In this over-stuffed episode, Jamie (@BoyfriendJamie), Andrea (@afbusch), Kip (@myneighborhimbo), and Sarah (@bbyhag) discuss the two-parter "Welcome to Camp Nightmare," their love for the Twilight Baseball scene, and how many twists is too many before a story becomes incomprehensible. We also play our first official round of the catchily named "Goosebumps Book Titles Quiz."