The Broaddus family couldn’t have been more excited to move into their dream house at 657 Boulevard in the well-off town of Westfield, New Jersey in 2014. But as the couple was preparing to settle into the $1.3 million house with their three children, they received disturbing letters in the mail. They were signed only by “The Watcher" and had no return address. Whoever was writing these seemed to have been watching the Broadduses carefully and knowing their every move and all their names. This case did get large national attention in the media, yet is still unsolved. Listen along to hear what these letters said, who the suspects are and, of course, what our theories are!

As always, let us know what you think of this case or if you have any case suggestions on our social media accounts or by email:

Email: [email protected]

Instagram: @coldclawsandcrime

CHECK OUT OUR WEBSITE: https://coldclawpodcast.wixsite.com/my-site

See you next Wednesday!