In 1992 the home of Claude Garrett and Lorie Lee Lance started to burn in their sleep.  Claude ran out of the house no problem.  However, Lorie got stuck in a spare room and died of smoke inhalation.

Did he lock her in there and set the home ablaze with kerosene?  Did she get turned around, become disoriented and get stuck in the spare room?

Sam and Jeff get a little heated in their debate over this one.  

They end with a few current events and a surprising connection to the Bill Cosby case.