Deadly Ever After

Miriam Illes was a beloved wife, mother and Sunday School teacher living in the small hamlet of Williamsport, Pennsylvania. She had moved there to support her husband Richard, a local successful heart surgeon but the couple had recently divorced.

Then one evening, in 1999, tragedy struck and ruined life for the Illes family. It would take police across the country on a multi-year journey to solve this case.

Listen in as Harry and Elizabeth navigate this mind-boggling mystery in season two episode four of Deadly Ever After.

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

On April 9th 2001, an explosion rocked the community of Scottsdale, Arizona. A house at the end of a cul-de-sac had blown up in the very early morning hours. Police and firefighters arrived at the scene to find three bodies… but a fourth would never be discovered.

Join Elizabeth and Harry as they discuss an unbelievable tale of control, murder and manhunts on season two episode three of Deadly Ever After.

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

On the second episode of season two of Deadly Ever After, Elizabeth and Harry cover the unimaginable horrors that befell the Neulanders.

Fred and Carol Neulander were a happily married couple who had found great success in the town of Cherry Hill, New Jersey. Carol was an extremely successful businesswoman who ran a chain of kosher bakeries for the local Jewish community, while Fred founded a beloved congregation that grew larger with each passing year.

Sadly, there were secrets brewing underneath this peaceful domicile and subsequent events changed life in Cherry Hill, New Jersey forever.

Listen now to the latest episode of Deadly Ever After!

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

The final episode of Deadly Ever After season one follows a notorious case out of Australia, featuring the first woman in the country’s history issued a life sentence without the possibility of parole.

Katherine Knight grew up in a world of emotional volatility and physical violence. It’s no wonder that she recreated an equally-unstable environment for herself, her husband and her children. As her mental illness and chronic alcoholism worsened over the years, Katherine Knight finally snapped and committed one of the most heinous crimes in Australian history.

Join Harry as he walks Elizabeth through this extremely disturbing case.

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

This week’s episode was covered extensively on every major news outlet when it first made headlines in 2008.

Jodi Arias’ life changed drastically on the day she met 29 year old motivational speaker and successful salesman Travis Alexander. Jodi and Travis enjoyed an immediate, magnetic connection that quickly morphed into a passionate, tumultuous relationship.

Drama would ensnare them both for the next two years until this attraction finally turned fatal.

Join Harry and Elizabeth as they comb through Jodi Arias’ early life and childhood, looking for any reasonable explanation for the tragic events that occurred on June 4th, 2008.

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

The penultimate episode of the season covers a case that is almost too strange to be real.

The dismembered body parts of family man Bill McGuire are found floating in Chesapeake Bay, three hundred miles from his home in New Jersey. The police question his wife, fertility nurse Melanie McGuire who spins a tale of domestic abuse, gambling addiction and alcoholism. Detectives are forced to reconcile the conflicting accounts of Bill’s wife with those of his friends and colleagues.

Did this nurse violate her oath to Do No Harm?

Find out as Elizabeth & Harry detail exactly what happened during the Suitcase Murders.

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

TRIGGER WARNING: THIS EPISODE CONTAINS DEPICTIONS OF SEXUAL VIOLENCE AND INCEST.

Episode eleven features the little-known case of family annihilator and spree killer Ronald Gene Simmons.

This story unfolds very slowly over the many decades that Ronald Gene Simmons tormented his poor wife Becky and their seven children.

Excessive alcoholism and mental instability soon drove Gene to the point of no return and he unleashed a 6-day terror spree on the small towns Dover and Russellville, Arkansas, resulting in the murders of sixteen innocent people.

Join Elizabeth & Harry as they narrate the disturbing and disgusting life of madman Ronald Gene Simmons.

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

WARNING: This episode contains depictions of extreme animal cruelty.

Episode nine of Deadly Ever After is the most recent case of the entire season.

On May 11th, 2021, a man named Babis Anagnostopoulo called the police from his home in the small city of Glyka Nera, Greece. He told them a violent gang had just invaded his home, robbed him and terrorized his family, including his infant daughter.

When investigators reached Babis’ home, they found his wife Caroline Crouch unresponsive and that escalated the crime from home invasion to murder.

Detectives worked tirelessly to find those responsible for the crime, combing over the events with Babis for hours and hours, until holes began to form in his story…

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

This week’s case is new for the hosts of Deadly Ever After !

Stacey Castor’s domestic troubles were well-known to neighbors and authorities in the small town of Weedsport in upstate New York.

In 1999, she garnered sympathy after being widowed by her husband Michael Wallace. In the aftermath of his suicide, she was left to raise two young children on her own. When Stacey remarried in 2003 to a man named David Castor, her friends, family and children were delighted at the thought that she’d found love again.

Tragically, death and misfortune would continue to plague the Castor family. Police struggled to nail down what was really happening behind closed doors in Weedsport and, little did they know, they’d soon be racing against the clock to prevent another murder from occurring…

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.