War. Polio. Heat waves. What could make this worse? Sharks. In this one, Ian and Liv talk about a series of shark attacks that occurred on the beaches of New Jersey during the summer of 1916. How many sharks were involved? How would everyone react to the first string of shark attacks that was publicized by the media? Who tried blaming a turtle?

Also, Ian learns an important lesson in fact-checking. Liv knows a thing or two about films.