This week Barb left Paul a heartfelt note that had him crying for 24 hours. On the podcast, Paul decided to "Run It Back" by reading his childhood role model essay dedicated to Barb—cue Barb's turn for tears. Between the waterworks, the two explored SoCal towns, played a wild round of "Would You Ever?" (where Barb dropped her infamous underwear confession), and continued the hunt for Mr. Right… which may have led to a catfish, or a headline waiting to happen (and not in a good way).