This week’s case is new for the hosts of Deadly Ever After !

Stacey Castor’s domestic troubles were well-known to neighbors and authorities in the small town of Weedsport in upstate New York.

In 1999, she garnered sympathy after being widowed by her husband Michael Wallace. In the aftermath of his suicide, she was left to raise two young children on her own. When Stacey remarried in 2003 to a man named David Castor, her friends, family and children were delighted at the thought that she’d found love again.

Tragically, death and misfortune would continue to plague the Castor family. Police struggled to nail down what was really happening behind closed doors in Weedsport and, little did they know, they’d soon be racing against the clock to prevent another murder from occurring…

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.