From the early 2000s to today, the Edmonton Oilers have had their share of players under the microscope. But who faced the most criticism from fans and media: Jesse Puljujärvi or Shawn Horcoff?

We dive into both eras — Horcoff wearing the "C" during tough years, and Puljujärvi's up-and-down tenure as a former 4th overall pick — to figure out who really took more heat in Edmonton.

2 Guys & a Goalie is presented by GS Construction!