Evan & Tiki

The conversation shifts to what Geno Smith actually means for the Jets moving forward. Evan and Tiki break down whether Geno can truly raise the floor for a franchise that desperately needs stability at quarterback, and why the Jets may be more focused on positioning themselves for the future than chasing a Super Bowl right now. The guys react to calls from fans, debate the importance of offensive line play, and discuss whether the national media is unfairly mocking the Jets for the move. Plus, a look at how Geno’s role could impact the Jets’ draft strategy and whether a rookie quarterback is still very much in play.

Evan and Tiki react to the stunning news that Geno Smith is returning to the New York Jets. Is this the right move for a franchise desperate to stabilize the quarterback position, or are the Jets settling for a short-term solution with no real future? The guys debate whether Geno is simply a bridge to the next quarterback, why some fans hate the move, and what the Jets’ long-term plan might actually be. Plus, the emotional side of a full-circle reunion in New York and whether fans can separate Geno’s past with the team from the player he is today.

From 'Rico Brogna' (subscribe here): Evan can't get David Stearns to go on record... because he was having his Spring Training press conference on Monday!!! So, Evan does what he does on the Rico and breaks down everything he says! Let's have some fun.

To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

The Giants bring back heir right tackle, the Jets still don't have a QB, and Aaron Judge wanted Bryce Harper as a Yankee

Evan and Tiki react to a busy Giants offseason stretch as Isaiah Likely, Jordan Stout, Tremaine Edmunds, Jermaine Eluemunor, and Greg Newsome all enter the mix. They break down why the Giants look improved, where the roster still needs work, and why the cornerback room is still a concern.

The Jeremiyah Love debate also takes center stage as Evan pushes the idea of the Giants taking the star running back with the 5th pick, while Shaun Morash wants absolutely no part of it. Plus, the guys dive into the Jets’ defensive additions, the mounting tension over their quarterback plan, a surprise earthquake discussion, Knicks frustration after another rough loss, and a fun Wilt vs. SGA conversation to close the hour.

Evan and Tiki start with a quick reaction to a small earthquake in Westchester before jumping into the Jets’ quarterback uncertainty as fans brace for whatever move comes next. From Geno Smith to Kyler Murray and other possibilities, the panic around the position is very real.

The guys also react to Alijah Vera-Tucker landing with the Patriots and what it says about the Jets’ situation, while callers weigh in on the team’s direction and the Giants’ possible draft plans. Plus, another edition of Posted and Toasted brings back some old takes from the internet, and Evan shares a hilarious and awkward spring training encounter with former Mets owner Fred Wilpon that somehow involved a half-eaten sandwich.

Evan and Tiki react to the heated World Baseball Classic moment between Randy Arozarena and Cal Raleigh and debate whether the postgame comments were real or a WWE-style work. The guys also discuss Aaron Judge, Juan Soto’s WBC comments, and how the tournament atmosphere compares to MLB. Plus, Shaun Morash returns with his Cinco de Luncho ranking the NFL players who will look the most different in their new uniforms as free agency reshapes the league.

The final hour of Evan & Tiki is packed with NFL quarterback debates, a massive Yankees “what if,” and heated World Baseball Classic drama.

The show starts with Evan’s deep dive into rare NFL history — trying to find examples of teams with two left-handed quarterbacks in the same room, including the Boomer Esiason era in Cincinnati and legendary lefty Ken Stabler.

Shaun Morash returns with a new Cinco de Luncho, counting down the players who will look the most surprising in their new uniforms. Evan and Tiki react to the list, debate how much uniform changes really matter in football, and dive into a left-handed quarterback rabbit hole. The hour wraps with more Jets talk, Daniel Jones speculation, and a hilarious on-air debate over a stolen show idea.

Evan and Tiki break down a surprising World Baseball Classic moment after Randy Arozarena blasted Team USA catcher Cal Raleigh following an awkward on-field interaction. Was it a real feud or just showmanship? The guys debate whether the tension is legit, how teammates can clash during international play, and what it would look like if something similar happened between New York stars. Plus, the conversation shifts to Aaron Judge and whether fans are reading too much into his emotions while playing for Team USA.