environments experience 67% higher turnover rates and 32% lower productivity scores. More troubling, these toxic cultures perpetuate themselves as emerging leaders learn that aggression and self-interest are the paths to advancement.
The Sheep: Leadership Through Passivity and Abdication
While the wolf represents aggressive self-interest, the sheep embodies the opposite extreme: passive leadership that fails to provide direction, make difficult decisions, or protect the team from external threats. Isaiah 53:6 reminds us that "all we like sheep have gone astray," highlighting our natural tendency toward directionless wandering without strong guidance.
Sheep-like leaders are often well-intentioned people who've been promoted beyond their comfort zone or who mistake consensus-building for leadership. They avoid conflict, defer critical decisions, and fail to establish clear vision or accountability standards.
The Sheep's Impact on Others:
* Creates confusion and lack of direction
* Enables poor performers to remain comfortable
* Frustrates high achievers who crave clear expectations
In my experience, sheep-style leadership is often more damaging than wolf-style leadership because it's harder to identify and address. Teams can rally against a clearly toxic leader, but they slowly lose energy and focus under passive leadership that provides no clear direction or protection. This is also masked by kindness or a person’s desire to want to be liked by everyone.
The Shepherd: Leadership Through Service and Strength
The biblical model of shepherd leadership appears throughout Scripture, from David's psalms to Jesus' teachings about laying down one's life for the sheep (John 10:11-15). The shepherd leads from the front, protects the vulnerable, makes sacrificial decisions for the good of the flock, and develops other shepherds to extend care and leadership.
Shepherd-style leaders combine the strength to make difficult decisions with the heart to serve others' best interests. They're willing to confront wolves when necessary while remaining gentle with those who are struggling. Most importantly, they understand that their primary role is to develop and empower others to reach their full potential.
The Shepherd's Impact on Others:
* Creates psychological safety that enables innovation and growth
* Develops a pipeline of strong leaders throughout the organization
* Attracts and retains top talent who want to learn and contribute
The Daily Choice: Which Leader Will You Be Today?
The profound truth I've learned is that leadership style isn't a fixed personality trait, it's a daily choice influenced by pressure, circumstances, and conscious intention. I've seen shepherds become wolves under extreme pressure, and I've watched sheep transform into shepherds when given proper support and development. Consider these practical applications:
In Crisis Moments: Do you protect your team from unnecessary organizational turbulence (shepherd), throw them under the bus to save yourself (wolf), or fail to provide clear direction when they need it most (sheep)?
In Success Celebrations: Do you ensure credit flows to those who did the work (shepherd), claim disproportionate recognition (wolf), or fail to celebrate achievements meaningfully (sheep)?
In Development Conversations: Do you invest time in growing others even when it doesn't directly benefit you (shepherd), see talented team members as threats to your position (wolf), or avoid difficult developmental feedback to maintain harmony (sheep)?
The Multiplication Effect: Your Leadership Legacy
Perhaps the most sobering aspect of this framework is understanding how leadership styles multiply. Wolves create more wolves. Sheep enable more sheep. But shepherds—shepherds develop other shepherds who go on to serve and develop even more leaders.
As Proverbs 27:17 reminds us, "Iron sharpens iron, and one man sharpens another." Every interaction is an opportunity to sharpen someone else's leadership capacity or to dull it through poor modeling.
A Personal Commitment
As I reflect on my own leadership journey, I'm humbled by the times I've chosen the wolf's path in moments of pressure or the sheep's path when courage was required. But I'm also encouraged by the transformative power of choosing the shepherd's way, not just for those I lead, but for my own growth and fulfillment. The question isn't whether you'll face situations that tempt you toward wolf or sheep behavior. The question is whether you'll cultivate the self-awareness, character, and skills necessary to consistently choose the shepherd's path, especially when it's difficult. Values shining when adversity is at its peak.
Your leadership legacy is written daily. Which role will you choose today?
I’d love to hear which archetype resonates most with you and how you’ve seen these patterns play out in your own career. Share your thoughts below.
#Leadership #ExecutiveLeadership #LeadershipDevelopment #BiblicalLeadership #CorporateCulture #TeamDevelopment #LeadershipImpact
This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit elevateleadership.substack.com
