All's fair in love and war, even if you find yourself in love with your fiancé's brother! Hey, the heart wants what it wants. And this heart... wants a hunk!

This week, Mary and Charlie are debating the ethical dilemma that is "It Was Always You," the latest Hallmark Channel movie starring Erin Krakow (aka Elizabeth Thatcher) and certified hottie, Tyler Hynes.

Notable topics include:

• What is up with this draconian oyster bar?
• Has Hallmark been listening to our podcast?
• Did Elizabeth get her travel inspo from Lizzie Maguire?
• Why is the sister trying to be a poor man's Monet?
• Who made our leading lady look like a tablecloth?
• Can we get to the bottom of ferry-gate?
• Why was this family trying to force this forbidden love?
• At what age should one have heard of the Colosseum in Rome?

Plus, hear about the new online interactions we had with Hallmark stars last week.