Evan & Tiki

Boomer & Gio on the Knicks’ win over the Celtics and if there’s anything to take away from it heading into the postseason. Plus, Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber, and Shaun Morash discuss expectations from Knicks fans this postseason (14:16), and whether or not the Knicks face an NBA Finals or bust kind of pressure (28:35); Craig Carton looks ahead to the likely Knicks playoff seeding and schedule (41:03).

The Yankee offense has looked lifeless for much of the season, and Craig Carton sounded off on how "unwatchable" the lineup has been. The Evan and Tiki crew debate what the team should do about Ryan McMahon, and Shaun Morash has a hysterical story about meeting David Wells at a bar. Mike Vaccaro of the New York Post joins the midday show to discuss his new book on the Steinbrenner family.

The Mets moved up two of their start times, and Steve Cohen made it known via social media that he was not happy with the attendance. Craig Carton says the Mets owner is losing a fanbase that he seems to "hate," while Evan Roberts sounded off on the fans that accepted free tickets and didn't show up. Plus, will Juan Soto's calf injury carry lingering concerns related to a potential future Achilles injury?

From 'Rico Brogna' (subscribe here): The 7th inning Nolan McLean started to work into some trouble. How did you feel Carlos Mendoza handled the situation? Evan gives you his thoughts.

To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Evan and Sean examine the New York Knicks' statistical improvement and the late-season chemistry between Jalen Brunson and Karl-Anthony Towns. They also review iconic calls by Mike Breen and Ian Eagle before debating the logic of 'cold degree weather' during a recent local doubleheader.

02:10 - Knicks Statistical Improvement

06:58 - Shaq on Baylor Scheierman

11:06 - Mike Brown Coaching Genius

16:15 - Breen vs Eagle Battle

21:10 - Jayson Tatum Return Controversy

26:45 - Knicks Championship Window

31:55 - Doubleheaders and Draft Talk

41:30 - Cold Degree Weather Debate

46:30 - Yankee Turning Point Analysis

What starts as a debate about leaving a no-hitter early turns into a full hour of passionate, hilarious, and deeply relatable sports talk. The guys dive into the unwritten rules of fandom, questioning whether witnessing history matters more than loyalty to your team, and whether any excuse is good enough to walk out before the final out.

The conversation expands into unforgettable personal stories, near misses with historic moments, and the emotional ties that shape how fans experience the game. From parenting through sports moments to arguing about rivalries, dating, and lifelong allegiances, this episode captures the intensity, absurdity, and heart that come with being a true sports fan.

A heated conversation breaks out over the Knicks playoff positioning and whether dropping to the four seed could actually be the smarter path. The discussion dives into competing perspectives, media narratives, and the reality of how matchups could shape the postseason outlook in the East.

The episode also features a bizarre and uncomfortable Karl-Anthony Towns interview moment that sparks debate, plus a deep dive into emerging Mets and Yankees pitching comparisons and the nature of New York sports rivalries. From strategy debates to classic fan arguments, the show captures the passion and unpredictability that define the city’s sports scene.

A packed Friday show dives into the Knicks’ emotional win over the Celtics and the heated reaction that followed, including the “act like you’ve been there” debate. The hosts break down whether New York’s celebration was justified and what it says about the team’s mindset as the playoffs approach, while also touching on early-season Yankees and Mets storylines.

The conversation shifts to Citi Field, where Jeff McNeil’s return stirs up strong opinions among Mets fans. Should he be welcomed back or booed after an up-and-down tenure? Plus, wild fan stories, wrestling debates, quirky baseball rule hypotheticals, and another hilarious round of “Idiots with Idioms” round out a chaotic and entertaining episode.

Full Show: The Knicks take down the Celtics as they rare into playoff form, whether you should leave a possible no-hitter early, the Mets struggles continue, debating the Mets and Yankees aces, the Yankees offense remains stagnant, and much more.

The final stretch of the show zeroes in on the Knicks’ emotional win over the Celtics and the backlash that followed, as the hosts push back on the idea that New York celebrated too much. They break down the double standard from Boston fans, the meaning of regular season wins versus playoff expectations, and why emotion in big moments shouldn’t be criticized.

From there, the energy shifts into classic show chaos with listener calls, sharp sports takes, and a hilarious edition of “Idiots with Idioms.” The segment delivers nonstop laughs with bizarre phrases, accidental innuendos, and unforgettable one-liners that cap off a wild and entertaining end to the week.