Soft Skills Engineering

Episode 512: Can non-engineers really contribute code with AI and not sharing


Listen Later

In this episode, Dave and Jamison answer these questions:

  1. Should I declare my struggle with this AI world we live in here? Nah. I mean, I’d like the hype to die down, a lot, but we keep getting new tools and I get to experiment, so here we are.

    My real struggle, and this podcast is implicated in it, is around non-technical people contributing to production systems. Why are we so obsessed with this idea?

    COBOL tried it. Low-code and no-code tried it. BDD and Gherkin aspire to it. Yet time and again the field demonstrates that you need people who know their stuff.

    To “democratize” software engineering implies that all people have the desire and ability to become software engineers. That premise is false. You democratize access to education or financial systems, the stock market say. You don’t democratize skill. Skills are earned. We would never, I hope, democratize bridge engineering or piloting an aircraft. Software engineers are just as critical as either. When our software breaks, money goes missing, electrical grids fail, information stops flowing.

    What I do think is great: now more than ever, as long as tokens stay cheap, people have more ability to build useful tools for themselves. But here is how I think about it. We have done tremendous work on literacy, and most people can read, but not everyone is an author. The same applies to code.

  2. anon e mouse asks,

    Should I share my tools?

    I keep building small local software tools to better test and debug the application I’m working on. The problem is that whenever I go “above and beyond” the assigned and expected work and try and responsible check it into version control and share it with the rest of the team, it gets bogged down in code reviews because it doesn’t meet the team lead’s vision because it wasn’t part of the vision! Once I go through that process though, it’s mostly appreciated, but the team lead is under a lot of business pressure and often mentions that we need to focus.

    Maybe I’m not focused enough, but many of these little tools are things that making verification and delivery much smoother! Like local testing utilities to verify and sample api endpoints that otherwise could only be called after prod deployments due to a lack of test data. Our partners like when we’re able to show the output before deployment, and the rest of the team usually struggles with that.

    I feel a pressure to hide my tools, but then I feel sloppy for having a bunch of useful tools outside of version control. These are things like formatting output, running experiments, testing data for variations. Am I unfocused or just bad at articulating the value of these tools?

    ...more
    View all episodesView all episodes
    Download on the App Store

    Soft Skills EngineeringBy Jamison Dance and Dave Smith

    • 4.8
    • 4.8
    • 4.8
    • 4.8
    • 4.8

    4.8

    284 ratings


    More shows like Soft Skills Engineering

    View all
    Software Engineering Radio - the podcast for professional software developers by team@se-radio.net (SE-Radio Team)

    Software Engineering Radio - the podcast for professional software developers

    273 Listeners

    Hanselminutes with Scott Hanselman by Scott Hanselman

    Hanselminutes with Scott Hanselman

    382 Listeners

    The Changelog: Software Development, Open Source by Changelog Media

    The Changelog: Software Development, Open Source

    288 Listeners

    Software Engineering Daily by Software Engineering Daily

    Software Engineering Daily

    626 Listeners

    Talk Python To Me by Michael Kennedy

    Talk Python To Me

    583 Listeners

    Thoughtworks Technology Podcast by Thoughtworks

    Thoughtworks Technology Podcast

    44 Listeners

    Syntax - Tasty Web Development Treats by Wes Bos & Scott Tolinski - Full Stack JavaScript Web Developers

    Syntax - Tasty Web Development Treats

    985 Listeners

    REWORK by 37signals

    REWORK

    212 Listeners

    CoRecursive: Coding Stories by Adam Gordon Bell - Software Developer

    CoRecursive: Coding Stories

    189 Listeners

    Practical AI by Practical AI LLC

    Practical AI

    212 Listeners

    AWS Podcast by Amazon Web Services

    AWS Podcast

    204 Listeners

    .NET Rocks! by Carl Franklin and Richard Campbell

    .NET Rocks!

    242 Listeners

    The Stack Overflow Podcast by The Stack Overflow Podcast

    The Stack Overflow Podcast

    63 Listeners

    The Real Python Podcast by Real Python

    The Real Python Podcast

    140 Listeners

    Oxide and Friends by Oxide Computer Company

    Oxide and Friends

    67 Listeners