EvaluLand
Download on the App Store

EvaluLand episodes

  • 11: Eval20 Virtual Experience - Pre-Conference Reflections

    Thank you to everyone who participated in the call-in to share their own reflections about the 2020 AEA virtual experience! After the conference, please sure your own thoughts and reflections by calling in. It's very similar to leaving a voicemail!

    In this episode, I start with my own reflection about the conference, how I'm going to make the most of the conference, and what I am personally excited about. Then, we get to hear from nine other evaluators (in no particular order):

    1. Tom Archibald, associate professor at Virgina Tech (@tgarchibald)
    2. Bianca Montrosse-Moorhead, associate professor at University of Connecticut (@b_mmoorhead)
    3. Danielle Murillo, at the Claremont After School Program (@happyeval)
    4. Kathleen Doll, independent evaluation consultant (part-time at the Chan-Zuckerberg Initiative and part-time at Intention 2 Impact)
    5. Christian Lucchesi, project manager with Catalyst at University of Wisconsin-Stout (@luccheesey)
    6. Nina Sabarre, founder and principal of Intention 2 Impact (@ninasabarre)
    7. Akihiko Ashimoto, National Institute for Educational Policy Research in Japan
    8. Elizabeth Grim, director of community impact from the Connecticut Data Collaborative (@ecgrim)
    9. Libby Smith, evaluator and educator (@work_with_libby)
    10. Music by Matt Ingelson, http://www.mattingelsonmusic.com/

      Support EvaluLand

      41 min
    11. 10: Nonprofit Evaluation and Music with Chari Smith

      This week, Chari Smith joins me to talk about nonprofit evaluation, how to build a culture of evaluation, the relationship between music and evaluation, and the AEA conference.

      Chari Smith wrote a book! Nonprofit Program Evaluation Made Simple: Get your Data. Show your Impact. Improve your Programs. Sign up for the mailing list to learn more about the book, including the launch date.

      Resources & People Mentioned:
      • In 4 All blog post on adapting to Covid-19
      • Managing applied social research by Russ-eft and colleagues (2017)
      • Enhancing the effectiveness of logic models by Jones et al. (2020)
      • Northwest Housing Alternatives concept paper: Program Evaluation and Data Culture in Resident Services
      • Graphic mentioned - NW Housing Alternatives: Housing Stability Status: This graphic was created as a result of the evaluation planning session with Resident Service Coordinator staff. We wanted to visually depict where their program activities fell on a spectrum of residents that are at a high risk of losing housing to a low risk of losing housing. This graphic was included in their program evaluation plan.
      • Data into Dollars: The Intersection of Program Evaluation & Fundraising blog post
      • Chari's presidential strand session with AEA president Aimee White on Tuesday, October 27
      • New Directions for Evaluation: Organizational Capacity to Do and Use Evaluation
      • Two people mentioned: Michael Quinn Patton and Stephanie Evergreen
      • Contact:
        • Chari Smith: [email protected]
        • EvaluLand: Website & Twitter (@EvaluLand)
        • About Chari:

          Chari Smith believes evaluation should be accessible, practical and usable. She founded Evaluation into Action, located in Portland, Oregon, to help nonprofit professionals create realistic and meaningful program evaluation processes. She has taught several workshops helping nonprofit professionals understand the value and use of program evaluation. Her book comes out fall 2020: Nonprofit Program Evaluation Made Simple: Get Your Data. Show Your Impact. Improve Your Programs.

          Music by Matt Ingelson, http://www.mattingelsonmusic.com/

          Support EvaluLand

          1 hr 6 min
        • 9: R with David Keyes

          This week I am joined by David Keyes. We talked about R, why evaluators should learn R, tips for teaching courses, and more!

          Interested in getting started with R? Check out David's free course!

          Interested in learning how to do inferential statistics in R? Check our our new course!

          Resources:

          Blog posts

          • Dana's R journey
          • What is a tidyverse-centric approach?
          • How to make beautiful tables in R
          • How to make functions in R
          • How to evaluate R packages
          • Using Word reference documents with R Markdown to create custom reports
          • If you care about equity, use R
          • Other resources

            • Daniel Lakens' course Improving your statistical inference
            • My manuscript written entirely in R
            • Todoist
            • Savical and Calendly
            • Figma
            • QuickBooks
            • WordPress and SquareSpace
            • Evaluation Jobs
            • Teachable
            • Streamlabs
            • Some packages: tidyverse, beepr, praise, janitor, gt, gtsummary, lavaan, ggplot, rstatix, papaja

              Contact:
              • David Keyes: Twitter @dgkeyes and @RfortheRest and email [email protected]
              • EvaluLand: Website & Twitter (@EvaluLand)
              • About David:

                David Keyes is the founder of R for the Rest of Us. Through online courses and custom trainings, he helps people and organizations learn R, the most powerful tool for data analysis and visualization (which also happens to be free).

                In addition to training folks to use R, David does consulting work with research and evaluation organizations, foundations, and others. David's creates high-quality data visualization, helps organizations to use R to improve their workflow, and much more.

                Music by Matt Ingelson, http://www.mattingelsonmusic.com/

                Support EvaluLand

                1 hr 6 min
              • 8: Solopreneurship with Ann K. Emery

                ThisThis week I am joined by Ann K. Emery about her journeys in evaluation and entrepreneurship. Ann K. Emery is an internationally-acclaimed speaker who equips organizations to get their data out of dusty spreadsheets and into real-world conversations. She now runs Depict Data Studio.

                If you’d rather watch this talk, you can do so on YouTube here.

                Topics & Resources Mentioned:
                • #EvalTwitter hashtag on Twitter (also follow #eval and #dataviz)
                • Company of One by Paul Jarvis
                • Nina Sabarre presentation on getting into independent consulting
                • Independent consulting vs. entrepreneurship
                • Teaching (and blogging and YouTube-ing) as a way to give back to the community
                • Multiple references to Chris Lysy
                • Your Money or Your Life by Vicki Robin
                • All the books by Octavia Butler, and the podcast on her parables by Adrienne maree brown & Toshi Reagon with Kat Aaron
                • Rethinking consulting from a mindset of abundance, not scarcity
                • Farnoosh Torabi on Instagram
                • 99 Tips for Creating Simple and Sustainable Educational Videos by Karen Costa
                • Soar Beyond the Dusty Shelf Report course
                • Contact:
                  • Ann K. Emery: Instagram and Website
                  • EvaluLand: Website & Twitter (@EvaluLand)
                  • About Ann:

                    Ann K. Emery is an internationally-acclaimed speaker who equips organizations to get their data out of dusty spreadsheets and into real-world conversations.

                    Each year, she delivers over 50 keynotes, workshops, and webinars with the aim of equipping organizations to visualize data more effectively.

                    She has been invited to speak in more than 30 states and 10 countries; more than 3,200 people have enrolled in her online training academy; and she has consulted to more than 150 organizations, including the United Nations, Centers for Disease Control, and Harvard University.

                    She earned a Bachelor’s degree from the University of Virginia and a Master’s degree from George Mason University.

                    Ann resides in Florida along with her husband and two daughters.

                    Music by Matt Ingelson, http://www.mattingelsonmusic.com/

                    Support EvaluLand

                    1 hr 5 min
                  • 7: Trust and Numbers with Anjie Rosga

                    This week, we’re chatting with AnnJanette, or Anjie, Rosga about objectivity, trust and numbers, truth and power, and more.

                    AnnJanette (Anjie) Rosga, PhD, co-directs the small, Berkeley-based consulting firm Informing Change which works to support strategic learning initiatives in the social sector. Most of Anjie’s projects involve facilitating strategy development, promoting equity and participatory research, and leading evaluation for hard-to-measure initiatives that cross disciplines, sectors, geographies, and/or cultures.

                    This episode centers around Anjie's 3-part Medium series on Trust & Numbers. Read the 3-part series here: Part 1, Part 2, and Part 3

                    Some resources, quotes, etc. mentioned:
                    • Power as electricity metaphor - Understanding "New Power" by Jeremy Heimans and Henry Timms
                    • Rethinking objectivity by Allan Megill
                    • Mariana Valverde: Truth as a "pragmatic ethical choice" (In Law's Dream of a Common Knowledge, page 10)
                    • Decolonizing Wealth by Edgar Villanueva
                    • Level Up: Growing Your Approach to Participatory Evaluation (AEA365) by Elizabeth DiLuzio
                    • Grace Jones in I'll Never Write My Memoirs: "If you are a fan of doing the unexpected, and I am, then it is an advantage to be highly skilled at changing your mind. If you do not want to limit yourself, then be prepared to change your mind—often."
                    • Cultivating trust on Twitter - NYT Daily Podcast
                    • Contact:
                      • Anjie Rosga: Contact her through the Informing Change website
                      • EvaluLand: Website & Twitter (@EvaluLand)
                      • About Anjie:

                        AnnJanette (Anjie) Rosga, co-directs the small, Berkeley-based consulting firm Informing Change which foregrounds strategic learning for equity, participatory research, and complex systems change. Most of Anjie’s projects involve facilitating strategy development and leading evaluation for hard-to-measure initiatives that cross disciplines, sectors, geographies, and/or cultures. In her prior professional lives, she worked as an independent consultant to human rights NGOs and United Nations agencies, as an advocate for international women, peace & security, and as an academic: first at Knox College in Illinois, and later the University of Colorado, Boulder. Her independent research began with an ethnography of anti-hate crime groups and the police in the US and later evolved into a multinational study of human rights training for police in emerging democracies. She holds a PhD in the History of Consciousness, an interdisciplinary program combining humanities and social sciences. She grew up in Minneapolis, MN, and Louisville, KY and makes her home in Oakland, CA.

                        Music by Matt Ingelson, http://www.mattingelsonmusic.com/

                        Support EvaluLand

                        1 hr 6 min
                      • 6: Research Roundup

                        This week I discuss some of the latest Research on Evaluation (RoE) articles that have come out in 2020.

                        Articles Mentioned:
                        • At the beginning I mention the RoE TIG’s definition of RoE, which is summarized here.
                        • Evaluation Journal of Australasia – Special Issue on Values in Evaluation
                          • Vol 19, Issue 4: Guest Editors: Keryn Hassall, Kelly Hannum, Amy Gullickson and Mathea Roorda
                          • Vol 20, Issue 2: Guest Editors: Ayesha S Boyce, Amy M Gullickson, Keryn Hassall and Kelly Hannum
                          • New Directions for Evaluation Volume 2020, Issue 166 - Examining issues facing communities of color today: The role of evaluation to incite change: Issue Editors: Leah C. Neubauer Dominica McBride Andrea D. Guajardo Wanda D. Casillas Melvin E. Hall
                            • Neubauer, McBride, Guajardo, Casillas, & Hall (2020) Examining issues facing communities of color today: The role of evaluation to incite change
                            • Hall (2020) Blest be the tie that binds
                            • Reid, Boyce, Adetogun, Moller, & Avent (2020) If not us, then who? Evaluators of color and social change
                            • Ghanbarpour, Mercado, & Palotai (2020) A language justice framework for culturally responsive and equitable evaluation
                            • Dhaliwal, Casey, Aceves-Iniguez, & Dean-Coffey (2020) Radical inquiry—liberatory praxis for research and evaluation
                            • Guajardo, Robles-Schrader, Aponte-Soto, & Neubauer (2020) LatCrit theory as a framework for social justice evaluation: Considerations for evaluation and evaluators
                            • Moss & Crewe (2020) The Black perspective: A framework for culturally competent health related evaluations for African Americans
                            • Lemos & Garcia (2020) Promoting culturally responsive and equitable evaluation with Latinx immigrants
                            • Bowman (2020) Nation-to-nation in evaluation: Utilizing an indigenous evaluation model to frame systems and government evaluations
                            • McBride, Casilla, & LoPiccolo (2020) Inciting social change through evaluation
                            • Neubauer & Hall (2020) Is inciting social change something evaluators can do? Should do?
                            • Lemire, Peck, & Porowski (2020) The growth of the evaluation tree in the policy analysis forest
                            • Hurteau, Rahmanian, Houle, & Marchand (2020) The role of intuition in evaluative judgment and decision
                            • Brown & Di Lallo (2020) Talking circles: A culturally responsive evaluation practice
                            • MERL Tech State of the Field Series
                            • Engage R&D (2020) Listening for change: Evaluators of color speak out about experiences with foundations and evaluation firms
                            • Contact:

                              EvaluLand: Website & Twitter (@EvaluLand)

                              Music by Matt Ingelson, http://www.mattingelsonmusic.com/

                              Support EvaluLand

                              51 min
                            • 5: MS in Applied Psychology - Evaluation Reflections

                              “If you are someone who is interested in bringing change, or making the world a better place, or if you would like the results of your work to get used, evaluation is something that you might be interested in.”

                              This episode is a bit different. I asked three of my students to reflect on their experiences in the MS in Applied Psychology program at University of Wisconsin-Stout, as well as their experiences in the two evaluation courses. Emma, Omar, and Jade share their thoughts and reflections.

                              Click here to learn more about the MS in Applied Psychology program.

                              If you have feedback about this episode, any previous episode, or the podcast in general, please email me at [email protected] or go to our website https://evaluland.fireside.fm.

                              About the guests:

                              Emma Frenn: My name is Emma Frenn, I am 24 years old and I am originally from Milwaukee Wisconsin (go bucks!) and moved to Eau Claire Wisconsin for my undergrad career. I graduated with a major in a psychology and minor in biology. I currently attend UW-Stout graduate program Applied Psychology. I am the youngest of six and as of recent I picked up on rollerblading as a fun hobby.

                              Jade: Jade is a student a UW Stout who is majoring in evaluation and I/O psych. She has a passion for creating surveys and reports, and enjoys learning new things from her peers and professors.

                              Omar Albaraidi: Omar is an M.S. in Applied Psychology graduate student with a primary concentration in Industrial & Organizational Psychology. He is interested in bringing psychology to the workplace to stimulate organizational growth, overcome obstacles, and make data-driven decisions.

                              Music by Matt Ingelson, http://www.mattingelsonmusic.com/

                              Support EvaluLand

                              26 min
                            • 4: Teaching Evaluation and Supporting Students and Colleagues of Color with Ayesha Boyce

                              This week I am joined by Dr. Ayesha Boyce, assistant professor of educational research methodology at the University of North Carolina at Greensboro, to discuss teaching evaluation and supporting students and colleagues of color.

                              Topics Covered:
                              • Reflections on five years of teaching evaluation
                              • The -ologies: ontology, epistemology, and axiology beyond just methodology
                              • Favorite evaluation activity (of course, it’s the evaluating the cookie activity!)
                              • Mentoring students of color. Five keys from Ayesha (see upcoming CJPE article):
                                1. Consider impact of vicarious trauma
                                2. Assist with facilitation peer mentors/squads
                                3. Respect, honor, and celebrate students’ culture, religion, and family
                                4. Be vigilant of microaggressions, and practice microvalidation
                                5. Develop mentoring competence
                                6. Supporting colleagues of color: helpful actions, silence as complicity, listening in, getting comfortable being uncomfortable
                                7. Approaching institutional leaders about actions for supporting students, faculty, and staff of color
                                8. Speaking out on the tenure track
                                9. Having a family and being exceptional at work simultaneously (Ayesha encourages us all that it IS possible!)
                                10. Resources mentioned:
                                  • Boyce & McGowan (2018) article “An exploration of two novice evaluation educators’ experiences developing and implementing introduction to evaluation courses”
                                  • Evaluating the cookie activity in Preskill & Russ-Eft’s Building Evaluation Capacity book
                                  • Upcoming issue in CJPE on evaluator education
                                  • Ibram X. Kendi
                                  • Letter from Dr. Boyce and students and faculty of color to their department
                                  • Letter from Dr. Boyce and other black UNCG faculty
                                  • NDE upcoming issue on evaluator education
                                  • Contact:
                                    • Ayesha Boyce: Twitter @AyeshaBoyce and [email protected]
                                    • EvaluLand: Website & Twitter (@EvaluLand)
                                    • About Dr. Boyce:

                                      Dr. Ayesha S. Boyce is an assistant professor of Educational Research Methodology at UNC Greensboro. She is a program evaluation teacher, scholar, and practitioner. Before pursuing her Ph.D., she was an education research associate (evaluator) for the Arizona Department of Education. She is the Co-Director of the UNCG Office of Assessment, Evaluation, and Research Services (OAERS). Her research focuses on attending to value stances and issues related to diversity, equity, inclusion, access, cultural responsiveness, and social justice within evaluation—especially multi-site, STEM, and contexts with historically marginalized populations. She also examines teaching, mentoring, and learning in evaluation. She has evaluated over 40 programs funded by the National Science Foundation (NSF), US Department of Education, National Institutes of Health, and Spencer and Teagle foundations. She is currently the external evaluator for five NSF funded projects and a Co-Principal Investigator on four NSF funded projects. She is a Co-PI on the recently funded 1 million-dollar NSF grant, Spartans ADVANCE: Adaptations of Practices For Faculty Equity, Diversity, and Inclusion at The UNCG. Dr. Boyce is a co-chair of the American Evaluation Association Multiethnic Issues in Evaluation Topic Interest Group, a member of the editorial board for the Canadian Journal of Program Evaluation and teaches classes in program evaluation and research methodology where she emphasizes good practice with mindful attentiveness to theoretical roots. She encourages students to develop a strong methodological foundation, conduct studies based on democratic principles, and promote equity, fairness, inclusivity, and diversity. She is a 2019 UNCG School of Education Distinguished Research Scholar Award recipient and a 2019 American Evaluation Association Marcia Guttentag Promising New Evaluator Awardee.

                                      Music by Matt Ingelson, http://www.mattingelsonmusic.com/

                                      Support EvaluLand

                                      47 min
                                    • 3: Evaluation Education and Data Cleaning with Jennifer Ann Morrow

                                      This week I am joined by Dr. Jennifer Ann Morrow, the program coordinator of the Evaluation Statistics and Measurement doctoral program (soon to be named "Evaluation Statistics and Methodology) at the University of Tennessee-Knoxville. We talked about teaching evaluation and data cleaning in evaluation.

                                      Topics Covered:
                                      • Jennifer’s background, philosophy, and experience in teaching evaluation (01:58)
                                      • Our favorite evaluation activities: evaluating cookies, one-pages on hot topics and people in evaluation, evaluation failures, self-reflection journals, practical experience outside of class (11:33)
                                      • Personal professional development in data visualization and R (32:00)
                                      • What’s giving Jennifer life in evaluation right now (38:40)
                                      • Data cleaning book proposal by Jennifer and Gary Skolits (44:13)
                                      • What’s next for Jennifer (50:55)
                                      • Resources mentioned:
                                        • Preskill & Russ-Eft (2015) Building Evaluation Capacity: Activities for Teaching and Training
                                        • Wanzer (2020) What is evaluation paper (preprint)
                                        • Hutchinson (2018) Evaluation Failures: 22 Tales of Mistakes Made and Lessons Learned
                                        • Jennifer’s student’s blog on user experience for Ann K. Emery
                                        • Great Graphs with Ann K. Emery](https://depictdatastudio.com/)
                                        • R for the Rest of Us with David Keyes](https://rfortherestofus.com/)
                                        • Amy Cesal Play-Doh data visualization activity
                                        • Bianca Montrosse-Moorhead’s research on what ought to be included in the curriculum for master’s and doctoral eval programs
                                        • Jennifer’s handout on the 12 steps to data cleaning](http://comm.eval.org/qual/viewdocument/cbd146-a-brief-intr-1)
                                        • Contact:
                                          • Jennifer Ann Morrow: @evaluationdiva on Twitter and [email protected]
                                          • EvaluLand: Website & Twitter (@EvaluLand)
                                          • About Jennifer:

                                            Dr. Jennifer Ann Morrow is currently the program coordinator of the Evaluation Statistics and Measurement doctoral program at the University of Tennessee-Knoxville. Her main areas of research are higher education assessment and evaluation and effective strategies for teaching methodology. She has been teaching evaluation and methodology courses for the past 22 years. She is passionate about evaluation and assessment and regularly tweets on these topics (@evaluationdiva). In her spare time she loves to travel and explore the beautiful towns and mountains of Tennessee.

                                            Music by Matt Ingelson, http://www.mattingelsonmusic.com/

                                            Support EvaluLand

                                            56 min
                                          • 2: Meta-Evaluation, Research on Evaluation, & Evaluation Theory with Zach Tilton

                                            This week I am joined by Zach Tilton, a Doctoral Research Associate at the Interdisciplinary PhD in Evaluation Program at Western Michigan University. We discussed research on evaluation and meta-evaluation.

                                            Topics Covered:
                                            • How Zach got into evaluation and at Western Michigan University (01:12)
                                            • What peacebuilding evaluation is (03:52)
                                            • Evaluation specialists vs generalists (05:45)
                                            • Research on evaluation and meta-evaluation (09:50)
                                            • Prescriptive vs descriptive theories (22:35)
                                            • Evaluation theory (25:00)
                                            • Zach’s dissertation: RoE on peacebuilding evaluation (35:50)
                                            • Adjusting to life amidst Covid-19 (40:10)
                                            • What’s next for Zach (46:00)
                                            • What’s giving life for Zach (50:55)
                                            • Resources mentioned:
                                              • Western Michigan University Interdisciplinary PhD in Evaluation, including Michael Harnar and Chris Coryn
                                              • EPP article on knowledge syntheses
                                              • AEA Research on Evaluation TIG
                                              • Blog describing working group’s updated RoE definition
                                              • Weaver & Cousins article on participatory evaluation
                                              • AEA Integrating Technology into Evaluation TIG
                                              • MERL Tech conference
                                              • Everyday Peace Indicators
                                              • Digital Impact Alliance
                                              • Evaluation Practice Reconsidered by Thomas Schwandt
                                              • EvalCentral Unwebinars, Blogs, and Discussion Forum
                                              • Equitable Evaluation Initiative
                                              • Eval4Action Campaign
                                              • Black youth-led movements: Black Visions Collective Reclaim the Block, The Twin Cities Coalition for Justice for Jamar, and Minnesota Freedom Fund
                                              • Contact:
                                                • Zach Tilton: @ZachTilton on Twitter and [email protected]
                                                • EvaluLand: Website & Twitter (@EvaluLand)
                                                • About Zach:

                                                  Zach Tilton is a Doctoral Research Associate at the Interdisciplinary PhD in Evaluation Program at Western Michigan University where he is setting and pursuing an agenda for research on peacebuilding evaluation. He holds a BS in Peacebuilding and Business Management from Brigham Young University-Hawaii and an MA in Peace Studies from the University of Bradford. Along with peacebuilding evaluation, he researches technology-enabled evaluation, meta-evaluation, and participatory and collaborative evaluation. He is a Returned Peace Corps Volunteer, a Rotary Peace Fellow, an Institute for Economics and Peace Ambassador, and has worked as an evaluation practitioner for various international peacebuilding organizations. He is also currently an Evaluation Consultant for the Digital Impact Alliance at the United Nations Foundation, an Associate at Everyday Peace Indicators, and the Co-chair for the Topical Interest Group for Integrating Technology into Evaluation and the EvalYouth representative to the American Evaluation Association.

                                                  Music by Matt Ingelson, http://www.mattingelsonmusic.com/

                                                  Support EvaluLand

                                                  56 min

                                                About EvaluLand

                                                From the publisher's feed

                                                This podcast discusses the landscape of evaluation. Each episode will feature a guest in or around evaluation to discuss something evaluation-related. Email me at [email protected] if you have…