It's the first episode of You Scared of This ----! Join Eli Phillips and @david-dycus on their epic rewatch of Are You Afraid of the Dark.

We begin with the episode that started it all, "The Tale of the Phantom Cab." Will the guys stumble upon the dark truth about the Midnight Society? Is Dr. Vink accredited? And will Eli and David get through this first episode without screwing up the main characters' names? Tune in and find out!