When a high-powered New York businesswoman, played by the omnipotent Lacey Chabert, becomes the legal guardian of her niece and nephew in North Carolina, will she leave her big city life behind to raise them? Well, if their basketball coach is the smoking hot Tyler Hynes, the answer is a slam dunk.

Mary and Charlie were a little split on the movie, but they both had questions.

• Does a toaster really blacken bread so much that it smokes?
• Does Delilah look like dirndl woman from Winter in Vail?
• Why is Charlie mansplaining bagel mode?
• How come she packs a sheet? How come?
• Why was Lacey simultaneously straightening her hair, blow-drying it, and using a Waterpik at 4 am?
• Did homeboy really need to dump a whole bag of flour on her head?
• Where did dad get his cardigans?
• Did ex-boyfriend have to be so savage?
• How awkward is it that her brother played her boyfriend in another move?

Also, weigh in on Instagram on which Juilliard grads are richer and listen to Mary's final rant about When Calls the Heart.