Sign up to save your podcasts
Or
Share EPISODE 73: Billy Milligan
Share to email
Share to Facebook
Share to X
Share to email
Share to Facebook
Share to X
Or
EPISODE 73: Billy Milligan
One man gets arrested for violent crimes near Ohio State University. Then he says something that sounds impossible: “It wasn’t me.” Not an alibi, not a lie detector story. He claims it was one of his alternate identities, part of a system of 24 personalities living in the same body. That’s the rabbit hole we go down with our guests as Lindsay walks us through the Billy Milligan case, the “campus rapist” headline, and the DID defense that made US legal history.
We trace the timeline the way a forensic psychiatrist would: early instability, a father’s suicide, a strict and violent home, and years of alleged sexual abuse that the story links to dissociation, missing time, and identities formed to survive what a child couldn’t endure. We talk through the alters listeners always ask about: Arthur the British gentleman, Reagan the Yugoslav “protector,” Danny the terrified 14-year-old, and the identities tied to the 1977 kidnappings, robberies, and rapes. Along the way, we dig into the details that make this case so polarizing, including distinct skills, accents, medical knowledge, and even different art styles attributed to different parts.
Then we get to the courtroom consequences: psychological evaluations, the identification of multiple alters, and the first acquittal in US history based specifically on dissociative identity disorder rather than a general insanity ruling. We also say the quiet part out loud, because victims and listeners deserve it: even if DID is real, harm is still harm, and release still raises serious public safety questions. If you want to go deeper, we point you to Daniel Keyes’ The Minds of Billy Milligan and the documentary coverage that keeps this debate alive.
Subscribe for more true crime with context, share this with someone who loves psychology-heavy cases, and leave a review so the show can grow. Where do you land on DID and criminal responsibility?
CHECK OUT THE BAND AND LINKS!!!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aTeqh18FV9w
LET US KNOW WHAT YOU THINK!!!
Ready to explore more shocking true crime cases with us? Subscribe to Drink About Something for new episodes every Friday, and visit drinkaboutsomething.site with links to see all our content, including visual evidence from the cases we cover.
AS ALWAYS D-A-S
View all episodes
By Jendsey
5
44 ratings
One man gets arrested for violent crimes near Ohio State University. Then he says something that sounds impossible: “It wasn’t me.” Not an alibi, not a lie detector story. He claims it was one of his alternate identities, part of a system of 24 personalities living in the same body. That’s the rabbit hole we go down with our guests as Lindsay walks us through the Billy Milligan case, the “campus rapist” headline, and the DID defense that made US legal history.
We trace the timeline the way a forensic psychiatrist would: early instability, a father’s suicide, a strict and violent home, and years of alleged sexual abuse that the story links to dissociation, missing time, and identities formed to survive what a child couldn’t endure. We talk through the alters listeners always ask about: Arthur the British gentleman, Reagan the Yugoslav “protector,” Danny the terrified 14-year-old, and the identities tied to the 1977 kidnappings, robberies, and rapes. Along the way, we dig into the details that make this case so polarizing, including distinct skills, accents, medical knowledge, and even different art styles attributed to different parts.
Then we get to the courtroom consequences: psychological evaluations, the identification of multiple alters, and the first acquittal in US history based specifically on dissociative identity disorder rather than a general insanity ruling. We also say the quiet part out loud, because victims and listeners deserve it: even if DID is real, harm is still harm, and release still raises serious public safety questions. If you want to go deeper, we point you to Daniel Keyes’ The Minds of Billy Milligan and the documentary coverage that keeps this debate alive.
Subscribe for more true crime with context, share this with someone who loves psychology-heavy cases, and leave a review so the show can grow. Where do you land on DID and criminal responsibility?
CHECK OUT THE BAND AND LINKS!!!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aTeqh18FV9w
LET US KNOW WHAT YOU THINK!!!
Ready to explore more shocking true crime cases with us? Subscribe to Drink About Something for new episodes every Friday, and visit drinkaboutsomething.site with links to see all our content, including visual evidence from the cases we cover.
AS ALWAYS D-A-S