
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


This episode of Folk Files looks at a family of songs where the main character "dies for love." In particular, I explore "The Butcher Boy," a song with American, Irish, and English versions. The versions vary drastically: they swap out characters, drop details, and change the reasoning behind the narrator's decisions. I investigate what effect these changes have on the listener and what lessons we can draw from those effects.
Host: Olivia Harding
Check out more from Pollyanna: https://open.spotify.com/artist/1Rgyvnw9WrAm20MhlS2kyp?si=irIKZtNOTFaZWDOt9mh0cA
Special thanks to: Aaron J. Morton
Support Folk Files: https://www.patreon.com/c/FolkFilesPodcast
*This episode of Folk Files was recorded on the road. Apologies for any lapses in quality.*
Musical excerpts:
ARTIST: Alisa Marie
WORK: O'Carolan's Cup
SOURCE: https://youtu.be/zrBwqFco0Xs?si=-SdsYnEWGiD5SnFO
ARTIST: Sarah Makem
WORK: The Butcher Boy
SOURCE: https://youtu.be/x_mtUaBHWCE?si=tBXVy9ELCV9dECgh
ARTIST: Derek and Hazel Sarjeant
WORK: A Sailor Coming Home on Leave
SOURCE: https://youtu.be/e91Ug-CAjAc?si=sMcd-NpQC-FQmNSL
ARTIST: Music the Gathering
WORK: Johnny Jump Up
SOURCE: https://www.musicthegathering.com/store/lvl-3-digital-album-esexe
ARTIST: Frank Profitt
WORK: Morning Fair
SOURCE: https://youtu.be/wdyO1890Zpc?si=1esdsYhrRNWTg7zD
ARTIST: Sam Lee
WORK: Over Yonders Hill
SOURCE: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v2jcdbFRRYc
ARTIST: The Kings of Calicutt
WORK: Sheffield Park
SOURCE: https://youtu.be/o1lDKhJd6Pw?si=XWyn9hQQ3ImN2PRq
ARTIST: Bellowhead
WORK: Cold Blows the Wind
SOURCE: https://youtu.be/WvuxL8UQiLQ?si=Sdr7Zz7yUVEXi7zg
ARTIST: Jean Ritchie
WORK: Go Dig My Grave
SOURCE: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kGrcOqcbzYk
ARTIST: The Clancy Brothers
WORK: The Butcher Boy
SOURCE: https://youtu.be/WMc8QSxZe_M?si=PIv8GZyRL_1vkSRD
ARTIST: Buell Kazee
WORK: Butcher's Boy
SOURCE: https://youtu.be/lwSJoMNRGuI?si=fehdH-zflcTkTbY2
ARTIST: Pollyanna
WORK: Railroad Boy
SOURCE: https://pollyanna.bandcamp.com/album/man-time-deluxe-edition
By Olivia Harding4.8
2121 ratings
This episode of Folk Files looks at a family of songs where the main character "dies for love." In particular, I explore "The Butcher Boy," a song with American, Irish, and English versions. The versions vary drastically: they swap out characters, drop details, and change the reasoning behind the narrator's decisions. I investigate what effect these changes have on the listener and what lessons we can draw from those effects.
Host: Olivia Harding
Check out more from Pollyanna: https://open.spotify.com/artist/1Rgyvnw9WrAm20MhlS2kyp?si=irIKZtNOTFaZWDOt9mh0cA
Special thanks to: Aaron J. Morton
Support Folk Files: https://www.patreon.com/c/FolkFilesPodcast
*This episode of Folk Files was recorded on the road. Apologies for any lapses in quality.*
Musical excerpts:
ARTIST: Alisa Marie
WORK: O'Carolan's Cup
SOURCE: https://youtu.be/zrBwqFco0Xs?si=-SdsYnEWGiD5SnFO
ARTIST: Sarah Makem
WORK: The Butcher Boy
SOURCE: https://youtu.be/x_mtUaBHWCE?si=tBXVy9ELCV9dECgh
ARTIST: Derek and Hazel Sarjeant
WORK: A Sailor Coming Home on Leave
SOURCE: https://youtu.be/e91Ug-CAjAc?si=sMcd-NpQC-FQmNSL
ARTIST: Music the Gathering
WORK: Johnny Jump Up
SOURCE: https://www.musicthegathering.com/store/lvl-3-digital-album-esexe
ARTIST: Frank Profitt
WORK: Morning Fair
SOURCE: https://youtu.be/wdyO1890Zpc?si=1esdsYhrRNWTg7zD
ARTIST: Sam Lee
WORK: Over Yonders Hill
SOURCE: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v2jcdbFRRYc
ARTIST: The Kings of Calicutt
WORK: Sheffield Park
SOURCE: https://youtu.be/o1lDKhJd6Pw?si=XWyn9hQQ3ImN2PRq
ARTIST: Bellowhead
WORK: Cold Blows the Wind
SOURCE: https://youtu.be/WvuxL8UQiLQ?si=Sdr7Zz7yUVEXi7zg
ARTIST: Jean Ritchie
WORK: Go Dig My Grave
SOURCE: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kGrcOqcbzYk
ARTIST: The Clancy Brothers
WORK: The Butcher Boy
SOURCE: https://youtu.be/WMc8QSxZe_M?si=PIv8GZyRL_1vkSRD
ARTIST: Buell Kazee
WORK: Butcher's Boy
SOURCE: https://youtu.be/lwSJoMNRGuI?si=fehdH-zflcTkTbY2
ARTIST: Pollyanna
WORK: Railroad Boy
SOURCE: https://pollyanna.bandcamp.com/album/man-time-deluxe-edition

90,841 Listeners

38,837 Listeners

25,872 Listeners

7,625 Listeners

14,641 Listeners

874 Listeners

87,395 Listeners

112,664 Listeners

56,879 Listeners

8,404 Listeners

66 Listeners

3,221 Listeners

4,856 Listeners

15,632 Listeners

9,412 Listeners